State Sen. Jackie Speier (D-Hillsborough) said Shumake's death and statistics about doctors' spotty records illustrate a system in crisis.
"It's appalling," said Speier, who has joined Sen. Gloria Romero (D-Los Angeles) in investigating the troubled prison system. "In addition to causing tragedies for inmates, this incompetence leads to lawsuits that cost taxpayers even more."
Today's hearing on medical care adds another dimension to what has been a difficult year for the youth and adult prison system. Despite new leadership and a governor who says he is committed to reforming corrections, the state has weathered allegations of inmate abuse, corruption and other scandals that have prompted a federal judge to threaten a takeover of California's 32 adult prisons.
The disclosures about doctors come as healthcare costs are soaring. This year, the Department of Corrections will spend more than $900 million treating 164,000 convicts, accounting for 20% of the prison budget. Care is provided by 302 staff doctors, whose annual salaries average $177,000, as well as scores of physicians who work under contract with the state.
Corrections officials acknowledged that previous hiring practices failed to screen out some problem doctors, and that managers at each prison had their own, often inadequate standards.
"We really had various fiefdoms in the 32 institutions," said Dr. Renee Kanan, acting chief of healthcare. Instead of seeking versatile physicians with a background in primary care medicine, managers hired doctors who simply met the state's minimum qualifications, she said. But recently, "we've raised the bar," she said. Now the state requires applicants to undergo thorough screening and a test of their abilities.
In addition, the department agreed last week to a court order that will subject every prison doctor to a rigorous evaluation by outside experts to determine whether they are competent. Physicians with minor shortcomings would be given remedial training, while those who fail could be fired. Kanan said she expects some doctors will flunk, but could not predict how many.
She would not provide a cost estimate, because negotiations are still underway with UC San Diego, the likely testing site. An aide to Speier, however, said the first phase of screening would cost at least $1.5 million, not counting any supplemental training.