Yes if that's the case then maybe bbry drops for a while and if its not the case the analyst should burn, there needs to be accountability, its not legal to lie if someone losses wealth over that lie. His statement is ridiculous do you really think there are more returns then sales. Its a niche market with a loyal following and the Q10 will show this (people like the keyboard), there's no way I believe returns are greater than sales, no way possible! Not only that but they have plenty of cash and the business no one talks about the service side alone is worth as much as what bbry is trading at, no brainer if the market don't intimidate you
Look, BB has more to lose by calling this guy/firm out if they know he might be right. They know it's all BS and it will be proven with the next earnings report. Sure we may go lower in the meantime but it won't be for any legitimate reason.