% | $
Quotes you view appear here for quick access.

Petróleo Brasileiro S.A. - Petrobras Message Board

you are viewing a single comment's thread.

view the rest of the posts
  • bzusa6 bzusa6 Jan 1, 2013 4:01 PM Flag

    The Left's Dirty Little Secret: The Middle Class and Poor Pay For the Entitlement State

    A dollar left in a taxpayers pocket will always provide more potential economic impact than if taken by the govt - and that economic impact will be felt in a very positive way by Chinese manufactures.
    It's a global economy, and Americans are consumers first.
    The majority of the $600 rebate from a few years back went to banks (pay off debt) and to buy consumer goods, the majority of which were produced in Asia.
    the direct positive economic impacts of that "rebate" were felt by US retail employees, US bank employees, and foreign manufactures, not necessarily in that order
    Gov money hires bureaucrats, consultants, construction workers, teachers, and researchers directly, then trickles down to the Chinese.
    If your taxes are lower, you ill not invest in American projects, you will buy more foreign manufactured products.
    If your taxes are higher, essentially you (the governed) have hired a bunch of marginally productive and very productive US residents who pay taxes here and create service jobs here.
    One makes for some folks having more stuff and but fewer US jobs.
    The other makes for more jobs, more folks having some stuff, and an educated, healthy family traveling about on smooth roads or using quiet wi-fi enabled rapid transit.

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • That is the silliest reasoning I've heard yet.
      By that token, we should be rushing madly to raise taxes and expand government as big as possible. In fact, every county in the world that carried a trade deficit would prosper by doing the same by your reasoning.
      For one thing, by your post, you assume that 100% of disposable income goes to purchase Chinese products. That assumption is highly flawed. Wallmart is the largest employer in the US, so Chinese manufactured products still benefit the workforce in the US. So why does it stand to reason that the government employees can return the money back to the economy(or to China for that matter) any more than Walmart employees ?

      I just don't see more gov. jobs being the answer. I've said it here before and I'll say it again, the government can not add anything to the economy that it didn't already take out.

    • "If your taxes are lower, you ill not invest in American projects, you will buy more foreign manufactured products."

      You are just thinking abou the spending/consumption side of things and that's only accurate to the extent tht all goods and services are from offshore and that's not qyuite true.

      Lower taxes also encourages domestic investment.

4.93-0.19(-3.71%)Nov 27 1:02 PMEST