The Madison Square Garden Company Message Board

*** SPAM!

Sentiment: Hold

I noticed in the past on up days, SGY would be down. But on down days, SGY would be up. Looking at the chart, we have been down the last few days. Hopefully this will trend up soon. I for the life of me, do not know how this companies PPS has fallen below $20.00. Natty is only down a penny for what I have seen. Makes no sense then again, this whole market makes no sense to me…

Sentiment: Hold

DUDE, you do mean disrespect or you wouldn't single me out so don't give me that nice guy routine #$%$!
What is hilarious, the fact that prior to this week, I haven't posted in 4 months but yet I have seen people on this board RIP Stone Energy apart. I mean, look at the title of this thread. Yet, you say NOTHING to the person who refers to SGY as DOG-$hit nor do I ever recall you calling out others who have torn into this company. Yet you seem to single me out for whatever reason you have. That is funny to me (sarcasm)
As far as your cheap shot of me my buying on emotion. Lets see, since Sept 2012, this companies stock has tanked over 38%, yes 38% so excuse me for being very emotional and upset back then when I voiced my frustration about the company and the stocks continued decline. My venting here was tame comparmed to what I have read the past 4 months or even prior to that. I NEVER once bash SGY or disrespect ANYONE on this board. I have always been cordial to those on these boards but people like you make me sick! and not want to post...
As far as my comment today, YES it is a painful stock to hold and my sentiment hold will not change! I bought this week hoping for a bounce and a nice profit heading into earnings. And I am in the red once again. If I get back what i have lost when I last sold, I will sell and be gone until I see a better opportunity here. I unlike you have not been holding a bag at all time highs. Maybe that is why you single me out. And for the record, yes I did sell back in January, and I took a nasty loss but I got into VLO (as I commented on 4 months back) and made a nice return. Now I am back to make up for the money i lost here earlier.
Let's get one thing straight, I am not going to engage in a battle of words but I will NOT let you attack me and keep quiet any longer. I took the better road and did not comment months back when you and another board member (probably you under another ID) attacked me, not today!

Sentiment: Hold

Well, this just proves your facts are twisted and incorrect. First off, I NEVER bought SGY @ $34.00. That post was from WNR and my average in WNR recently, not SGY. WNR a great company by the way which I have FULL confidence in. My comment about this being painful stock to hold is the truth no matter how low your PPS average is. Dont believe me, look at the chart from 9/2012 until now. The comment was just that, a comment based on my past being in SGY. I wasnt trying to bash. I wish nothing but the best for SGY. Since you like to dig into my history, look up when I express my love for this company back in Feb 2012. I bumped the post but Yahoo took it down. IMO, you took my comment out of line and again come at me yet say nothing to the true bash posts. I guess that might be you using another user name trying to show your true feelings, maybe, maybe not. I no longer care. I am ending this today. Good luck to you, but I do not nor will not read anything you write on this board any longer...

Tully

Sentiment: Hold

@ redleaf9298. Thanks for the response! I admit, I did not know about that until I read your post. Being at work, it was hard for me to take the time to do some DD. Did a quick check on my lunch break and now that i am home, will read up. I have made nice profits here before and wanted to get back in on the way up into earnings. I thought I was getting a great deal today and after just my luck, it tanked after I bought long...LOL! I am very surprised WNR fell over 7% today. Percentage wise, we fell harder than VLO. I am not a big believer in A/H trading but I do hope the 2.5% carries into tomorrow and we can gain back some if not all of today's loss. Again, thanks as i do appreciate it...

Good Luck All,

Tully

Sentiment: Hold

And to think this was a $40.00 a few years back. WTH happened to this company?

Natural Gas is up a nickle. It is going to be a long day...

Sentiment: Hold

I couldn't agree more. I am back in. This has to be the bottom for now, NO?

Sentiment: Hold

Well, it was down now in the green...

Sentiment: Hold

Here's another who like me, has been frustrated by the direction of this company..

Sept 14 2012 - The PPS was $27.65
April 19 2013 - The PPS is $17.68

It is very painful owing this stock...

Sentiment: Hold

I averaged down but have to admit, it is scary holiding when a stock is close to it's 52 week low. The recent drop in the market could continue next week with APPL reporting earnings. Holding long and hoping for the best!

GLTA

Sentiment: Hold

Pal, your comments are FOS just like you. I have every right to express my opinions on a open message board. Like I previously stated, my comments were tame compared to what I have read. And there is more than one person who bashed here not just this so called short who flipped. Your comments are not only smart #$%$, but just plain rude. I love how you end it w/have a good weekend while taking a cheap shot at me. And thank for the one star on my posts... GFYS!!

Thanks for the thumbs down MORON!

Sentiment: Hold

Here is one of my posts "whining" as n2profits states. Funny, I didnt create this thread...

I for one have bought enough. Never fails, always in the red...

GLTA,

Tully

Sentiment: Hold

Lets see, this guys here rips SGY and N2profits and Quest are no where to be found. By the way, congrats on your short. If you made some cash, good for you

Yes it does hurt when a company that one (myself) was so high on in the past, doesnt meet shareholders expectations. But becareful, there are PRICKS on this board that hate the truth!