Wed, May 23, 2012, 1:56 AM EDT - U.S. Markets open in 7 hrs 34 mins

Occupy Wall Street Is “Not Doing Anything Right”: Ben Stein

Follow us on Facebook!

Occupy Wall Street dominates the headlines and it comes as news to no one that there are cracks in the firmament of America's version of capitalism. Among the problems are an inequitable distribution of wealth, a taxation system that seems at once exorbitant and insufficient, and a widely held view that the system is rigged in favor of those who least need assistance.

Few dispute the need for change, the question is how to effectively enact it. I explored the issue with Ben Stein, a man with vast experience in finance, politics, and law as well as author of the new book "What Would Ben Stein Do?" We started with the OWS movement.

"They're not doing anything right," Stein says in a way that somehow combines flat affect and high impact. "They don't accomplish anything specifically useful."

So what would Ben Stein do?

He'd do what he's done in the past. Stein used to write 7,000 word in-depth exposes on corporate fraud. "They were a lot of work but they eventually got some people prosecuted," Stein says. "They got some money recovered for stockholders." Stein offers that if the OWS crowd wants to do something helpful they should do the research necessary to direct and inform their discontent.

Beyond method and means, Stein is unimpressed with the very notion of "crusading against greed." Especially when the protesters themselves are demonstrably guilty of something he thinks far worse.

"You know what the worst deadly sin is? Spiritual pride or thinking that you're morally better than other people," Stein says. "That's what the Occupy Wall Street people are all about; thinking they're better than other people and that's a sin, too."

Not that he doesn't have grievances himself. "It's breathtaking how much tax I pay, but I think I should probably pay more," says the former speechwriter for Nixon. He outright believes the U.S. will default on our credit, either outright or via inflation, so his self-imposed tax hike is a last but necessary resort.

See the attached video to hear Stein's thoughts on how our tax dollars can be deployed more effectively, where he'd like to see the budget cut, and to generally enjoy his Ben Stein-ness. Whatever you do, don't dismiss Ben Stein as another Doom and Gloom crank. He's more along the lines of a man who's already seen the scary movie and knows everything turns out alright by the time the lights come up.

"The future looks difficult but it always looks difficult," he says. "I cannot remember a time when the future looked like it was all clear sailing with no problems." In other words, relax, folks, it's going to be a bumpy ride but we'll get there... if not we can just ask Ben Stein what he would do to help.

Breakout Asks

Do you think Facebook (FB) will end this year above or below its IPO price of $38 a share?

Loading...
Poll Choice Options
  • Yes, FB will recover
  • No, FB is too unstable
 

137 comments

  • A Yahoo! User  •  6 months ago
    Many of the ultra rich advocate higher taxes for themselves; why is it not happening? Or don't they REALLY believe this? I'm serious about this question. Who has an answer?
    • Andy 6 months ago
      Many is still less than 50%. Most will not agree to pay higher taxes.
    • just_plain_name 6 months ago
      They are free to give whatever they want to the government. Why don't they? Who has an answer?
    • Harry 6 months ago
      That's because they don't really mean it and talk is cheap. Ask Warren Buffet and Bill Gates if their will leaves some money to the U.S. treasury when they pass away. Even $10k? No, not a dime...
  • semper fi  •  6 months ago
    Human nature usually doesn't cherish anything that is not earned,or paid for, including government.
    • tayronachan 6 months ago
      Brilliant, that's almost a Thomas Jefferson like quote.
    • Amerikan 6 months ago
      True.........he is a #$%$......
  • A Yahoo! User  •  6 months ago
    If you intentionally created a fake cause and tweeted for protesters you would get most of the low life presently involved with "Occupy Wallstreet". These people are lost and looking for something to do. By the way our Constitution says nothing about the right to sleep and camp on public property between protests.
  • HEW  •  6 months ago
    Redistribution of the wealth - Isn't that what the IRS does with our tax money. Apparenty they don't pay taxes or they would know this. If the corpoate leaders breal the law then confiscate thier assets and fine them $3.00 for every $1.00 illegally taken. Case closed.
    • tayronachan 6 months ago
      Ron Paul 2012. Listen to him.
    • Amerikan 6 months ago
      Don't work that way.........the rich rule....and are above the law
  • Rules Too  •  6 months ago
    Yea, like Stein has ever gotten anything done. As I recall he cheered on virtually everything that has gone wrong especially financial deregulation.
    • Lloyd C 6 months ago
      You recall incorrectly.
    • Rules Too 6 months ago
      If you want to follow some guy who in his film "Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed" argues that Darwin is responsible for the holocaust then have at it. And I am sure little Ben put a lot of work in his film. But he did support financial deregulation and only after its massive failure did he do a 180. Fact. He is a master of self promotion and goes with the wind.
  • JacquelineS  •  6 months ago
    The people who are getting the million dollar salaries while destroying their companies are corrupt and greedy. The people who are on welfare and disability when they don't legitimately need it are also corrupt and greedy. The system works for the people at the very top. It also works well for the people at the bottom because they get something for nothing while enjoying the quaint image of the poor presented by the media. The system doesn't work for the vast middle class. A reasonable protest would include the people at the very top who don't deserve what they make (Thus excluding physicians, engineers, etc) And the bottom 30% who get something for nothing via fraud.
    • rocky 6 months ago
      ok I will vote for you. Let me know where
    • Freedom 6 months ago
      The idle poor and the idle rich.....
  • Michael  •  6 months ago
    ows...so what exactly is the point of this "movement". Maybe the 99% they claim to represent would be more supportive if the knew exactly what that is.
  • Kalapu  •  6 months ago
    I personally don't care what Ben Stein would Do?, or thinks. The man has been wrong so many times in the past ten years he has absolutely no credibility.
  • O  •  6 months ago
    1. Get rid of lobbyists in Washington and put limit on service-term for politicians.
    2. Simplify tax code. Particularly, get rid of tax loopholes for companies outsourcing jobs.
    3. Promote free enterprise and enforce regulations to terminate monopolies. In the meantime, provide government-sponsored alternatives to compete/protect against controlling monopolies, particularly in the healthcare, insurance and mortgage industries.
    4. Stop senseless wars.
  • Scott  •  6 months ago
    "Among the problems are an inequitable distribution of wealth" - SAYS WHO? IF YOU WORK HARD, YOU GET REWARDED FAIRLY

    "a taxation system that seems at once exorbitant and insufficient", - INSUFFICIENT? ARE U INSANE?

    and a widely held view that the system is rigged in favor of those who least need assistance -"NO BEN, THAT VIEW IS THE FALLACY OF SOCIALISM.
  • Steven Q  •  6 months ago
    August 18, 2007 - Ben Stein: The credit crunch is way overblown. The [financial institutions] are being given away; they're so unbelievably cheap...The subprime problem is a problem, but it's a tiny problem in the context of this economy...It's a buying opportunity, especially for the financials, maybe like I've never seen before in my entire life.

    Peter Schiff: This is just getting started. It's not just subprimes. This is a problem for the entire mortgage industry. It's not just people with bad credit that committed to mortgages they couldn't afford. It's not just people with bad credit who are going to see their home equity vanish... This is going to be an enormous credit crunch...

    Neil Cavuto: You must be a laugh-riot at parties.

    (LAUGHTER)

    Ben Stein: ...subprime is tiny. Subprime is a tiny, tiny blip.

    Peter Schiff: It's not tiny. And again, it's not just subprime. It's the entire mortgage market.

    Ben Stein: You're simply wrong about that... Defaults for the whole mortgage market are tiny.

    Ben Stein: I think stocks will be a heck of a lot higher a year from now than they are now.
  • Vermontocs  •  6 months ago
    I like the idea of Americans gathering and protesting injustice. I wish they were better organized. They seem almost dysfunctional and only want to party.

    A park full of Lindsy Lohans wont get anything done.
  • Loki Thegod  •  6 months ago
    Inflation is the ONLY way we are going to get out of this hole. We can begin a slow controlled period of inflation NOW and slowly climb our way out of this hole, OR we can wait for a hard default and see massive inflation which will probably disrupt the world economy drastically sending us into another depression. The other benefit of high inflation would be that people would stop sitting on their money; debt is good when inflation is high.
  • not I said the ape  •  6 months ago
    'your' inputs are mine...thats what I meant to say. The Holy Spirit is perfect but I make typos. It has me laughing so hard, its unbelievable. I wanted to know where the rescue funds are and what the austerity measures were so I could capitalize. there you go breakout theres some useful information you can report to us tomorrow. i didnt even do that on purpose believe it or not
  • Say it like you see it  •  6 months ago
    Have you noticed how the news and media outlets are down playing this protest movement? Who owns the news and media outlets? The same people that are afraid of losing power is who. They are very afraid of this movement. The message is: "GET THE CORPORATE MONIES OUT OF OUR ELECTION PROCESS"!!! The individual stock holder has no say in how those monies are used. The elitists are propping people up on ballots all around the world. They than use their owned or controlled news and media outlets to convince the masses to vote for their candidates. The elected are nothing more than puppets on a string to these people to get their agendas passed. The elected no longer work for the voters. This has to stop. These same elitists are all for the United Nations goals of a one world government. Fewer people to buy off. They are all for no currencies in the world. Come to the company store. They are all for disarming the masses of small arms. A disarmed masses are easier to control. All of this is the United Nations goals. The U.S. is the biggest backer of the U.N. That is our tax dollars at work. If this agenda is achieved, are you better off? HELL NO! Wake up America! You Democrats had better wake up. It is the people you elect who is for all of this. I am talking about the Liberal crowd who has taken over and destroyed your party. Do you really think these Liberals are for the working man? Pay attention to what they are doing. It is not the Democrats, it is the Liberals who have taken over your party. I am talking about O'bama, Clinton, Pelosi, and etc. Cast them out of your midst or hang them, that is up to you. You have been duped, pure and simple! Wake Up!!!
  • Jack Mehoff  •  6 months ago
    These people camping in the park are not part of the 99%, there is no 99% there is a 98%, but these losers and freaks are the bottom feeders of society. Degenerates, drug addicts, uneducated, lazy #$%$ are the 1% human debris that preys on hard working Americans. Round them up and send the trash to Cuba where they can live in the type of life they so desperately seek.
  • KennethB  •  6 months ago
    Someone explain to me again why these malcontents are not protesting at the WH?? With Corzine, MF global and Obama scheme, this seems like the perfect place to make their point! I guess they can not protest their own saviour and his failed presidency.
  • Barney  •  6 months ago
    ...who killed the young girl....
  • Manly HA  •  6 months ago
    Losers are always unhappy and blaime the other guy. Do what I did, get two jobs, live cheap, save your money, open your own business, hire people, build your financial security. Your future is what you make it. Take the less traveled route and pay your dues. It takes time and diligence but the rewards are there. Opportunites abound.
  • Roland  •  6 months ago
    Anyone? Macke...anyone...

ABOUT BREAKOUT

Breakout is Yahoo! Finance’s daily all-out, roll-up-your-sleeves, dive-in, interactive investing show, offering fresh segments throughout the trading day. If you love making money, if you want to protect what you have, if you’re passionate about understanding these crazy markets, you’re in the right place. Welcome!

MEET THE TEAM: Matt Nesto, Jeff Macke, Aaron Task, Jennifer Carinci and Kevin Chupka

Investing 101

Subscribe and RSS

[X]

How to subscribe

Roll over each section to subscribe using Add to My Yahoo! or RSS Feed feeds.

Yahoo! News offers dozens of RSS feeds you can read in My Yahoo! or using third-party RSS news reader software. Click here to find out more about RSS and how you can use it with Yahoo! News.

DISCLAIMER

Merrill Lynch is not responsible for any content on this site.
 
Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
 
Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.