Friday, August 8, 2008, 2:30PM ET - U.S. Markets close in 1 hour and 30 minutes.

How-to Guides

Your step-by-step online resource

Very Good (61 Ratings)
3.213114/5

Saving Strategies: Buying vs. Leasing a Car

Leasing is a popular but expensive route to driving away with the car of your dreams. This report covers the ins and outs of leases and provides sources of information to evaluate a lease.

Before You Start

  • Estimate the number of miles you will likely drive each year.
  • Consider whether you really need to replace your current car — particularly if it is already paid for and runs well.
  • Ask people you know for referrals to reputable auto dealers.
  • Consider how a new vehicle might affect your budget. For example, will insurance or fuel costs rise significantly?
1

Saving Strategies: Buying vs. Leasing a Car

With the sticker price of many automobiles now exceeding $25,000, more and more Americans are considering leasing as a viable financing alternative. In general, leasing a new car will end up costing you more over time than buying one. So why do so many people lease cars? Leasing can result in a lower initial cash outlay and lower monthly payments than a typical new car purchase. Through leasing, drivers can enjoy more car for their cash. The potential cost of that luxury, however, can be high.
Back to top

2

How a Lease Works

The cost of the lease will depend on the sales price of the car, the interest rate, the lease period, and whether the lease is closed- or open-ended. With an open-end lease, you enjoy unlimited miles, but if the resale value of the car at the end of the lease is less than the agreed-to amount, you must make up the difference. A closed-end lease imposes a mileage limit, usually 12,000 to 15,000 miles a year. If you average more than this, you'll have to pay a per-mile surcharge (typically 8 to 15 cents a mile) at the end of the lease.

The terms and conditions of the lease typically hold you responsible for the care and condition of the car. Most leases require some initial down payment, but the actual amount will vary from dealer to dealer and car to car. To see how a lease can lower your cash outlay, consider the following example: You have $2,000 in cash and your heart is set on a car stickered at $35,000. Buying the car with such a low down payment would mean monthly payments of more than $775 for four years, assuming an annual percentage rate (APR) of 6%. With a lease, however, your monthly payments could fall to just $516, assuming a 40% residual value and 6% APR.

Other factors that affect the monthly payment are the vehicle sticker price and, for an open-end lease, the expected vehicle resale value. It is a good idea to negotiate the car price before asking for a lease. The higher the price, the higher the lease cost. A higher resale value will lower your lease cost, but you may end up with a large termination fee if the resale value is unrealistic.
Back to top

3

Single-Payment Leases

Paying the entire lease amount in a single up-front payment can save you significantly on lease payments. The up-front payment reduces default risk and administrative costs, allowing the lessor to pass the cost savings along. Before choosing a single-payment lease, however, consider the potential opportunity cost of losing the use of that money in the interim. Single-payment leases are typically preferred by those leasing premium cars and who travel frequently between residences in several cities. For these individuals, making regular monthly payments on time may simply be too inconvenient.
Back to top

4

Is a Lease Right for You?

When you lease a car, you pay only for that portion of the car that you use -- in other words, if you want it for two years, you'll pay only for two years' worth, without then having to resell the car or trade it in. If short-term use is your goal, a lease may make the most sense. However, if you will always need a car, but it doesn't have to be a new car, a lease is an expensive option.

At the end of the lease term, you'll have to replace the car with another lease, and another series of payments. When you purchase a car, you own it long after the monthly payments end.

If savings is a priority over convenience, and you absolutely must have a car but can't afford a new one, consider purchasing a used car rather than leasing a new one. While you won't have the new-car luxury, the purchase price -- and your down-payment -- will be substantially lower. And if you buy a car under six years old, you'll be able to stretch out payments over three to four years. If you buy the car from a dealer, you may also be able to purchase an extended warranty that will cover major repairs for several years, giving you some protection against buying a "lemon."

If you must have a new car, and leasing is the only way you can afford it, don't lease as much car as you possibly can. Shop around for the best interest rate. Although some dealers will not disclose the factors they use to arrive at the lease price, there are tools available that you can use to discover these variables.
Back to top

Summary

  • A lease will cost you more than purchasing a car.
  • A lease will typically result in a lower initial cash outlay and lower monthly payments. But at the end of the lease, you don't own the car.
  • An open-end lease allows you unlimited miles, but you must make up the difference between the agreed-upon resale value and the actual value when the lease is terminated.
  • A closed-end lease imposes a mileage limit. If you drive over this amount, you will pay a per-mile surcharge.
  • Paying the entire lease price upfront can save you significantly on lease payments.

Checklist

  • Ask each auto dealer you visit to provide written details regarding prices, warranties, financing arrangements, etc.
  • Check the Blue Book value of any vehicle you are considering to make sure you'll be paying a fair price.
  • If you already own a vehicle, decide whether to sell it yourself or offer it to a dealer as a trade-in.
  • Don't let an auto dealer convince you to spend more for a car you don't need.

Rate This how-to guide

Very Good (61 Ratings)
3/5
Sign-in to rate!

16 Comments

Showing comments 1-5 of 16Next >>
Sort: first to last
  • Yahoo! Finance User - Wednesday, October 17, 2007, 9:34PM ET  Report Abuse

    • Overall: 3/5

    Here's the problem, I hear from all of you that a car is an asset - this is true. But it is a depreciating asset. So unless you plan to own your car until it's fully depreciated and beyond, you're actually better off leasing. Why? Because you don't have the inefficiency cost of selling your car and you can invest the difference. With a lease, you simply pay for the depreciation and in 3-5 years when you're ready for another car, it technically should be the equivalent as if you sold the new car you bought. The benefit? Well, instead of tying up your money in those high car loan payments, you can invest that $200 difference in something else - an appreciating asset during those 5 years. You get a new car instead of a 5 year old beater that you will probably trade in after 5 years (10 year old car). And you end up paying the same amount.

  • fairnessman - Wednesday, October 17, 2007, 7:43PM ET  Report Abuse

    • Overall: 3/5

    Smart people need dumb people to buy new cars so we have used cars to buy.

  • rocky - Wednesday, October 17, 2007, 6:01PM ET  Report Abuse

    • Overall: 3/5

    My views are exactly same as vaderman...A car is just another utility and i guess a smart investor wud never spend money on something tht depreciates in value....I thought the same way when i bought mine..i make close to 55 grand and i am not 25 yet....my second hand car saves me a lot of money w.r.t insurance, tax etc....i wud rather invest my money in stocks or some real estate... peace..

  • bdettwyler - Wednesday, October 17, 2007, 4:38PM ET  Report Abuse

    • Overall: 4/5

    Short, consise, to the point. May be the 1st time I read such an article that wasn't full of the author's personal rantings. You point out that while leasing payments are typically lower than financing, leasing is not an alternative for folks who can't afford a particular car at a typical 4 or 5 year loan. Credit worthiness and history are much stricter when one leases because the car belongs to the bank, not the driver. Don't forget GAP insurance. Most lenders today include it in the payment, but still check to make sure. Not getting it can cost you a fortune if the car is destroyed. One never builds equity when one leases. 1 pay leases are a great option for folks who have a lot of cash. But most salespeople have no idea how a 1 pay lease works, let alone how to calculate it or even present it. If the lender doesn't offer it, look for a multiple security deposit option. You'll get a lower rate because you're giving the bank your cash that they'll use for the term of the lease, which means a lower payment, and you get it all back at lease end (you still make monthly payments). And NEVER give the dealer any more cash than is required to get out the door - 1st payment, security deposit and his fees. Any cash "down" ( money to lower the sale price to reduce the payment) is lost. not a good tradeoff. And finally, the best reason to lease is - any good accountant will tell you to always minimize your financial exposure in depreciating assets. Nothing depreciates like a car.

  • Dale - Wednesday, October 17, 2007, 4:00PM ET  Report Abuse

    • Overall: 4/5

    Yes folks the bottom line is leasing costs you more than buying. It can also be "adictive". You never own the can, therefore never have a trade-in to use as a down payment on the next car. What really "bites" you in the rear is that if you sutain a scratch or dent or any other damage while leasing it, you will pay to have it repaired when you turn the vehicle in. If you owned it, well you have more options. You can keep the car and drive it with the dent.......sell it outright.....trade it in as-is.......or fix the dent and sell or trade. Many more options.......And less expensive. Leases get the person who has NO Money into a car for Tax, and Title, but usually has higher Hidden Internal Interest Rates than alot of other Lenders offer. No tax tax deduction on leases either. Interst Borowed on a Home Equity Loan to purchase the vehicle is fully tax deductible if you itemize your deductions.

Showing comments 1-5 of 16Next >>

Rates

See today's average rates across the country.

More from Yahoo! Sources

  • CNN Money
  • Consumer Reports
  • Kiplinger
  • The Motley Fool
  • Business Week
  • Wall Street Journal

Sponsored Links

Trade Forex Online with GFT
Free Practice Account & Training. Trade 24 hrs-a-day 5.5 days a week.
www.GFTforex.com
Countrywide® Home Loans
Govt-insured mortgages up to $729K in select areas-Lower rate options.
www.Countrywide.com
Earn From 3.04% to 3.35%
With AAA rated, GE Capital Corp. Not an offer of securities for sale.
www.geinterestplus.com
Fast Way To Debt Free
We Get You Debt Free Fast. 20k Min - Specialize in High Debts.
www.NationalDebtAssistance.com
Private Student Loans
Pay for college now. Defer payments until later.
www.betterstudentloan.com
Stop the Paday loan cycle! We Can help
Consolidate and save. Stop the interest payments. Save thousands.
www.PDLAssistance.com