Problem with your reasoning doc is that karma always gets you in the end, what goes around comes around. So, if the stock is doing well but the company is a POS, eventually the stock will reflect the company. Are you going to be holding the POS stock when that happens?
First of all, karma is a bunch of garbage talk coming from someone grasping at strings and has no place in investing. It's like buying a stock base on what phase the moon is in. Just stupid talk. Secondly, I'll be long gone before your "karma" kicks in.