Friday, July 4, 2008, 10:16PM ET - U.S. Markets Closed for Independence Day.

Anya Kamenetz Generation Debt

Anya Kamenetz, Generation Debt

Welcome to Generation Debt

by Anya Kamenetz

Very Good (1014 Ratings)
3.0670598/5
Posted on Thursday, June 28, 2007, 12:00AM

I'm a 26-year-old freelance writer. In April 2004, when I was 23, I was assigned an article for the Village Voice as part of a series titled "Generation Debt: The New Economics of Being Young."

That summer, I sold a book on the same concept. So for the past three years, which happens to be my whole career, I've covered the economic challenges affecting Americans under 35. I blog about them, write articles about them, talk about them on TV and the radio, and visit college campuses to talk with students about them.

Just as important as diagnosing the problem, my job is figuring out how people our age can encounter and overcome these challenges. Maybe it's just because I'm a journalist, but I often find that the solution boils down to having the right information. So I'll need your help to make sure I'm asking and answering the right questions.

No Select Membership

First, I'll discuss what it means to be part of Generation Debt. See if any of this sounds familiar: You worked 20 hours a week while attending a public college, did internships and worked full time in the summer, and graduated after five or six years with five figures of student loans.

You have four figures of stubborn credit card debt, too, and your savings are miniscule. You moved to a big city with rents you could barely afford to find more job opportunities -- and you did, but those jobs were often short-term, freelance, or contract positions, without benefits or a truly livable wage.

Sometimes you spend too much of your hard-earned cash on stuff like electronics, vacations, concert tickets, and eating out, because you're only young once and you deserve to have fun. You may have changed careers a couple of times or headed back to graduate school (meaning more debt) to try to improve your prospects; you may have moved back in with your parents to save money. And a small but very important contingent of you even served (or are still serving) in Iraq and Afghanistan; these veterans often say they enlisted to pay for their education.

You're putting off marriage, starting a family, and buying a house. You're wondering when, exactly, you're going to feel settled, like a grownup. I know I do.

The Big Picture

To turn to the big picture for a second: Generation Debt means larger-than-ever-before levels of student loan debt (two-thirds of undergraduates now borrow an average of $19,300) and credit card debt (91 percent of final-year students have a card with an average balance of $2,864).

About half of us don't have any college experience, while less than a third end up with a four-year degree at a time when a B.A. seems like the minimum requirement for earning a middle-class income. (How to succeed without a degree is something I'll discuss in a future column). On average, young people from 25 to 34 are spending an amazing 16 percent more than they're earning.

Where the Money Goes

There's no getting around it -- we're the first generation of Americans who have fallen short of what our parents achieved economically by the same age. In fact, at the end of May, a study by the Pew Charitable Trusts and other big think-tanks found men in their 30s earning 12 percent less on average than men of their fathers' generation.

Wealth has also been redistributed from younger to older across generations. Recently, USA Today ran a front-page analysis of federal data showing that nearly all wealth created in the United States since 1989 has gone to households headed by people over 55, which have doubled in wealth. Meanwhile, households headed by younger folks have fallen behind or barely kept even with inflation.

Footing the Bill

I hate to say it, but being in Generation Debt isn't necessarily something we're going to grow out of. In just 10 years, this cohort (a fancy name for people who remember the same Top 40 songs as you) will be the bulk of the workforce. Meanwhile, the aging of the baby boom generation will change our nation's demographics permanently, calling the survival of Social Security and Medicare into question.

Though I don't know exactly how these federal budget dilemmas will be solved (does anyone?), the likely requirement that we pay higher taxes as workers to cover massive national retirement expenses constitutes a kind of generational debt as well, as economist Lawrence Kotlikoff has brilliantly discussed. Our current record national debt of over $8 trillion isn't helping things much.

What We're Not

I should also explain what Generation Debt isn't.

It's not about entitlement, or an unwillingness to pay our dues or struggle like young people always have when starting out. It's not about spending too much money on PlayStation 3, Starbucks, or "This Is Why I'm Hot" ringtones.

It's not about complaints like, "Oh, we have it worse than World War II or the Great Depression!" It's not about whining or blaming our problems on anyone else. It's not a situation that mainly affects rich people, white people, or college-educated people -- in fact, the average young person is none of these.

Stepping Up, Staying Informed

So if we're not whining, complaining, or blaming, what should we be doing? Stepping up. Making changes where we can in our own financial lives, and working for change where it'll help in the public arena.

Individually, your first responsibility is to stay informed. You should know what you owe now on your student loans and other debt, and have a plan to get square. You need to plan for frequent transitions -- from job to job, city to city, school to work and back -- because the unexpected is a constant in our stage of life.

You should also have a savings account and an Individual Retirement Account (IRA). Both will get you in the habit of saving, even if the amount seems pathetic right now. And you should have some short-term and long-term financial goals. This column will discuss how to establish them.

My Personal Finances

Finally, let me put my money where my mouth is for a second. I opened an IRA at 24 and have fully funded it for the past three years. It's in two no-load mutual funds. Aside from that annual contribution, I put 10 percent of each freelancing check I get into a savings account, plus I make four estimated income tax payments annually.

My short-term financial goal is to pay off my two credit cards and all bills in full each month, which I do electronically, and to try to repair my credit score, which got dinged from great to "fair" when I went out of the country last year and missed payments on one card for three months. (Dumb, I know.)

My long-term financial goals are to integrate my finances more fully with my new husband's, track our expenses better, and purchase a home in the next couple of years. I'd also like to stop spending too much money on travel and fancy groceries.

In terms of public policy, I see changes on the horizon in the regulation of debt and creditors for student loans, credit cards, mortgages, and bankruptcy. I'm hoping for changes in our health care system and other workplace issues that affect young people, too. I'll be covering all of these areas in this column as well. So bookmark me or put me in your RSS feed -- you won't regret it.

Rate This story

Very Good (1014 Ratings)
3/5
Sign-in to rate!

378 Comments

Showing comments 1-5 of 378Next >>
Sort: first to last
  • Adam K - Friday, October 26, 2007, 2:32AM ET  Report Abuse

    • Overall: 3/5

    Mrs. Kamenetz brings up a very valid and frightful point about our generation, yet fails to mention an additional integral point to the possible root causes of this phenomenon. Not only are Universities jacking up their tuition rates at multiples of the rates of inflation (not to mention average income), but taxes are being raised at any facet of our life that they can be. Let us forget not that the passage of the 16th Amendment (ushered in not even 100 years ago) has given the power of the government to impose taxes on anything that they want. So natually, many in our culture rack up this student loan debt, live up to our cultural standards of having to buy a house, not to mention dish out 30% of our income in taxes. After we get that roughly 30% taken out, we actually live on 70% which is also taxed by buying that home entertainment center, those new kicks you've always wanted, the soap on your sink and the phone that you use for work and personal reasons. Then being the proud, newly minted property owner, you learn your lesson in School board levies, "for the children." However, interestingly enough a short 3 year levy "for the children," ends up being another permanent tax hike. Health care is in a state of disrepair, I do agree with this. Although, on the flipside of the coin, should we really trust the government to take over our ability to acquire health care on our own? The track record of government responsibility with our money is horrendous; Social security as a prime example. Medicare as another, et cetera, et cetera. Strong taxation along with multi million dollar marketing campaigns on behalf of influential corporations entrench itself in a society teaching us that spending is ok, so long as you have the plastic. All is well so long as we are not forking over the cash right out of our wallets. Just judging the premise of the Alternative minimum tax, one can faily conclude that the better job you have, the more productive you are, the more you will be penalized through taxation. I challenge each and every one of you to take one paycheck and account for EVERY penny you spend. Througout the course of your couple weeks until your next paycheck, count how much in taxes you actually pay.Save reciepts. That means those clothes, the food, gas to get to work, everything. When you get your next check divide that out based on what you made before taxes and you will see an astonishing percentage. It's no wonder that Americans are sinking in debt. Maybe we should demand tax reform to the tone of what Colorado came up with: a taxpayer's bill of rights, which caps taxation. Pay off every ounce of debt you have. Get yourself into the stock market, an IRA, mutual funds, AND and employer sponsored 401k. Do all of them. If that means renting longer than you like, fine. If that means driving a crappy car that is paid off, fine. But for all that is holy, save your money and minimize your exposure to those influences that take your money! One last thing, if you think that getting into a home is a smart choice at this point in your life, try amoritizing a $200,000 loan and be ready to be appalled at the amount of interest that bank will charge you over the life of that loan in it's totality. Folks it's time to wake up and smell the stench that is our reality. Be prepared. Be insightful. Be inspired to be the master of your own finances.

  • Sean the Politico - Sunday, September 9, 2007, 1:27PM ET  Report Abuse

    • Overall: 3/5

    I'm 28 years old and feel the emphasis should about generation debt should be about the number of jobs and careers we will have. I've had 10 employers and 3 careers in dramatically different industries. I live in a unfashionable outer-borough neighborhood in NYC but have worked/lived in 4 other states chasing career advancement opportunities. The old story of how 30-40 years ago people could expect to work for the same company for life had been replaced 15-20 years ago with a career constantly jumping from company to company. The current paradigm though is the current young generation can expect to change careers and industries multiple times during their adult life. I've notice the first 4 articles you've written were all about college hopefully you get out from underneath that and start writing for and about young workers. To all the haters that have posted their arrogant and self-righteous criticism and bragging about how much money they already have; well I guess this column is not directed to you and you don't need any advice so write your own column.

  • El Viejo - Wednesday, August 29, 2007, 12:35PM ET  Report Abuse

    • Overall: 1/5

    wow .... looks like it IS about too much Playstation, Starbucks, and fance ringtones after all, isn't it .... this should be more interesting than Penelope, but still .... in the end Gen-Y will inherit a ton of real estate, the greatest wealth transfer in the history of mankind, then what ?

  • cmaldoon2001 - Wednesday, July 18, 2007, 4:37PM ET  Report Abuse

    • Overall: 4/5

    I think that enough people in your same Demographic will read this column to make it worthwhile. I would hope that as well as addressing those issue for people striving to put their financial house in order, you can also offer something to those who have a bit more of a solid footing but are still looking to move up. (23, no credit debt, no student loans, Saving substantially for retirement, saving for house downpayment {but living in CA and thus far from that})

  • William S - Wednesday, July 18, 2007, 2:17PM ET  Report Abuse

    • Overall: 4/5

    Thank you Students are often presented with a total financial aid package with out a full understanding of how difficult it will be to pay back and live at the same time. It "rings" like subprime mortgage business

Showing comments 1-5 of 378Next >>

More from Anya Kamenetz

Read the Generation Debt Book

According to economics professor Laurence J. Kotlikoff, Generation Debt offers "a truly gripping account of how young Americans are being ground down by low wages, high taxes, huge student loans, sky-high housing prices, not to mention the impending retirement of their baby boomer parents." Generation Debt will inspire you to take charge of your financial future.

Read more from Anya Kamenetz here and here.

More from Yahoo! Sources

  • CNN Money
  • Consumer Reports
  • Kiplinger
  • The Motley Fool
  • Business Week
  • Wall Street Journal

Sponsored Links

Earn From 3.04% to 3.35%
With AAA rated, GE Capital Corp. Not an offer of securities for sale.
www.geinterestplus.com
Forex Currency Trading
Trade Forex Online with GFT. Free Practice Account. Try Risk-Free Now.
www.GFTforex.com
Countrywide® Home Loans
No Closing Cost Refi Options. No Points or Processing Fees. Call Now.
www.Countrywide.com
stock information at Scottrade®
Trade stocks for just $7. Unlimited shares. Trade like the pros.
www.Scottrade.com
Currency Options Made Easy
See How To Turn Every $1 Into $30. Free 25 Page Report.
www.MoneyAndMarkets.com
real estate Investments
Our experience brings superior investment returns to savvy investors.
www.wangardadvisors.com