You're confusing the fact that he got correct information and acted on it with the fact that it was illegal. You're probably just upset because he found that GMCR was overvalued and acted on that information. And he was right.
It's kinda like someone comin to your house and burning it down....then saying it's your fault because you built it out of flammable materials.... Come on man... You are being smarmy and stupid... Einhorn is a criminal.
He was right in the sense that GMCR did have a bad qrt. Yet he got his lemmings and promoted about how bad it was. he basically made a mountain out of a mole hill. Stock never should drop that far in earnings. Not for a penny off. This stocks fair value is in the 70's with a good qrt being 80's. Any kind of really blow out earnings this baby will take off.