Breakout

Treasury’s GM stock sale would land a hedgie in prison: Macke

Jeff Macke
Breakout

On December 9th of last year the U.S. Treasury sold its final 31.1 million shares of General Motors (GM) stock, coming just a year after Treasury announced plans to exit its 500 million share position in the once bankrupt car company. According to a timeline created by NPR, the Treasury department sold out less than one month before GM executives linked a faulty ignition switch to 31 crashes and at least 13 fatalities.

Treasury’s decision to dump its entire stake in GM allowed it to avoid $262 million in potential losses.

Nine days later in New York former SAC trader Michael Steinberg was convicted on multiple counts of insider trading shares of Dell. Steinberg will be sentenced later this month and is facing up to 85 years in prison. Steinberg’s crime was trading based on a chain of evidence including ex-employees and an analyst with a different firm who reportedly had close ties to the company.

Steinberg’s information led to, in the Government’s words, “profit or avoid losses of at least $1.7 million.” That’s not a typo. Steinberg was arrested in front of his children, professionally ruined and could go to prison for 85 years because of second and third-hand information that convinced a jury Steinberg had helped SAC avoid $1.7 million in losses.

Yahoo Finance’s Rick Newman has written about GM’s “shrewd timing” in the past, correctly observing that the Treasury Department had no official operational authority at GM. That said, as Newman points out in the attached video that hands-off approach isn’t the end of the story.

“By definition the government had inside information (when it sold its stake in GM),” says Newman. “The Transportation Department knew there was a problem with these vehicles as early as 2007. That doesn’t mean somebody connected all the dots and passed the information from the Transportation Department to Treasury but it’s the government, so the government did have inside information.”

Was what the government did when it came to dumping GM shares a violation of insider trading laws? Based on the way the law is written and the earnestness with which U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara has been prosecuting Wall Streeters the answer is almost certainly yes.

Here’s the law: “Illegal insider trading refers generally to buying or selling a security, in breach of a fiduciary duty or other relationship of trust and confidence, while in possession of material, nonpublic information about the security. Insider trading violations may also include "tipping" such information, securities trading by the person "tipped," and securities trading by those who misappropriate such information.”

Bharara has gone 80-0 against accused violators of a law that doesn’t require hard evidence to prosecute yet its highly unlikely there will be any substantial investigation of the government’s suspiciously brilliant GM trade. Whatever your take on white collar crime the people buying GM from Treasury were the same widows, orphans and pension funds victimized by SAC.

No one needs to cry for hedgies but a nation of laws can do better than the ongoing Spanish Inquisition-style prosecution of a law that still doesn’t have a clear definition.

More from Breakout:

New troubles for Herbalife, Coke bubbles higher, Pep Boys needs a lift

'Drone Wars' taking off as tech giants fight on new battleground

Tesla can't be measured by traditional metric despite what short interest is saying: Fahmy

 

Rates

View Comments (154)

Recommended for You

  • 3 Lessons An Investor Learned After Losing His Job, Reputation, And $1.6 Million

    The late Jim Paul went from a poor Kentucky boy to serving on the board of governors of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange through a series of lucky breaks and smart investments. By 1990 he was working in the futures research department at Morgan Stanley Dean Witter & Co., managing a team that…

    Business Insider
  • Often Overlooked Method to Pay Off Mortgage

    If you own a home and pay for a mortgage, you could reduce your payments by an average of $4,100 a year. Here is how it works.

    AdChoicesRateMarketplaceSponsored
  • Bill Gates Is At Least $6 Billion Richer Than He Was Six Months Ago, But Not From Microsoft

    In July, Bill Gates may or may not have lost his title as the world's richest man. According to Forbes, Gates has a net worth of almost $82 billion, which puts him in the No. 2 spot behind Mexican telecom magnate Carlos Slim, who's worth $85.4 billion. According to Bloomberg, Gates is still the…

    Business Insider
  • Silver Is Getting Crushed

    Silver is getting crushed. On Friday, Silver fell more than 3% to less than $18 an ounce, its lowest level in more than four years. The price of gold also fell about 0.8% and touched its lowest level since January.

    Business Insider
  • Bitcoin tanks, is Alibaba to blame?

    The price of bitcoin has plummeted in the past few days, and some are blaming the Alibaba IPO for the virtual currency's fall. Members of the bitcoin community are pointing fingers at the e-commerce giant's IPO, suggesting that tech-minded China-centric money is being pulled out of the currency in…

    CNBC
  • Play

    'Great Rotation' Into Stocks Runs Its Course

    Investors have been putting money back into bond funds as interest rates have unexpectedly dropped this year.

    Morningstar
  • Eric Holder’s Shameful Legacy on Wall Street Fraud

    Right in the middle of the midterm election season, and just before Attorney General Eric Holder reportedly might step down, he made it known that the Justice Department will really really indict Wall Street executives in financial fraud cases. “We expect to bring charges in the coming months,”…

    The Fiscal Times
  • Can Sears Close 2,300 Stores?

    In a widely publicized note to investors, Gary Balter of Credit Suisse said that it is best that Sears Holdings Corp. (SHLD) close its Sears and Kmart locations while they, and the inventory they sell, still have value. Sears Holdings operates about 2,350 stories. Sears is generating negative…

    24/7 Wall St.
  • Best Womens Wrinkle Creams 2014

    Mom reveals simple wrinkle solution that has researchers very excited. Try this free solution today to look and feel years younger.

    AdChoicesBellaLabs.comSponsored
  • Rivals dash to support Apple Pay for fear of losing out

    Apple Pay preserves many existing relationships while inserting a new dominant player - itself - as kingmaker. The 800 million Apple users who have already connected credit and debit cards to iTunes accounts. "Apple's approach appears to be collaborative with traditional payment networks, instead…

    Reuters
  • Pilot Delays His Flight for Alibaba Debut, Nabs Shares at $94

    Cory Frugé, a commercial airline pilot, first learned of Ltd. about four years ago when he set out to build a private runway on his property in Iota, La. He needed to buy lighting for the runway and in his search for affordable solar-powered lights he stumbled on Alibaba's website. On Friday…

    The Wall Street Journal
  • 'Bubble in everything, everywhere': Marc Faber

    Even after the Dow (Dow Jones Global Indexes: .DJI) and the S&P 500 (^GSPC) closed at new all-time highs, closely followed contrarian Marc Faber keeps sounding the alarm. Faber has long argued that the Federal Reserve's massive asset purchasing programs and near-zero interest rates have inflated…

    CNBC
  • Why you shouldn't buy Alibaba: Pros

    Alibaba (BABA) shares hit the market Friday amid much hype, becoming the biggest initial public offering in U.S. For one, since it's an IPO, it's probably overpriced, Barry James, president of James Advantage Fund, told CNBC. "When you look at initial public offerings, 80 percent of them lose money…

    CNBC
  • Play

    A Favorable Prognosis for This Pharma Stock

    Recent clinical success in cystic fibrosis positions Vertex as a dominant player in this attractive rare-disease market.

    Morningstar
  • Here's What Mark Cuban Wishes He Knew About Money In His 20s

    AP Mark Cuban is the owner of the Dallas Mavericks. Billionaire investor and entrepreneur Mark Cuban is generous with his advice. When we asked him what he wishes he'd known about money in his 20s, he said:

    Business Insider
  • Get a Move On With Budget Truck

    Starting college can be tough, but moving to your dorms doesn’t have to be! Make the move easier by renting a Budget Truck.

    AdChoicesBudget TruckSponsored
  • Can I Actually Rent-to-Own a Home?

    For them, a rent-to-own arrangement can appear to be an attractive option. During that time, the landlord/seller sets aside part of each month’s rent payment into an escrow account. When the lease is up, provided the payments have been made in a timely manner, the renter can use the money in the…

    Credit.com
  • Stock Market Blogger 'Jesse Livermore' Is Calling The Top

    On Friday, Alibaba is set to make its debut on the NYSE in the largest IPO ever.  Jesse Livermore, the pseudonymous blogger of Philosophical Economics, on Thursday night noted that in 2012, Facebook's IPO marked the market bottom for the year, and sees Alibaba's debut as potentially marking the top…

    Business Insider
  • At a Glance: the business dealings of Jeb Bush

    Jeb Bush entered the Florida governor's mansion in 1999 with a net worth of $2 million, a relatively modest fortune compared with others in the Bush family. Within months of leaving office, he started a consulting firm, registered as a broker for Lehman Brothers and joined a number of corporate…

    Associated Press
  • Yahoo rakes in another jackpot from Alibaba's IPO

    Yahoo is making amends for years of blundering with one smart move: an early investment in Alibaba Group that has turned into a multibillion-dollar boon. The latest windfall came with Alibaba's record-setting IPO completed late Thursday, in which the Chinese e-commerce giant raised $25 billion.…

    Associated Press
  • 3 Chinese Stocks That Are Better Bargains than Alibaba

    All eyes are on Alibaba Group Holding (BABA) as the Chinese e-commerce giant makes its U.S. Alibaba dominates Internet sales in the world's most populous nation, moving more merchandise than Amazon.com (AMZN) and eBay (EBAY) combined and serving up healthy profits. When the stock begins trading on…

    Kiplinger
  • Lacker Says He Opposes Fed Plan to Hold Mortgage-Backed Assets

    Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond President Jeffrey Lacker said he couldn’t fully support the central bank’s revised exit strategy released this week because he opposes a measure to hold mortgage-backed securities. “I believe this approach unnecessarily prolongs our interference in the allocation of…

    Bloomberg
  • Everyone's Past Exposed on this New Website!

    A new site has made it simple to find the truth out about anyone online. It's as easy as typing in a Name and selecting a State!

    AdChoicesInstant CheckmateSponsored
  • 10 Stocks Trading Under $10 With Huge Upside Potential

    Ballard Power Systems Inc. (BLDP) has been around forever as a fuel cell play. DryShips Inc. (DRYS) was started as Buy with a $5 price target at Deutsche Bank in a late-Monday call. The Deutsche Bank research on the sector was very positive, with 2015 expected to be a solid year for growth across…

    24/7 Wall St.