Tell us what you think about the new Article Page. Send us feedback
Part I of this article looked at the recent sharp rise and fall of the solar sector and its peers, looking forward two to three years to identify future trends in pricing, demand and what it takes to survive the coming industry shakeout. In Part II of this series, we are looking for some of the likely winners and losers in the fast-changing industry.
As I noted last time, the Claymore/MAC Global Solar Energy
The charm of owning the TAN ETF is that you have broad-based sector exposure and don't need to make any company-specific bets. The downside is that the ETF will be dragged down by the industry laggards, which, as I noted in Part I, may not have the capital, market share or pricing power to survive the next six to 12 months, which could be a tough time for the industry. (The ETF's major holdings are in the table at the bottom of this page.)
If you want to stick with the industry's strongest player, take a close look at First Solar
As noted in Part I, thin-film solar lacks the energy conversion rate of silicon - that is, the amount of sunlight that it converts into energy -- but it is cheaper to build and install. As a result, the payback on using thin-film is usually far quicker.
First Solar's size has already yielded a wide range of scale economies: Gross margins rose from 34% in 2005 to around 50% currently. Although pricing pressures are hitting the industry, a new facility in Malaysia is already sharply reducing manufacturing costs as well.
The company's management has already garnered high marks for solid execution, as seen by the fact that earnings per share have exceeded estimates by at least 18% in each of the last four quarters. Moreover, investors are usually given a wide range of operating metrics and scenario analyses to digest; this is unusual in an industry known for murky economics.
|
But that reputation may be challenged in coming quarters as the company deals with sharply dropping prices and tepid end-user demand. The company recently secured new contracts equating to roughly 500 megawatts of new solar power. This should provide some smoothing to near-term results, but investors should be prepared to hear of a slowdown in order flow for the next quarter or two.
And as the credit markets reopen, as more governments look to push cost-effective renewable energy mandates, and if we see a reversal in energy prices, then First Solar may be poised for a nice rebound in coming quarters in anticipation of a return to high growth rates later in 2009 and into 2010. As a final tailwind, investors would benefit from a rebound in the euro, which has taken a beating recently against the dollar. Once the "flight to quality" phase of this crisis has passed, signs point to the greenback returning to its secular decline. FSLR derives more than half of its sales from Europe.
Although the production of wafers used to make solar panels has turned into a low-margin commodity business, China's LDK Solar
Shares are weak because of investor concerns that management is ambitiously boosting capacity at a time when demand may be weak. Management chose to pursue aggressive growth as the fastest path to margin expansion in a segment of the industry where gross margins rarely exceed 25%. And a rising backlog (the equivalent of 3.3 Giga-watts of power) means that LDK is already sold out of its production for the next two years.
By adding capacity, management is accelerating production to forestall competition down the road. This is clearly a risky strategy, but it could yield big returns if demand for solar power keeps building in 2010 and beyond.
Yet management insists that such a dire scenario would still enable the company to operate profitably in the tough times ahead and to become vastly more profitable when the market stabilizes in 2010 and beyond. The company has built a nice cushion to handle the near-term concerns, thanks to a September 2008 secondary offering that raised $200 million.
Many other intriguing names in this space are worthy of further research, including Emcore
Copyright © 2009 TheStreet.Com. All rights reserved.