As I have stated several times in the past this was not my comparison these were as listed by the Wall Street Journal. Even believe I gave the date and page number. Sorry, but normally I do tend to believe what the WSJ prints over some one posting on a board.
However, I do definitley agree that the returns on these two financials do not compare.
Hope someone does check out the comparables from year to year and gets back to the board.The number of comparables seem to vary from year to year too.