% | $
Quotes you view appear here for quick access.

Synaptics Inc. Message Board

  • risorjimento risorjimento Mar 2, 2010 10:19 PM Flag

    Apple Inc.s Lawsuit against HTC???

    Will this have an impact on Syna stock?

    As HTC is being sued for touch screen control, hardware and software control and is seeking a ban on phones that Synaptics are in such as the Nexus one and phones using the Windows Mobile system.

    SortNewest  |  Oldest  |  Most Replied Expand all replies
    • AAPL is trying to bully its way to get more market for its products with its $40 billion cash. I am not too worry here since this patent stuff always finds a way to work itself out. Moreover, I believe SYNA uses its own patents in its products.

    • (...)
      As with all patent cases, a decision or settlement could hinge on whether lawyers for HTC — and perhaps Google, if they decide to help — can find “prior art” that demonstrates Apple’s innovations were not all that novel.

      Such a task may not be that difficult. Palm sold touch-based mobile phones for years before the introduction of the iPhone, and is believed to have a large portfolio of patents. Synaptics, based in Santa Clara, Calif., is also a major owner of intellectual property related to touch screens.

      These companies, and others, may now become valuable acquisition targets as the big players look to improve their position in the coming legal battles and the inevitable countersuits.


    • UPDATE 8-Apple sues HTC over phones with Google software
      10:07 pm ET 03/02/2010- Reuters
      * Apple claims HTC infringed on 20 iPhone patents

      * Suit filed with ITC and in U.S. District court

      * HTC's touchscreen smartphones use Google software

      * HTC sees no impact on Q1 outlook

      * HTC shares recover after falling 3 pct in early trade
      SAN FRANCISCO, March 2 (Reuters) - Apple Inc sued Taiwan's HTC Corp <2498.TW>, which makes touchscreen smartphones using Google software, accusing it of infringing 20 hardware and software patents related to the iPhone.

      Even though the suit did not name Google Inc as a defendant, Apple's move was viewed by many analysts as proxy for an attack on the Internet company, whose Nexus One smartphone is manufactured by HTC.

      "I think this is kind of an indirect lawsuit against Google," said Kaufman Bros analyst Shaw Wu.

      Apple's suit was filed with both the U.S. International Trade Commission and the U.S. District Court in Delaware on Tuesday, and seeks to prohibit HTC from selling, marketing or distributing infringing products in the United States.

      The complaint filed with the ITC cited Google's Nexus One, which was launched in January, and other HTC phones such as the Hero, Dream and myTouch -- which run on Google's Android mobile operating system -- as infringing products.

      In a statement, a Google spokeswoman said: "We are not a party to this lawsuit. However, we stand behind our Android operating system and the partners who have helped us to develop it."

      • 1 Reply to ham1198
      • HTC said in a statement that it was looking at the filings.

        "HTC values patent rights and their enforcement but is also committed to defending its own technology innovations," spokesman Keith Nowak said.

        In a statement in Taipei on Wednesday, HTC added that it had not had the opportunity to investigate the suit.

        "Until we have had this opportunity, we are unable to comment on the validity of the claims being made against HTC."

        In a separate statement to the Taiwan stock exchange, HTC said it will not see any impact on its financial outlook for the first quarter from the lawsuit.

        By 0250 GMT, HTC shares lost 1.4 percent in Taipei in a broader market <.TWII> up 0.4 percent. The stock had fallen as much as 3 percent in early trade.

        "The news is having some impact on HTC's shares but lawsuits are quite common among tech firms and I would say it is just a threat from Apple this time," said John Chiu, a fund manager at Taiwan's Fuh Hwa Securities Investment Trust.

        "However, HTC is not a good buy in the longer term since its margins will be coming under pressure when competition intensifies."


        Apple's move comes amid fierce competition in the smartphone market, as new players angle for a piece of the fast-growing segment.

        Mark Simpson, a patent attorney with law firm Saul Ewing in Philadelphia, said HTC made for an easier target than Google.

        "It's probably simpler for them to go after the company making the infringing goods, which is HTC. It's easier to prove at this point," he said.

        MKM Partners analyst Tero Kuittinen agreed.

        "HTC is an optimal target for Apple -- it's a relatively small vendor with a weak brand. It may be easier to push around than Samsung <005930.KS> (which also makes Android smartphones). One question here is whether Apple can intimidate operators to back away from new HTC products by flashing the possibility of litigation trouble."

        Apple said HTC "knowingly induce(s) users of accused HTC Android products" to infringe on a number of Apple's patents, some dating back to the mid-1990s. They cover user interface processes and other software and hardware components.

        "We think competition is healthy, but competitors should create their own original technology, not steal ours," Apple Chief Executive Steve Jobs said in a news release.

        An Apple spokesman declined to comment beyond the complaints.

        The iPhone held a 14.4 percent smartphone market share in 2009, according to research group Gartner.

85.13-0.56(-0.65%)Apr 27 4:00 PMEDT