Tue, Sep 23, 2014, 5:25 PM EDT - U.S. Markets closed

Recent

% | $
Quotes you view appear here for quick access.

Assured Guaranty Ltd. Message Board

  • rain_man_in_finance rain_man_in_finance Apr 28, 2011 7:42 AM Flag

    must read for ago

    New briefs back banks fighting MBIA restructuring
    BY Reuters
    — 2:30 PM ET 04/26/2011
    * Scholar backs banks fighting MBIA (MBI

    Loading...
    ) restructuring
    * MBIA (MBI) confident Court of Appeals will affirm ruling
    NEW YORK, April 26 (Reuters Legal) - A well-known legal scholar on Tuesday called on New York state's highest court to revive a $5 billion lawsuit brought by a group of banks challenging the restructuring of bond insurer MBIA (MBI

    Loading...
    ) .
    Arthur Miller, a professor at New York University School of Law, joined Patrick J. Borchers, a professor at Creighton University School of Law in Nebraska, in making the argument in court papers filed with the New York Court of Appeals in Albany.
    They said a state appeals panel decision in January dismissing the case posed a "grave threat to the coherence and fairness of New York law and is unconstitutional in its application."
    In 2009, the New York State Insurance Department approved MBIA's (MBI

    Loading...
    ) move to split its municipal bond business from its structured-finance operations. As part of the restructuring, $5 billion in cash was moved from MBIA Insurance Corp into a new entity called National Public Finance Guarantee Corp.
    A coalition of banks, including UBS AG (UBS

    Loading...
    ) and Bank of America Corp (BAC

    Loading...
    ) , sued MBIA (MBI

    Loading...
    ), claiming the split had stripped assets from MBIA Insurance Corp that could potentially leave it unable to pay out insurance claims.
    In January, a sharply divided appeals panel held that the banks could not sue MBIA (MBI

    Loading...
    ) directly, but instead should challenge the State Insurance Department under a separate proceeding known as Article 78.
    The banks are pursuing the Article 78 proceeding, but have also asked the Court of Appeals to overturn the January ruling.
    Miller's and Borchers' court filing on Tuesday was an amicus brief in support of the banks' appeal. They argued that the insurance superintendent's approval of the restructuring was not a formal agency proceeding and it should not preclude the banks from suing MBIA (MBI

    Loading...
    ).
    Upholding the January decision would mean that "thousands upon thousands of informal determinations made by state agencies would have binding effect in judicial proceedings," the brief said.
    MBIA (MBI

    Loading...
    ) believes the Court of Appeals will affirm the January ruling by the appeals panel, a spokesman for MBIA (MBI

    Loading...
    ) said. "None of these proposed briefs adds anything new to the legal issues before the Court of Appeals," he said.
    The New York Civil Liberties Union, two nonprofit legal service groups and a group of investment funds also submitted amicus briefs supporting the banks.
    In an interview, Robert J. Giuffra Jr. of Sullivan & Cromwell, the lead attorney for the banks, said the amicus briefs confirm that there is more at stake "than just between the banks and MBIA (MBI

    Loading...
    )." The issues affect all parties in New York state who want to litigate cases that in "any way touch upon government approval or review," he added.
    The Court of Appeals is slated to hear arguments on May 31.
    Meanwhile, the Article 78 proceeding filed by the banks is pending before Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Barbara Kapnick.
    The case is ABN Amro Bank NV v. MBIA Inc. (MBI

    Loading...
    ), 601475-09. (Reporting by Noeleen Walder of Reuters Legal; Editing by Gary Hill)

 
AGO
22.47-0.40(-1.75%)Sep 23 4:02 PMEDT

Trending Tickers

i
Trending Tickers features significant U.S. stocks showing the most dramatic increase in user interest in Yahoo Finance in the previous hour over historic norms. The list is limited to those equities which trade at least 100,000 shares on an average day and have a market cap of more than $300 million.