Wells Fargo - Best Potential Suitor
Wells Fargo (WFC) is my choice for buying either CBSH or UMBF. This assumes that either CBSH or UMBF want to sell out. Different branches of the Kemper Family control both banks and call the shots. I think CBSH would sell out before UMBF, but I don't think it will happen anytime soon.
Wells Fargo has a big hole in its geographic coverage in St. Louis and Kansas City. Either CBSH or UMBF would be a good fit. UMBF would command a much higher price since it is very conservative and there is greater potential to improve its lackluster operations. Now that the goodwill rules will be eliminated starting this year, I'm expecting to see a pick up of merger activity this year.
Just my thoughts...
Full Disclosure: I own both CBSH and UMBF (long positions). I do not own any WFC.