Buffett Is Right About What Being Rich Is, Wrong About Tax Increases


The fiscal cliff negotiations may be the main event in Washington right now, but the sideshows are where all the action is — specifically, the debate over proposed tax increases, which looks like it's set to be the most bruising. On one hand, there's the President who is proposing that the current tax rates stay put (except for the rich), with the so-called "Bush tax cuts" being extended for households earning up to $250,000 a year. On the other hand, the White House's stance on the need for upper-income tax increases is unchanged; their notion of "rich" is now being challenged by none other than Warren Buffett.

In an op-ed in The New York Times today entitled "A Minimum Tax For the Wealthy," the Omaha billionaire writes that while he supports President Obama's proposal to eliminate the Bush tax cuts for high-income taxpayers, he prefers a higher cut-off point, "maybe $500,000 or so." At the same time, as my co-host Jeff Macke and I discuss in the attached video, Buffett argues that prior periods of high tax rates — whether on income, capital gains or dividends — had no negative effect on his accumulation of wealth or that of the nation, which he says saw GDP and jobs rise sharply during the post-war boom.

In addition to raising the threshold on the rich for the Bush tax cuts, Buffett also calls for minimum tax rates of 30% and 35% to be set on what I call the "Really Rich" and the "Super Rich" — which the 82-year old chairman of Berkshire Hathaway (BRK) pegs at $1 to $10 million and $10 million plus, respectively.

"The fact is, that debate needs to be elevated," Macke says of the current "What is rich?" discussion, adding that "a million dollars is where you start getting rich."

Implicit in all of this income targeting and wealth labeling are two keys facts: fairness and recession. In the case of the former, it is a known fact that over the past generation the rich have gotten richer and today control a larger slice of the nation's income and total wealth. However, on the latter point, the reluctance to raise tax rates on the masses is also couched in the reality that the economy is still too fragile and it would likely trigger a recession next year. The same thinking also applies to Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke's commitment to keep interest rates low, since the economy just can't handle any headwinds.

Finally, in spite of recent reports inferring that a growing number of Republicans are warming up to the idea of higher taxes, The Wall Street Journal counters that idea in a sweeping discussion with Grover Norquist, who heads up the influential Americans for Tax Reform committee that wields signed anti-tax increase pledges over the heads of almost all elected Republicans. Contrary to the conventional wisdom that Republicans have no choice but to fold and raise taxes, Norquist argues otherwise.

Even here it seems that Buffett and Norquist are in agreement that tax increases alone will do little to close the gap between revenues and spending in Washington nor will it help to tackle the nation's long-term debt of $16 trillion and counting. In fact, Buffett concedes that even if his aggressive GDP-linked targets on taxes and spending (18.5% and 21% respectively) were hit, it would not "stem our budget deficits; in fact, it will continue them."

Of course, no one knows how the fiscal cliff talks will ultimately play out in the coming weeks, but it is clear that the pressure will mount and the drama will build as the clock ticks down. The debate is set to continue even if the cliff is avoided, given that regardless of which course of tax increases and spending cuts lawmakers agree on, the country may be headed toward recession again.


View Comments (490)

Recommended for You

  • The point where you might want to buy Tesla

    This has been a great year for Tesla. For founder Elon Musk, that means his shares have lost over $1 billion in value since the start of this month. Musk’s 28.3 million Tesla shares mean he still has $7 billion worth of shares.

    Talking Numbers
  • 1 Tip To Lose Belly Fat

    It's Hollywood's Hottest Diet And Gets Rid Of Stubborn Fat Areas Like Nothing Else.

  • Wall Street thinks Yahoo is worth less than nothing

    The Alibaba (BABA) IPO made financial history as the largest public offering ever. In the shadow of that news is Yahoo (YHOO), the old-time Internet "portal," which held a bundle of Alibaba stock and made billions. Not so long ago, investors thought that Yahoo was essentially worthless, trading at…

    CBS News from RSS
  • SHOE COMPANY: Our Ex-CEO Who Disappeared With All Our Money Called Us Over The Weekend, And Said He's Coming Back

    The missing CEO of show company Ultrasonic — who last week disappeared with the company's money   — says he's going to give it back. In a press release on Monday, Ultrasonic CFO Clifford Chan said  Qingyong Wu, the company's former CEO who was dismissed at a board meeting late last week, called him…

    Business Insider
  • Washington DC Could Light Up the Debate on Legalized Cannabis

    Whitefish, MT / September 23, 2014 / Washington DC voters appear overwhelming ready to legalize recreational cannabis, based on a recent poll sponsored by NBC4, Washington Post, and Marist. The poll found that 65% of respondents supported Ballot Initiative

  • The Kawasaki Ninja H2 - Understanding the Hype

    Here's what we know for certain about the Kawasaki Ninja H2: it will be officially unveiled next month at the INTERMOT bike show in Cologne, Germany… that's about it.  Is the Ninja H2 the most-hyped motorcycle in recent memory? The answer is debatable - the cruiser world certainly heard the…
  • When the Dealership Steals Back the Car They Just Sold You

    You bought a car and a couple days later the dealership comes by in the middle of the night and steals it back from you. JT went to a car dealer and found a late model used vehicle he liked. The salesman and the others involved in the deal kept coming and going from the desk where he was sitting,…

    Oppositelock from RSS
  • Silicon Valley talent wars: Engineers, come get your $250K salary

    In Silicon Valley, even the smallest team of talented engineers can hit the jackpot. Take Instagram, which entered into tech folklore when its 13 employees -- only half of whom were developers -- created a simple photo-sharing app that wound up getting bought by Facebook for a $1 billion in 2012.…

  • New Site Releases Everyone's Past Online!

    A new site has made it simple to find the truth out about anyone's Past online. It's as easy as typing in a Name and selecting a State!

    AdChoicesInstant CheckmateSponsored
  • Cramer: As stocks slide, should strategy shift?

    More than a few bulls spent the session battling an upset stomach as stocks tumbled for the third time in three days. Given the circumstances, Cramer says it's only logical to question whether your stocks have topped out for the year. Looking out to the horizon, Cramer says there are plenty of…

  • View

    A Look inside Alberta’s Oil Sand Industry (16 photos)

    In 1967 Suncor helped pioneer the commercial development of Canada's oil sands, one of the largest petroleum resource basins in the world.Canada's oil sands industry is shrugging off declining world oil prices as some of the world's highest-cost producers

    Yahoo Finance
  • How Ford Motor Company Is Growing in Europe

    Ford's Fiesta is its best-seller in Europe, and the latest version is finding new fans. The numbers have been terrible: Even while a dramatic turnaround was boosting profits in North America, Ford was losing a fortune in Europe. Ford's European division posted losses of $1.75 billion in 2012 and…

    Motley Fool
  • 4 Ways to Avoid Running Out of Money in Retirement

    Compared to the length of retirement, 15 minutes is no time at all. But that's all you need to learn the basics of developing a plan to make your savings last as long as you need them. Still, many investors don't take this time—putting their retirement

    Fisher Investments
  • Why Smart People Take Social Security Benefits Early

    Most self-described retirement experts will advise you to wait as long as possible before applying for Social Security benefits. The argument in favor of waiting goes something like this: By holding out until full retirement at age 66, if not longer, you increase the chances of maximizing your…

    The Motley Fool from RSS
  • RadioShack may not have enough power to recharge its business

    Not long ago, RadioShack Corp. launched an effort called “Fix it Here,” an in-house service repairing mobile devices such as your smartphone or tablet. “That was the original mission for what RadioShack was, to do things like repairs,” said Stephen Baker, an analyst with the NPD Group.

  • Best Womens Wrinkle Creams 2014

    Mom reveals simple wrinkle solution that has researchers very excited. Try this free solution today to look and feel years younger.

  • Play

    Hedge funds unhappy over Alibaba IPO: O'Leary

    Dissecting what caused the move to the downside in today's market close, with Shark Tank investor Kevin O'Leary; CNBC's Kate Kelly; Kenny Polcari, O'Neil Securities; and CNBC contributor Carol Roth.

    CNBC Videos
  • Jordan backs Arab Bank support after 'Hamas' verdict

    Jordan's central bank said Tuesday it still supports Jordan-based Arab Bank, found liable in a US court of supporting terrorism, saying it had been unable to defend itself adequately. A New York jury found the multinational lender liable Monday on 24 counts of supporting terrorism by transferring…

  • Transocean Fleet Update: 2014 Out-of-Service Time Higher

    Offshore drilling giant, Transocean Ltd. (RIG), has provided a fleet status report for the period commencing Aug 21, 2014 to date. The value of all the new deals and extensions in contracts, during the aforesaid time frame, is estimated at roughly

  • Chef Who Blamed Picky Customers for Shutter Says He's Tired of Trying to 'Satisfy Patrons'

    The San Francisco restaurant owner who blamed picky diners for the closure of his restaurant is defending his actions. The San Francisco chef that fired back at difficult customers last week with a very sassy sign is at it again. According to ABC7, James Chu — the owner and chef of SO Chinese…

  • Comcast to FCC: We already face enough competition, so let us buy TWC

    "Perhaps you should switch to another cable company… oh, that's right, we're the only one in town." Federal Communications Commission Chairman Tom Wheeler has made it clear he thinks there isn’t enough broadband competition in America, but Comcast is trying to convince the FCC that it faces enough…

    Ars Technica from RSS
  • Meet the Enemy of Retirement Security: Procrastination

    Young people have the world's most powerful investing tool at their disposal. Image source: Sakeeb Sabakka via Fotopedia. Last year, I signed up for a program called "Connections" through my alma mater . The program is designed to bring

    Motley Fool
  • AARP® Auto Insurance Program from The Hartford

    Age 50+? Responsible drivers deserve better protection. You Could Save $404* on Auto Insurance.

    AdChoicesThe HartfordSponsored
  • Russian assets firm on China data, newspaper report on sanctions

    MOSCOW, Sept 23 (Reuters) - Russian assets firmed on Tuesday, buoyed by positive economic data from China, a major market for Russia's raw materials, and by a report that the European Union might review sanctions imposed against Moscow over its role in