Michael Santoli

BlackRock, Goldman show investors prefer the "buy side." Should they?

Michael Santoli
A Goldman Sachs sign is seen over their kiosk on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange

View photo

A Goldman Sachs sign is seen over their kiosk on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange, April 26, 2010. REUTERS/Brendan McDermid

On Wall Street, market participants are represented by two separate, yet equally important groups: the “buy side,” which invests client assets in securities, and the “sell side,” which executes trades and underwrites stock and bond offerings.

BlackRock Inc. (BLK), the largest buy-side firm, with $4.3 trillion in managed assets, and Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (GS), the top sell-side firm, both reported sturdy profits Thursday – and in a statistical coincidence, they put up rather similar per-share earnings for the fourth quarter and full-year 2013.

View photo


REUTERS/Shannon Stapleton

In a sign of which business investors have greater trust and belief in at the moment, each dollar per share of BlackRock’s earnings is valued by the market at 70% more than a dollar of Goldman’s earnings.

BlackRock reported $4.86 per share in fourth-quarter earnings and $16.58 for the full-year 2013. Goldman, overcoming a soft bond-trading environment with some tight control over compensation expenses, earned $4.60 per share last quarter, about 40 cents better than forecasts, and $15.46 a share for the year.

Similar bottom lines, stark share differences

Those similar per-share bottom lines make stark the variance in these New York financial giants’ share prices: BlackRock stock trades near $320, or some 19.3-times its 2013 profits, versus Goldman’s around $175, or 11.3-times last year’s earnings. BlackRock shares are up more than 1% in midday trade following its earnings release, while Goldman stock is down around 2%.

(Goldman remains the far larger company, with nearly three times as many shares outstanding and a market value of $85 billion compared to BlackRock’s $56 billion.)

There’s nothing particularly new about the fact that global banks such as Goldman tend to trade at a discount to the broad market and to other categories of financial firms.

Goldman runs a large leveraged balance sheet, its results are fairly volatile and based on mercurial trading flows, and regulators have forced all big banks to hold more capital and pull out of some profitable trading businesses. The firm posted a return on equity – an important gauge of profitability for investment banks – of 11% for 2013, up a bit from last year but still perhaps a third of its ROE in the boom years of the mid-2000s, when hot trading markets and much higher use of borrowed funds by Goldman amplified returns.

Money management, by contrast, is a fabulous business – even more so for a company of BlackRock’s vast scale to reap huge efficiencies.

Initially an institutional bond manager, BlackRock has opportunistically bulked up at the expense of sell-side competitors in recent years, acquiring Merrill Lynch Investment Management and then the iShares exchange-traded funds business from Barclays PLC (BCS). The firm’s profit margin is around 40%.

What makes the comparison a bit more interesting is that Goldman is also in the money-management business, its Goldman Sachs Asset Management division overseeing a bit more than $1 trillion for wealthy individuals and institutions, as of Dec. 31.

That means Goldman has just under a quarter of BlackRock’s managed assets. Its 2013 revenue in asset management was closer to half BlackRock’s total revenue, as Goldman runs more high-touch strategies such as hedge funds, and counts much of its wealth-advisory revenues as part of investment management.

Still, without suggesting Goldman’s asset manager is remotely as profitable or as dominant a franchise as BlackRock’s, this represents some obscured value from a lower-risk business within Goldman. The market has rarely given Goldman “credit” for this in its share price, but this should at least provide some ballast for the firm’s long-term financial results.

Meantime, Goldman seems to be fully adjusting to the new regulatory and economic realities, going from the firm that paid its employees most lavishly to the one that's compressed compensation levels to better fit its revenue profile. As the Wall Street Journal points out, its emphasis on paying bonuses in Goldman stock has provided a nice windfall in the past year as Goldman shares rallied nicely  – but of course that was never guaranteed.

While the firm is never likely to return to the profit bonanza of the credit-boom years, Goldman appears well positioned to remain a leader in a more subdued securities industry – mediating global capital flows, taking companies public and topping the rankings of merger advisors. And, best of all, the firm seems finally to have become a lesser target of the “Law & Order”-style prosecutorial crowd who have been busy for years mopping up pre-crisis financial practices.


View Comments (11)

Recommended for You

  • Detroit retirees back pension cuts by a landslide

    DETROIT (AP) — A year after filing for bankruptcy, Detroit is building momentum to get out, especially after workers and retirees voted in favor of major pension changes just a few weeks before a judge holds a crucial trial that could end the largest public filing in U.S. history.

    Associated Press
  • Obama admin. says health subsidies will continue

    WASHINGTON (AP) — A federal appeals court delivered a potentially serious setback to President Barack Obama's health care law Tuesday, imperiling billions of dollars in subsidies for many low- and middle-income people who bought policies.

    Associated Press
  • Did You Know Every New Car Has a Secret Price?

    In the market for a new car? Don't pay MSRP. Save yourself both time and money. Find a great low price for your new car before you buy.

  • China food scandal spreads, drags in Starbucks, Burger King and McNuggets in Japan

    By Adam Jourdan SHANGHAI (Reuters) - The latest food scandal in China is spreading fast, dragging in U.S. coffee chain Starbucks, Burger King Worldwide Inc and others, as well as McDonald's products as far away as Japan. McDonald's Corp and KFC's parent Yum Brands Inc apologized to Chinese…

  • Play

    How to Build Your Own Annuity

    Instead of paying an insurance company, financial advisor Allan Roth recommends building your own "indexed annuity" that protects principal while giving market upside.

    WSJ Live
  • Herbalife Plummets

    Herbalife shares were down as much as 11%...

    Business Insider
  • What a Marijuana ETF Would Look Like

    The changes taking place around marijuana for medical use and for recreational use are the biggest in almost everyone’s lifetime. There are quite literally billions of dollars up for grabs for those who ...

    24/7 Wall St.
  • We Paid Off $90K of Debt in 4 Years

    One couple went into debt to give their son the education that he needed, eventually owing nearly $90K on credit cards. Here's how they paid it off.

  • Goldman Sachs: Here Are 25 Small-Cap Stocks to Buy

    While Goldman Sachs is cautious on small-cap stocks due to valuation concerns, the firm still finds some pockets of opportunity among individual names within the group.

    The Wall Street Journal
  • YOU could win $5,000.00 a Week "Forever"

    Publishers Clearing House will be ready to award $5,000.00 a Week "Forever" on August 28th. Click here to enter for free!

  • JetBlue pilot among 6 arrested in Boston drug bust

    BOSTON (AP) — A JetBlue pilot from Florida is among six people arrested by Boston police over the weekend in an investigation of drug dealing incidents near the Boston Common.

    Associated Press
  • How to avoid the biggest 401(k) mistakes

    Avoiding these four common, but serious, 401(k) mistakes can mean the difference between a great retirement and a shaky one.

  • Beef pollutes more than pork, poultry, study says

    WASHINGTON (AP) — Raising beef for the American dinner table does far more damage to the environment than producing pork, poultry, eggs or dairy, a new study says.

    Associated Press
  • Bodies from downed jet piled in boxcars in Ukraine

    TOREZ, Ukraine (AP) — Pro-Moscow rebels piled nearly 200 bodies from the downed Malaysian jetliner into four refrigerated boxcars Sunday in eastern Ukraine, and cranes at the crash scene moved big chunks of the Boeing 777, drawing condemnation from Western leaders that the rebels were tampering…

    Associated Press
  • Play

    U.S. Stocks Open Lower

    U.S. stocks kicked off the week in a decline, as investors paused following last week's run to record highs. MarketWatch's Victor Reklaitis joins Paul Vigna on the News Hub with the details, plus which stocks to keep an eye on. Photo: Getty

    WSJ Live
  • 10 Terms You Need to Know If You Ever Plan to Retire

    To secure the future you want, it’s important to plan for your retirement. Here are 10 essential retirement terms that can help you do that.

  • What's My Used Car Value?

    Black Book is an online leader in offering timely, independent & accurate used car values. Get trade-in value from Black Book & a new car price quote!

  • Microsoft CEO, Seeking Growth, Tells Managers to Step It Up

    The day Satya Nadella became Microsoft Corp.'s chief executive officer, he invited several dozen vice presidents to breakfast and had a simple, calm admonition for them: "Can you step it up?" The engineer's tone was a departure from the yelling and wild gesticulations favored by his salesman…

  • Philippine sect opens 'world's largest indoor arena'

    Philippine President Benigno Aquino presided over the opening on Monday of what is billed as the world's largest indoor stadium, erected by a politically-influential religious sect. The $175-million Philippine Arena, which can seat 55,000 people, was hailed as a showcase that will serve as a major…

  • What's Wrong With General Electric?

    Shares of General Electric (GE) fell 0.6% on Friday, despite what would seem to be good earnings news. Morgan Stanley's Nigel Coe and team explain why: Without a shadow of doubt, the number one question on our desk following General Electric's earnings was why the stock was so weak following…

  • Distraught Dutch mother: 'Send my children home'

    THE HAGUE, Netherlands (AP) — A distraught, grieving mother summed up a swelling mood of despair and anguish in the Netherlands on Sunday at faltering efforts to repatriate the bodies of loved ones killed in the downing of Malaysia Airlines Flight 17, appealing directly to Russian President…

    Associated Press
  • China's rich look abroad as home prices fall, others stay put

    By Xiaoyi Shao and Koh Gui Qing BEIJING (Reuters) - Rattled by falling home prices, some of the wealthiest Chinese are paring their property investments and turning to private equity or overseas holiday homes, a sign of fading hopes that the once red-hot market can bounce back any time soon. "There…

  • Top Analyst Upgrades and Downgrades: Apple, ARM, DaVita, GE, GoPro, Itron and Many More

    These are the top analyst upgrades, downgrades and initiations from Wall Street firms on Monday, July 21, 2014. They include Apple, ARM Holdings, DaVita Healthcare, General Electric, GoPro and Itron.

    24/7 Wall St.
  • Cheapest Las Vegas Hotels

    Compare rates from over 700,000 hotels to find the best deal on your Las Vegas room. Available now on trivago!