Here is where Yahoo is wrong as they indicate EPS $3.94/share. They came with this wrong number because they multiplied the number of customers ( 24 mill. ) NOT the number of accounts ( 36 mill. ) with $7.99 which gives you $2.3 bill./year. They simply ignored that 12 mill. customers have 2 accounts and pay 2x$7.99/month.
Yahoo shows under Analysts Estimates an EPS of $4.63 ( this year ) and $6.83 ( next year ). It means that the P/E is 33.47 ( this year ) and 22.69 ( next year ). In any case it's lower then the 39.38 indicated under Summary.