Wed, May 23, 2012, 1:02 AM EDT - U.S. Markets open in 8 hrs 28 mins

Crappy New Year! Stocks Will Fall 35% in 2012 Says Schoenberger

The flow of market forecasting is at its peak as we close out 2011 and look at the year ahead. Generally speaking, most outlooks fall safely within the bounds of existing consensus or conventional wisdom.

Reuters recently reported 2012 expectations showed an average anticipated return for the S&P 500 next year as a gain of about 7.5%, right smack in the middle of what you might call the cautiously optimistic camp.

It's rare to come across professionals who are willing to risk their reputation and make bold forecasts in public, which is why Todd Schoenberger of LandColt Trading caught our attention.

"We're predicting the S&P 500 will be down 20% by mid-year, and by the end of the year, we'll be down 35%," Schoenberger says in the attached video. "Buyer beware."

While many point to the upcoming election year and the typical bounce that comes with it, Schoenberger reminds us of 2008 and the 37% decline on the Dow Jones Industrial Average. So just as investors are beginning to see what might be light at the end of the tunnel, and consumer confidence has rebounded to a 6 month high, Schoenberger's bearishness seems out of sync.

"Here's the thing, the debt issue is poison, not just to the economy and national security around the globe, but to the stock market," he says. "Revenues are going to take a big hit next year."

He's also convinced that the U.S. will slide in to recession in 2012, pointing out that since 1948, anytime GDP has slipped below 2% the U.S. economy has always ended up in a recession. The number right now is at 1.6%.

Interestingly, Citigroup just published a forecast projecting 6 quarters of recession in Europe starting next year. This is part of the reason why Schoenberger is avoiding the same multi-national names that have been the favorites of 2011, including Macke-fave McDonald's (MCD) which he says gets 40% of its earnings from Europe.

"Guess what's happening in Europe?" he asks rhetorically. "A recession will have a big impact on a stock like McDonald's."

Instead, he's positioning himself defensively in stocks "that mimic the economy" such as Public Storage (PSA). "People are losing their homes but won't sell the family dining room set so they stick all their junk in a storage facility," he explains.

So-called dollar store discounters like Family Dollar (FDO) and Dollar General (DG) are also seen as timely beneficiaries. "This is a frugal world we live in," he says.

While outright shorting the market would seem to match such a gloomy outlook, Schoenberger is uncomfortable with the risk as well as the need to cover that short in the face of any rally.

"We're in big trouble," Schoenberger warns. "You have to be cautious going in to this market."

Breakout Asks

Do you think Facebook (FB) will end this year above or below its IPO price of $38 a share?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options
  • Yes, FB will recover
  • No, FB is too unstable
 
  • Ralph  •  Los Angeles, California  •  5 months ago
    Taxes will have to go up on all income at sometime. Now can you imagine not only income but payroll taxes as well. These people are not wrong, they're just early. Like Bill Gross at Pimco and Merideth Whitney on Munis. Its coming, what really surprises me is the stupidity in believing we can just keep going on like this.
  • chas  •  Springfield, Illinois  •  5 months ago
    The one thing I've learned from the time I started investing; don't believe anything in the media. They all have an agenda and are wrong 99% of the time. Do your own research and you'll be OK.
    • John 5 months ago
      maybe you will or maybe you won't be okay. But you would be responsible and accountable for the results unlike blindly following any published feature writer.
    • tonym 5 months ago
      Sound advice - regardless of direction.
    • anon 5 months ago
      well said. how many truly wise men are out there? there are madoffs and corzines and paulsons for sure. the ones who did well are seldom able to consistently perform, perhaps madoff figured that out and decided to fake it to maintain what is in reality probably impossible to maintain---the illusion of getting it right most times. i've also learned that chasing the latest hot fund or hot manager---the top 10 or 100 or whatever touted by Money, SmartMoney, Kiplinger, etc---seldom led to "great finds" as the hot fund or manager fizzled out subsequently. now, mostly, like you, chas, we do own our research and we form our own opinions and yup, john, there've been some iffy calls there but we own our results.
  • tom  •  Chester, Virginia  •  4 months ago
    A year ago "up 15% in 2011" was being touted....When will people wake up and realize there children are screwed?!.
    • Bob 4 months ago
      Can`t speak for anyone else but I`ve already explained to my Six Year Old Son and His Brother who is Thirteen that when they are of age to start College, Trade School, or Military Service whichever they choose, that The Real World has Turned into a Tough Cut Throat, Super Competative Amoral Place. I explained that they will have to for the most part fend for themselves. I no longer have the money to pay for or even help pay for their education. They will have NONE of the Cushion I had back in the 70s. Our 401K are depleted, our Savings almost gone, My wifes Awfull Job is our only income We`ll lose our Home within the next Six to Eight Months.We have Zero Health Insurance, nor life insurance, I was turned down for SSDI, Guess I needed to be missing Limbs or Something.Things look bleak. However things always llook Darkest before Dawn, I have Hope That my Children and All of Our Children here in America will be quicker than We Were in Figuring out That our Government Sold us out. I hope that they are not lulled to sleep like we were waiting and hoping against hope that this President was going to be Different and the New Congress and Senate would be Patriots instead of the usual Amoral Thieves, that they would fix the Damage and correct the Mistakes of their Predecesors and we could all hold our Heads Up High Again, all would be well. Sadly we didn`t realize until after the fact that The Damage Done was done as part of a plan and that the Terrible Mistakes that has put 90% of Americans in Dire Straights were not Mistakes but part of the same plan That has Removed the Jobs, the Hope and the once abundant opportunities. Those Jobs havre been Replaced with $8.00 an hour no benefit dead end trash jobs, Hope is gradually turning toward Hopelesness, and the once abundant opportinities are a thing of the Past. The final Nail in our Coffin was my Wifes Student loan. The #$%$ overpriced little AA degree saddled us with close to 30,000 Dollars worth of debt and didn`t increase her marketability one red cent. It is exactly that $300.00 a month payment that will cost our Children their Home.I am bitter about None of the Above WITH the EXCEPTION of that Student Loan. It was a Total Scam, and I was the one Pushing her to sign up for it, but I washed my hands of it and never read the Loan Docs she was Signing because I figured how much could it possibly cost to get an AA degree via the internet. Had I paid attention I would have said HELL NO.
    • Larry 4 months ago
      Hey Bob, you wanna go get a beer? You make my life look like a cake walk. I feel so much better now.
  • Flush Washington  •  Cincinnati, Ohio  •  4 months ago
    I have seen no evidence that suggests the Central Banks won't simply keep printing money to meet the debt requirements. The market will stay inflated through the election.....this prediction makes more sense to me in 2013.
  • Retired  •  4 months ago
    Nobody, including Schoenberger, can predict the future.
    • Fielding 4 months ago
      Ya think? What is the point of writing something that obvious?
    • Armin 4 months ago
      I think Schoenberger is correct in his prediction. I use the same crytal ball and ouija board that Schoenberber uses and get the same results. for futher financial advice, call psycic hot line @ 1 900 Your #$%$ because they also have the answer.
  • Steve  •  5 months ago
    Any time I see baleful predictions like this, I wonder, "what he is short?"
  • raymond  •  Klamath Falls, Oregon  •  5 months ago
    How can the stock market lose when the govt and the Fed are dropping in trillions of dollars of borrowed money into the economy? The economy will blow up one day because of all this debt, not if but when.
    • Chris 4 months ago
      We had a greater debt load after WWII than we have today and yet 1945-1952 were just fine for the stock market.
      1952 18.35
      1951 23.10
      1950 34.28
      1949 15.96
      1948 9.51
      1947 2.56
      1946 -12.05
      1945 39.35
      Federal debt began the 20th century at less than 10 percent of GDP. It jerked above 30 percent as a result of World War I and then declined in the 1920s to 16.3 percent by 1929. Federal debt started to increase after the Crash of 1929, and rose above 40 percent in the depths of the Great Depression.
      Federal debt exploded during World War II to over 120 percent of GDP, and then began a decline that bottomed out at 32 percent of GDP in 1974. Federal debt almost doubled in the 1980s, reaching 60 percent of GDP in 1990 and peaking at 66 percent of GDP in 1996, before declining to 56 percent in 2001. Federal debt started increasing again in the 2000s, reaching 70 percent of GDP in 2008. Then it exploded in the aftermath of the Crash of 2008, reaching 102 percent of GDP in 2011.
      If you look it is actually a decline in the federal debt load that has hurt the stock market. 1929 debt at 16% = great depression. In 1974 we lowered our debt to 32% and 1974-1979 markets were hurt and we get "stagflation". Clinton has a surplus in his last 2 years and markets decline 2000-2001.
    • raymond 4 months ago
      well, you are comparing apples to oranges. We had in house financing, we borrowed our own money, we were on the gold standard, we had a very low stock market, we had very high taxes paying back the debt. We were paying back debt unlike today. We just can't sustain this type of economic model. We are borrowing 40% of every dollar we spend. Just can't keep that pace up and it's so wrong anyways. One day, we will have to pay, it's going to get rough starting in 2013.
    • Fred 4 months ago
      Raymond, we still borrow our own money (China only accounts for a fraction of our debt). Taxes will gradually go up, deficits will gradually diminish, inflation will pick up and we'll turn the corner on our debt load. Like Chris points out, we've been here before. No sense letting all the doomsayers control the dialog.
  • Daniel  •  New York, New York  •  5 months ago
    I am constantly amazed that anyone claiming to be a market professional can get airtime to make outlandish statements and have their headline posted on the landing page. This so-called expert has spend most of his career as a broker at a half a dozen firms, never managed a significant sum of money and runs a "trading" company that sells metals trading models for $69 each. Are we that desperate for news to print?
  • A Yahoo! User  •  Bend, Oregon  •  5 months ago
    Yawn. The observations about looming debt crisis and market environment are correct enough. So we're left with the same old wisdom that has always applied. Diversify, dollar cost average, and allocate according to your goals, retirement horizon, and personal level of tolerable risk. Chasing the silver bullet, trying to time the market, and making rash decisions on the advice of the talking heads will always get you into trouble.
  • ron0913  •  Cincinnati, Ohio  •  5 months ago
    Idiot! Nobody knows what's going to happen. So, make a bold contrarian prediction, and you're a guru if you guess right. If you guess wrong, no real harm, you just crawl back into your hole and contemplate your next bold prediction.
  • Techno  •  San Diego, California  •  4 months ago
    Tell me what do you expect from the market in 2012 and I'll guess whether you are Austrian or Keynessian economics fan.
  • Arturo D  •  Manila, Philippines  •  5 months ago
    i am wondering if mr. schoenberger and his bearish cohorts have some ulteriol motives, either financial or political. would like to know their political affiliations.
  • Steve T.  •  Omaha, Nebraska  •  5 months ago
    Breakout is a parade of whackos.
  • Vlad the Impaler  •  Orlando, Florida  •  4 months ago
    He sounds awfully bullish. I'm looking closer to 40 - 43% slide. If we don't invest at least $1.3 trillion in our infrastructure and jump start the the bottom 45%, our economy will be toast. It is the best possible short to midterm investment we can make to breath life back into the circular flow. If we don't get this segment of the population working, it will will become a HUGE drag and liability. If we don't pay them $24k a year, to work and do something productive, we will pay the departments of correction around the country $38k to cage them and do nothing. Instead of reopening factories, we'll be building more prisons. Get a clue! This isn't rocket science. The consequences are far more, and worse, than what I mentioned and the longer we keep our heads buried in the sand, the longer and harder and more painful it will be to get back on track.
  • John M  •  Phoenix, Arizona  •  4 months ago
    Bank of Ameica will go out of business when all the fraud cases go to court.
  • Quincy Magoo  •  5 months ago
    I doubt it. Bennie and the Feds won't let such a significant drop occur. Fed policy is to prop up the accumulated appearance of wealth in the stock market in any way possible, including stealing money from taxpayers to give to the robber-banksters. No, the Fed is going to continue this joyride even if it kills the country. After all, the Fed knows that we need the rich as a symbol of our individual potential so that we might dream of being annoited in the oil of extreme wealth, and the dream will keep us docile and pliable while we grind ourselves to dust in the pursuit of the impossible.
  • Richard  •  Pharr, Texas  •  4 months ago
    Shoenberger who???
  • foxyfish  •  Birmingham, Alabama  •  4 months ago
    Couldn't happen if a meaningful (like ten cent) Uptick Rule were reinstated. The Rule was enacted in 1938 to prevent garp like this from happening. It worked until 2001 Decimalization, and Then Rescinding of the Rule on July 6, 2007. See? Made it so much easier to abuse and manipulate "your" stocks and former "investments". It is amazing how many people out there do not understand what happened. Further amazing how many "Schools" and "Classes" and the like have cropped up to TEACH the gamblers how to short and further ram all stocks into the ground. More destruction of our Country. It is sick.
    IF you do NOT lobby your Congressperson, the President and the SEC to reinstate this Rule, stock prices will definitely be driven into the ground. 35% is a feeble estimate.
    If you are a "shorter", you ARE the problem.
  • The Ripper  •  4 months ago
    who's this schoenberger clown?
  • fed-up  •  Lima, Ohio  •  5 months ago
    I predict the market will go up 35% next year. I make that prediction based on nothing at all, the same this idiot is doing.

ABOUT BREAKOUT

Breakout is Yahoo! Finance’s daily all-out, roll-up-your-sleeves, dive-in, interactive investing show, offering fresh segments throughout the trading day. If you love making money, if you want to protect what you have, if you’re passionate about understanding these crazy markets, you’re in the right place. Welcome!

MEET THE TEAM: Matt Nesto, Jeff Macke, Aaron Task, Jennifer Carinci and Kevin Chupka

Investing 101

Subscribe and RSS

[X]

How to subscribe

Roll over each section to subscribe using Add to My Yahoo! or RSS Feed feeds.

Yahoo! News offers dozens of RSS feeds you can read in My Yahoo! or using third-party RSS news reader software. Click here to find out more about RSS and how you can use it with Yahoo! News.

DISCLAIMER

Merrill Lynch is not responsible for any content on this site.
 
Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
 
Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.