Now that the full Q1 results are out and the stock has begun to head south, perhaps some folks will finally "get religion."
Why overpay?
History shows that this is a good solid $20-$25 stock. The last time it headed for $30 was 1998 ... and it saw $10 to $11 two years later. IMO we could be heading for a repeat or worse.
Realestate stocks, especially the refi business (title insurance), are going to spend the next 5+ years in the toilet. With the 10 year bond now up a full point in just the past two months, I wouldn't be surprised to see ITIC trade at or below book value over concern about Q2 results, then on down to $20 in the second half of the year. Anywhere below $18 or so I'll be a buyer. But not at twice that!