Breakout

What Does it Mean When 2% of Stocks Account for 90% of Total Earnings Growth?

Breakout

After all the ups and downs in the market this year and the uncertainty surrounding the outlook for next year, the S&P 500 has still managed to chalk up a 13% year-to-date gain and is sitting close to a five-year high. Despite this strong performance, the cost to ride this train, so to speak, is still about 12% less than it has been over the past decade. According to FactSet, the forward price-to-earnings ratio for the benchmark large cap index is now 12.6x, down from an average of 14.3x for the past 10 years. It's a factor (and factoid) that allows investors of all shapes and sizes to confidently declare that "stocks are cheap" and still be able to face their kids and get to sleep at night.

But are stocks really cheap?

At least one Wall Street strategist is arguing that they're not, saying a concentration of growth in just a handful of names is distorting the true profit picture. In fact, Morgan Stanley's chief equity strategist and uber bear Adam Parker has compiled a chart showing that almost 90% of the profit growth has come from just 10 stocks. It's a top-heavy reality that masks a far less exciting growth story beneath the broader markets.

"Clearly that seems to be the intent here, to say that underlying all the noise, the market is not as bullish — in terms of the fundamentals — as a lot of people would give it credit for," says Yahoo! Finance senior columnist Mike Santoli says in the attached video. He thinks the market has largely figured this out already -particularly that growth has been concentrated in a few very big companies as well as a lot of large financials that are coming off of very weak prior year results (or what Wall Street calls ''easy comparisons").

For the record, the 10 stocks are Apple (AAPL), Bank of America (BAC), AIG (AIG), Goldman Sachs (GS), Wells Fargo (WFC), JPMorgan (JPM), IBM (IBM), Citigroup (C), General Electric (GE) and Western Digital (WDC).

"It tells me that when you get to this point of a bull market, you have to be a little more selective and actual organic growth becomes scarcer," Santoli says, while pointing out that the math behind this growth analysis is a ''little bit squishy."

"If all companies had exactly the same earnings this year as last year, but one company earns $1 more, that company is worth 100% of the earnings growth, but it doesn't really tell you very much," he says, calling the research revelation of the moment interesting but indecisive. "Ultimately, it doesn't really tell you how you should invest."

Rates

View Comments (127)

Recommended for You

  • U.S. SEC to pay $30 million-plus in largest whistleblower award

    By Sarah N. Lynch WASHINGTON (Reuters) - An anonymous tipster living abroad will be receiving more than $30 million, in the largest whistleblower award ever doled out by U.S. The Securities and Exchange Commission said on Monday that the whistleblower provided crucial information that helped…

    Reuters
  • Want a Career Change in Education? Earn your M.Ed.

    A Master of Education degree can help you launch a new career as a school administrator, curriculum director and more. Why wait? Apply to GCU!

    AdChoicesGrand Canyon UniversitySponsored
  • Wall Street Has A New Worry Now That The Economy Is Recovering

    Business Insider is at the annual Bloomberg Markets Most Influential Summit on Monday, and this year  guest after guest has talked about the same worry. Early in the conference Carlyle CEO William Conway, hedge fund legend Julian Robertson, and William Dudley CEO of the Federal Reserve Bank of New…

    Business Insider
  • Apple sells more than 10 million new iPhones in first three days

    Apple Inc said it sold more than 10 million iPhones in the first weekend after its new models went on sale on Friday, underscoring strong demand for phones with larger displays. Chief Executive Tim Cook said the company could have sold even more iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 Plus models if supplies had…

    Reuters
  • After big gains, stocks Cramer would avoid

    If you're looking at these stocks due to chatter of a super-cycle, Cramer thinks you'll come to regret it. Because sand is such an important part of fracking , a relatively new drilling process that's made formerly hard to reach deposits of oil (New York Mercantile Exchange: @CL.1) and natural gas…

    CNBC
  • Top Analyst Upgrades and Downgrades: Auxilium, BofA, Genworth, MGM, Walgreen, Wynn, Yahoo and More

    Auxilium Pharmaceuticals Inc. (AUXL) was downgraded to Hold from Buy at Stifel. Genworth Financial Inc. (GNW) was written up in Barron’s over the weekend as having 80% upside potential. Las Vegas Sands Corp. (LVS) was downgraded to Market Perform from Outperform and the price target was cut to a…

    24/7 Wall St.
  • Gold crashes and is now tarnished for good

    Gold shined brightly at the beginning of 2014, with bullion prices jumping by about 13% from New Year’s Day until mid-March. Last week, the precious metal settled near lows not seen since Christmas 2013.

    MarketWatch
  • 5 Giant Myths Of Retirement Planning

    The world of retirement planning is no different. It’s been more than two decades since retirees could comfortably consider retiring off the interest they earned at the bank. If not, you’ll find yourself living a life of scarcity when your retirement life could be filled with abundance.

    Forbes
  • What's Your Definition of Success?

    Success means different things for different people, that’s why we’ve started “The Success Project”.

    AdChoicesstrayerSponsored
  • Russian Industrial Giant Facing Bankruptcy?

    One of Russia's commodity producers could get crushed under the weight of its debt. U.S.-traded shares in the producer of coal, iron ore and steel, Mechel (MTL), fell 30%. The Market Vectors Russia ETF (RSX)  fell 1.83% today. The  iShares MSCI Russia

    Barrons.com
  • EMC Stock Soars After Investors Learn About Mega-Merger Talks With HP, Others

    For nearly a year, EMC and HP have been kicking the tires on a merger that would have created one the biggest enterprise tech companies on the planet — with over $130 billion in annual sales, according to the Wall Street Journal. Both companies were concerned they couldn't sell the deal as it was…

    Business Insider
  • One Apple supplier may not get a pop from the iPhone 6

    The iPhone 6 has been a smashing success for Apple. This past weekend, Apple reported selling an astounding 10 million iPhone 6 and iPhone 6 Plus smartphones. Investors hoping to be clever about the news may consider buying shares of SanDisk, the flash memory maker that is an important supplier to…

    Talking Numbers
  • US cracks down on companies moving overseas

    The Obama administration cracked down Monday on certain overseas corporate mergers and acquisitions, aiming to curb American companies from shifting their ownership abroad to shirk paying U.S. New regulations from the Treasury Department will make these co-called corporate inversions less lucrative…

    Associated Press
  • Next up after Alibaba: Biggest bank IPO ever

    Investors will get a little time to catch their breath after Friday's record-breaking Alibaba trading debut, but not too long. On the heels of what is the largest initial public offering on record, Wall Street will be asked to digest what could be the largest bank or thrift IPO ever-the expected…

    CNBC
  • Ruble Falls on Brent Decline, Fed Concerns: Russia Reality Check

    Markets are reacting in real time to tension in Ukraine following Russia’s March incursion into Crimea and subsequent annexation of the Black Sea peninsula. The Micex Index fell 1 percent to 1,417.46 at 12:44 p.m. in Moscow, giving a loss since Feb. 28, the day before President Vladimir Putin ’s…

    Bloomberg
  • With FlexPath, You Can Learn At Your Own Pace

    With Capella University's new self-paced FlexPath program, you can now earn a degree without sacrificing your schedule.

    AdChoicesCapella UniversitySponsored
  • Linn Energy: No Surprise, Everyone Loves ExxonMobil Swap

    Last week, Linn Energy (LINE) arranged to swap some assets with ExxonMobil (XOM). On the heels of a positive take from Credit Suisse last week, two more analysts murmuring sweet nothings about the deal tdoay. RBC's John Ragozzino and team note that Linn's "portfolio high-grading strategy" continues…

    Barrons.com
  • Alibaba becomes world’s largest IPO, but stock dives

    It’s official: Alibaba is the world’s largest IPO. The title was pretty much in the bag on Friday, when the Chinese Internet juggernaut raised $21.8 billion in a blockbuster public debut, and was on its way to $25 billion after the New York Stock Exchange said the underwriting banks would sell…

    San Jose Mercury News
  • SPIN METER: Those changing health law numbers

    Call it health care law numerology. The Obama administration has had to revise and refine some initial enrollment numbers for health insurance sign-ups after they turned out to be too optimistic. Parsing the numbers is a new pursuit for administration officials from President Barack Obama on down,…

    Associated Press
  • The Debit Card Danger You're Probably Forgetting

    As the American economy sunk in the wake of the Great Recession, many Americans were forced to rethink their spending habits and tossed their credit cards overboard, reaching instead for the perceived safety of their debit cards. Debit cards protect you from yourself by limiting your spending to…

    U.S.News & World Report LP
  • 5 401(k) Gotchas to Avoid

    Between employer contributions and the ability to defer income tax on your own contributions, 401(k) plans often help you come out ahead in retirement saving. Here are five 401(k) pitfalls to watch out for: [See: 10 401(k) Facts Everyone Should Know.]

    U.S.News & World Report LP
  • How to Play the Real-Estate Market

    Skimpy interest rates, pent-up demand and lower prices have sparked gains of about 20% in the median price of new and existing homes over the past two years. Select REIT Index—which covers a number of investment vehicles—has climbed about 150% since the beginning of 2009, roughly matching the…

    The Wall Street Journal
  • Blackstone to pull out of Russia

    US private equity group Blackstone is "giving up on Russia", highlighting how even well-connected western investors are shying away from doing business in the country. The New York-based buyout group has been frustrated in its attempts to find deals in the country since its co-founder Stephen…

    Financial Times