Sorry, if you do some DD, you will discover many reasons this stock could have tanked, most of which I explained on this board. It took it's big drop yesterday because many other investors felt the same. I have always liked this stock fundamentally and explained originally that I would buy it back when it dropped. The reason you are confused is because I am not a long term trader and as the analysts often do I change my mind from one day to the next depending on oil, jobs reports,market sentiment ect. Incidentally the whisper no for WSM was 27. Stocks that beat whisper numbers often go on for further gains.