What I am hearing you say is that they guided lower because the stock was taking it on the chin and would have, no matter what. That's profound. Why do you think it would have taken it on the chin no matter what?
If management was fraudulently understating future earnings as you say, should we expect class action law suits soon? I guess if there is a "nice" earning beat as you say, then we can expect law suits. Interesting take, if not delusional. I don't see how that helps the share price.