There's no contradiction here,but there's a tug of war going on. The option buyers want the stock move up huge and the option writers (MM) want to keep this stock right around $5 so they can keep all the premium.
Once this hits $5 then it is done in the february options. Then it is either off to $7.50 or $2.50. With the options that have been purchased $7.50 is more likely. So I agree with the first comment you are an idiot.