Breakout

Passive money management strategy actively crushing stock pickers

Jeff Macke
Breakout

The stock market is beating the tar out of professional stock pickers again this year. According to this morning’s Wall Street Journal more than 74% of actively managed mutual funds are lagging the S&P 500 (^GSPC) so far in 2014. Even when the numbers are tweaked so that funds are compared to their sometimes arbitrary benchmarks it’s the worst year for active managers since 2011.

It’s a disheartening reversal from 2013 when 50% of actively managed funds were able to keep up with the S&P but it should hardly come as a surprise. Over the long-term very few funds beat their benchmarks or the market as a whole.

Not that the numbers keep the industry from kneeling at the altar of stud money managers. The front page of today’s Journal features a 2,000+ word article about the comeback of Legg Mason’s “Mutual Fund King Bill Miller.” Miller’s Value Trust mutual fund outperformed the S&P 500 for a stunning 15 years before the financial crisis vaporized his relative gains, reputation and a good portion of the assets under management.

The market’s biggest advantage against active managers is that people are notoriously dumb when it comes to calculating returns, assessing risk and deploying assets. As Josh Brown points out, the un-ironic lauding of Miller rather nicely summarizes everything people do wrong when it comes to making investment decisions.

In the attached video Janney’s Mark Luschini says good old fashioned risk-aversion is responsible for much of the underperformance this year. “Everybody’s expecting a correction in equity prices. A lot of managers have braced for that by having excess cash in portfolio waiting for an opportunity to put it to work at a better price. So far it’s been steady climb into about a 7% return year to date and a lot of active managers as a result are paying the price.”

Luschini says that caution is warranted, even if it’s been costly so far. He’s got a roughly 2,000 price target on the S&P 500 by year end, a mere 2% higher than current levels. Against that potential reward he sees a fairly large amount of risk.

“The market is ripe for a pullback. We’re seeing full valuations in the making equity prices vulnerable to surprise whatever that may be, could be a spike in oil prices or shift in Fed policy later this year.”

Despite the risk with no where better to go Luschini thinks the mix of largely long stocks with a touch of cash on the sidelines will prove to be a winning strategy by year end. Even for those playing low-cost index funds banking a little profit makes sense by his thinking.

Ultimately the goal for individual investors isn’t beating the market but mastering their own emotions and saving money for a comfortable retirement.

More from Breakout:
Apple's amazing quarter, MannKind rebounds, Zillow zipping higher
Welcome back Charney? American Apparel saga gets weirder
'Common sense' says look out for a market drop

Rates

View Comments (14)

Recommended for You

  • Blackstone to pull out of Russia

    US private equity group Blackstone is "giving up on Russia", highlighting how even well-connected western investors are shying away from doing business in the country. The New York-based buyout group has been frustrated in its attempts to find deals in the country since its co-founder Stephen…

    Financial Times
  • Often Overlooked Method to Pay Off Mortgage

    If you own a home and pay for a mortgage, you could reduce your payments by an average of $4,100 a year. Here is how it works.

    AdChoicesRateMarketplaceSponsored
  • Here's What Mark Cuban Wishes He Knew About Money In His 20s

    AP Mark Cuban is the owner of the Dallas Mavericks. Billionaire investor and entrepreneur Mark Cuban is generous with his advice. When we asked him what he wishes he'd known about money in his 20s, he said:

    Business Insider
  • Tax refunds will be cut for ACA recipients

    A significant benefit of the Affordable Care Act is the opportunity to receive money-saving tax credits up front to cut the overall cost of health insurance, but now hundreds of thousands of consumers could owe back some of that money next April.Those affected took advance payments of the premium…

    USA TODAY
  • 10 Stocks Trading Under $10 With Huge Upside Potential

    Ballard Power Systems Inc. (BLDP) has been around forever as a fuel cell play. DryShips Inc. (DRYS) was started as Buy with a $5 price target at Deutsche Bank in a late-Monday call. The Deutsche Bank research on the sector was very positive, with 2015 expected to be a solid year for growth across…

    24/7 Wall St.
  • Oklahoma City oil producer unveils new formation

    An Oklahoma City-based energy company has unveiled a new formation in south-central Oklahoma that the company's CEO said will elevate the state as an oil producer. Continental Resources Inc. said western Oklahoma's Springer Shale deposit is in the heart of the South Central Oklahoma Oil Province,…

    Associated Press
  • At a Glance: the business dealings of Jeb Bush

    Jeb Bush entered the Florida governor's mansion in 1999 with a net worth of $2 million, a relatively modest fortune compared with others in the Bush family. Within months of leaving office, he started a consulting firm, registered as a broker for Lehman Brothers and joined a number of corporate…

    Associated Press
  • Bill Gates Is At Least $6 Billion Richer Than He Was Six Months Ago, But Not From Microsoft

    In July, Bill Gates may or may not have lost his title as the world's richest man. According to Forbes, Gates has a net worth of almost $82 billion, which puts him in the No. 2 spot behind Mexican telecom magnate Carlos Slim, who's worth $85.4 billion. According to Bloomberg, Gates is still the…

    Business Insider
  • Why Study at GCU's College of Education?

    Bachelor's degree programs at our College of Education are aligned to national standards & prepare you to sit for licensure exams. Learn more today!

    AdChoicesGrand Canyon UniversitySponsored
  • Genworth Shares Could Surge 80%

    Genworth Financial has traveled a rocky road since the insurer was offloaded by General Electric in 2004. At the same time, the long-term care insurance (LTC) business went so sour that big competitors like MetLife (MET) chose to pull out completely while Genworth (GNW) persevered. Barron's saw…

    Barrons.com
  • Play

    'Great Rotation' Into Stocks Runs Its Course

    Investors have been putting money back into bond funds as interest rates have unexpectedly dropped this year.

    Morningstar
  • Why Warren Buffett hates gold

    Warren Buffett didn't become one of the greatest investors of our generation by investing in gold. Just take a look at part of a speech Buffett gave at Harvard in 1998 when he said of gold:"(It) gets dug out of the ground in Africa or someplace. Anyone watching from Mars would be scratching their…

    USA TODAY
  • Baby Boomers Beware: You May Need a Birth Certificate to Buy a Home

    One way a mortgage lender verifies a borrower’s identity is by their Social Security Number. If your Social Security number was not issued at birth, and you’re applying for a mortgage, you may need extra documentation to back it up. Why Social Security Numbers Are a Hot-Button Issue

    Credit.com
  • How to Play the Real-Estate Market (Before It's Too Late)

    Skimpy interest rates, pent-up demand and lower prices have sparked gains of about 20% in the median price of new and existing homes over the past two years. Select REIT Index—which covers a number of investment vehicles—has climbed about 150% since the beginning of 2009, roughly matching the…

    The Wall Street Journal
  • Bundesbank warns of risky ECB 'change of course'

    The head of Germany's powerful Bundesbank sharply criticised what he called a radical new approach by the European Central Bank of easy money, in an interview published Sunday. The central bank chief, Jens Weidmann, told Der Spiegel news weekly that the bank's recent moves of setting interest rates…

    AFP
  • 1 Tip To Lose Belly Fat

    It's Hollywood's Hottest Diet And Gets Rid Of Stubborn Fat Areas Like Nothing Else.

    AdChoicesagoodcooksSponsored
  • Zambia’s Copperbelt Energy Restricts Power to Konkola on Dispute

    Konkola Copper Mines Plc said Zambia’s Copperbelt Energy Corp Plc is restricting its power supply amid a dispute regarding tariff increases. “The restriction in power supply will adversely affect Konkola Copper Mines’ operations and compromise safety of the employees and job security,” Shapi…

    Bloomberg
  • 6 Financial Moves to Help You Sleep Better at Night

    Have you ever spent sleepless nights worrying about your finances? Between battling debt, working to pay off a mortgage and planning for retirement, there is plenty to think about. But don’t let these worries keep you up at night — take action. Check

    Credit.com
  • 25 Things To Know About Investing By Age 25

    Most of us are just in it to bulk up our savings for retirement, make a little extra money on the side, or even just beat inflation (more on that in a minute). ... but your retirement savings are. Retirement savings, on the other hand, are invested if you put them in a retirement fund like an IRA…

    Business Insider
  • 'Maze Runner' races past 'Tombstones' with $32.5 M

    NEW YORK (AP) — The young-adult adaptation "The Maze Runner" raced to the top of the box-office with $32.5 million, giving a budding franchise a quick start out of the gate.The 20th Century Fox release easily outpaced the $13.1 million debut of Liam Neeson

    Associated Press48 mins ago
  • With Alibaba's big debut, 10 things to know

    China's e-commerce giant Alibaba began trading its shares Friday on the New York Stock Exchange. Here are ten things to know about Alibaba, and why its initial public offering made history: THE BIGGEST: Alibaba raised $21.8 billion in its debut, making it the biggest U.S.-listed IPO in history…

    Associated Press
  • Which to pay off first: credit cards or student loans?

    Dear Liz: I have $8,000 in savings. Should I use it to pay the accrued interest on federal student loans that go into repayment soon? Or should I pay credit card debts of $662 at 11.24%, $3,840 at 7.99% and $3,000 at 6.99%?

    Los Angeles Times
  • Best Womens Wrinkle Creams 2014

    Mom reveals simple wrinkle solution that has researchers very excited. Try this free solution today to look and feel years younger.

    AdChoicesBellaLabs.comSponsored
  • Can I Actually Rent-to-Own a Home?

    For them, a rent-to-own arrangement can appear to be an attractive option. During that time, the landlord/seller sets aside part of each month’s rent payment into an escrow account. When the lease is up, provided the payments have been made in a timely manner, the renter can use the money in the…

    Credit.com