Mon, May 28, 2012, 3:47 AM EDT - U.S. Markets closed for Memorial Day

American Brat Pack: where airline CEOs came of age

In its heyday in the 1980s, American Airlines was a training camp for future industry leaders

RELATED QUOTES

SymbolPriceChange
LCC12.300.14
DAL11.370.10
AAMRQ.PK0.4720.01
DISH28.24-0.27

NEW YORK (AP) -- From an office at the end of a Dallas runway in the 1980s, the modern airline business was born.

There in cubicles with thin, gray carpet and shared computers, young graduates of the top business schools were tasked with making sense of deregulation — a new era when the government no longer dictated routes or prices.

Under American Airlines' then CEO Robert L. Crandall, they issued the first frequent flier miles, developed the hub system and found a way to fill empty seats with deeply discounted fares. Standards were high. Perfection was demanded. Those who excelled were quickly promoted, regardless of how young or new to the company they were. At the time, being a financial analyst on the second floor of American's headquarters was unlike any other job in the industry.

Today, four of them are running airlines — including American — themselves.

"It was a magical time," says Virgin America CEO David Cush, 51. "You didn't know where these guys were going to end up, but you knew you were hanging around with a bunch of smart guys."

US Airways CEO Doug Parker, 50, and Spirit Airlines CEO Ben Baldanza, 50, got their start alongside Cush.

Tom Horton, the other member of this airline Brat Pack, arguably hit it even bigger — taking over as CEO of the airline where they all started. But the job that he inherited is a long way from American's glory days under Crandall.

The 1980s "was sort of a golden moment for American," says Michael Useem, director of the Center for Leadership and Change Management at The University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School.

Today, American is struggling with old jets and high labor costs. Once the largest airline in the world, American is now in third place behind Delta Air Lines Inc. and United-Continental Holdings Inc., which became bigger and more efficient through mergers. But the most-painful jab for the carrier came last month when American's parent, AMR Corp., sought Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection — the same day it promoted Horton, 50.

Horton and Parker declined requests for interviews.

American's success at molding future leaders echoes the success of big companies such as General Electric and Procter & Gamble. Those companies were known for weeding out underperforming executives and giving those who showed promise responsibilities well beyond their rank.

"These companies made developing great leaders a defining element of their DNA," Useem says.

American didn't just create CEOs. Dozens of its young financial analysts from the 1980s went on to become top executives at most of the major airlines. Others held senior roles at travel companies including Orbitz and Royal Caribbean.

They all came to American because it was the center of innovation in an industry on the verge of a revolution. There were challenges found nowhere else. For instance: how do you create the first curbside check-in system? These young analysts were driven by their bosses and each other. And nobody pushed harder than Crandall.

"The most competent got promoted very rapidly," says Crandall, who retired in 1998. "That made American a very good place to work. And the consequence of that is we attracted a lot of very, very bright people."

Crandall required major initiatives in other departments — from marketing to flight planning — to be vetted by the finance department, exposing the analysts to all aspects of the industry. He wanted to know the exact cost and potential benefit of any change.

Three decades later, most still recall the CEO's persistence.

The worst thing you could do was say you didn't want to waste his time with the details. Crandall thrived on those details and demanded them of his staff. He was known to quiz station managers on how much they spent on rags. If they didn't know, they were told they didn't really understand their operation.

"They didn't care if you were too young or didn't have enough years of experience. All they cared about was if you were competent and able to do a good job," says Bernie Han, who worked at American from 1988 until 1991. He later became the chief financial officer at America West and then held that title at Northwest. He is now chief operating officer of Dish Network.

American's headquarters was an energetic place. Competition was fierce but friendly. The analysts often bounced ideas off each other while playing Nerf basketball in a cubicle.

"If somebody did good work, the other guy wanted to do better work," says Jeff Katz, an American alumnus who went on to become CEO of Swissair, then led the online travel company Orbitz before landing the top job at Nextag, an online shopping website.

Despite being at competing airlines today, many of the former American analysts still keep in touch. From the start, they were a social group.

After work, beers were had at the Euless Yacht Club — a land-locked dive bar that was the closest place to headquarters. Other nights, it was margaritas at Esparza's, a nearby Mexican restaurant.

There were Texas Rangers games, a basketball league that Parker played in and the occasional lunchtime trip to Sonny Bryan's Smokehouse.

"We were all single and many people met their spouses there," says Teri L. Brooks, who rose to head human resources at American before leaving in 1996. She started the same year as David Brooks. Five and a half years later, they were married. He now runs American's cargo division.

Parker met his wife Gwen — then an American flight attendant — thanks to Cush, who knew her through a college friend.

Working at an airline meant free flights. Thursday night or Friday morning a weekend destination was selected — New York, London, the Caribbean or skiing in Utah.

"We'd all pile into hotel rooms, sleep on the floor," Brooks says.

Sometimes a random gate was picked. The plane might be heading to Cancun or Kansas City. Fate would decide.

"I was never a fan of that game," says Virgin America's Cush. "It never worked out very well."

For the most part, the young analysts were respected by those outside the finance department. Occasionally, a veteran manager would ask how long they'd been at American, suggesting they weren't qualified to be asking questions. That was the exception.

Crandall wanted the facts and would take them from whoever knew the business best. Those working around him learned how to gather information about a complex issue and then make a decision.

"If you were aggressive, intelligent and were willing to work hard," Baldanza says, "there was no limit on the types of things you could be involved in."

With reports from David Koenig in Dallas.

___

Scott Mayerowitz can be reached at http://twitter.com/GlobeTrotScott.

 

42 comments

  • C.J.  •  Minneapolis, Minnesota  •  5 months ago
    Basically you have described a bunch of thieves and crooks who took advantage of thousands of airline employees to make themselves rich. These guys never "built" a #$%$ thing. Too bad you didn't mention Doug Steenland and John Dasburg from Northwest, Frank Lorenzo from Eastern/Continental, and Steven Wolf from UAL. Wolf was also a Crandall clone. All airline "robber barons" and thieves in their own right.
    • Sandra 5 months ago
      Your comments give new meaning to the word "STUPID" Mr. Crandall was the respected dean of airline CEO's. I know because I worked for AA for over 40 years and was a member of his management team.
    • The Dude 5 months ago
      Agree, Sandra. I remember reading an article by Robert Crandall many years ago while flying on American. One of the points he made was the insane practice of the courts allowing airlines like Continental to go into bankruptcy in order to cut into American, United Airlines, Delta's and other's business -- essentially letting them write-off debt and then under charge on airfares all in the name of beating American Airlines, who up until last month had never filed for bankruptcy protection. Others have followed suit...now the industry is in shambles. Mr. Crandall tried to warn us!
    • eric l 5 months ago
      Yea Sandra was respected by your type the have's of the world you benefited from the crooked CEO's ways
  • Me  •  Houston, Texas  •  5 months ago
    I honestly can not take much comfort from the stories told in the article. all in all, and with all due respect to each guy mentioned, every one of these airline companies are/went into bankruptcy (American, America West, US Airways) or should be (Virgin America--continual losses, Spirit--poor service). You can say it is the industry, but look at southwest. The initiatives mentioned in the article (such as starting the frequent flier programs) in the end do not hide the reality that their ways did not work. Seems to me like the article can be mistaken by a simpleton who will take the people in the article as ‘success’ stories, when they are not, and go down the wrong path and pay the consequences. They are failed organizations, with failed policies, and those who made those decisions.
    • Sandra 5 months ago
      They went into bankrupcy because the GREEDY UNIONs drove them there. Just like they have done with every major industry that they have been involved with.
      The most recent the auto industry before that it was the steel industry, electronics industry, textile industry, apparel industry, manufacturing industry. The list goes on and on. The next industry to go bankrupt will be Federal, state, City governments as TAXPAYERS will revolt over public sector wages, pensions, and health care costs. Wake up America before it is to late as you will be paying the tab for public sector retirees, teachers, police, firefighters, govn. workers so they can retire at age 50 and you pay the tab for the rest of their lives with increased taxation. You need to vote the Dumbocrats out of office so they can't get into bed with the Greedy unions and steal your hard earned money.
    • Old Guy 5 months ago
      You make it sound like the union wrote the rules. They and the airlines execs. through collective bargaining, figure out what is going to work for both sides. After the cost of business is figured, the union people go to work and the company runs the place and makes all the decisions, not the union. So why is it the unions fault? Get informed before making such a statement
    • Johnb_dca 5 months ago
      Your comment shows you don't understand the industry's dynamics pre and post deregulation. The unions did in effect write the rules. They could do it pre-deregulation when management's only incentive was to pay them off and get the aluminum back in the air. That's why airline wages got so bloated. Deregulation changed that, but it has taken a long time to shake it out.
  • JB  •  5 months ago
    Narcissistic, self-serving thieves following an inept leader. Ever so pleased with themselves. This article speaks volumes about what has driven American business down.
    • Sandra 5 months ago
      Greedy UNIONS drove them to file for bankrupcy just like all the other airlines. In particular the pilots and flight attendants unions. Nothing but GREED!!!!!!!!!!!
    • eric l 5 months ago
      LOL typical management pay the CEO's millions and let the people do the real work for peanuts. shut your dumb mouth and quit posting
  • Blues Guitarist  •  5 months ago
    How is this even an article on Yahoo? How sickening. A story of crooks who came from a company with their finances and reputation in ruins.
  • Mark A.  •  5 months ago
    That hilarious! An industry that has lost more money than it has made and almost all have gone bankrupt!!! That's one smart group of guys!!!!
  • AZ  •  Elizabethtown, Kentucky  •  5 months ago
    Let's see...American Airlines went bankrupt, and US Air (aka US Worst) is a combination of two formerly bankrupt airlines; America West (aka America Worst) and US Air. Other than Southwest and Jet Blue, all amercian airlines suck...worst customer service in the world. The Bankruptcy Pack is a better name for this group of scumbags who've ruined the airline industry in this country.
    • Johnb_dca 5 months ago
      So the cattle call atmosphere at Southwest is good customer service? You can get away with that on flights from Omaha to Des Moines -- it won't work for long on, say, New York to LAX.

      BTW, Southwest's stock value has been basically flat for years. The Southwest miracle is mostly hype. Their high labor costs are going to kill them one of these days soon. They got lucky a few years ago on fuel hedges, but those days are gone.
    • Razzy101 5 months ago
      The best airlines in my experience have been the foreign airlines such. I would recommend trying United Arab Emirates or one of the Asian airlines that fly into the US.
  • TXLefty  •  5 months ago
    Robert Crandall said the way to make a small fortune is to start with a large fortune then invest with an airline.
  • ShutUpMeg  •  Kingwood, Texas  •  5 months ago
    Is the author seriously praising these morons? They were bred as greedy, cut throat, thieves who did exactly that. Pure 80's mentality that ran the airlines into the ground financially, yet they stuff their pockets with millions of dollars and stock options.
    • Razzy101 5 months ago
      I could never understand the handing out of bonuses in companies when they are losing money or just remaining flat. I always thought of bonuses as being paid if a company was doing well. But then many, if not all executives have easy performance goals to reach. It's agreed upon between the board of directors and the CEO. But the board of directors with many, many companies just rubber stamp the CEO's request.
  • tomtech  •  New York, New York  •  5 months ago
    These are the men who ruined the great american airline industry, after 'the great' Ronald Regan deregulated it and sealed its fate. My dad worked for TWA for almost 40 years through its heyday, and retired during its ultimate demise. Back in its heyday from the 50's through the 70's, air travel was something very special to experience, almost magical. These days air travel is no better than riding a New York subway with a free bag of peanuts.....RIP Dad, I love you ...RIP TWA.....EASTERN....PAN AM..... ETC.....ETC......ETC
  • Alberto  •  Quito, Ecuador  •  5 months ago
    C. R. Smith, the great American Airlines business had said -long before Bud Kahn pushed deregulation- that nobody makes any money in the goddamn airline business anymore. Kahn only made things even worse for the airlines have been subsidizing the public to the tune of billions. The only winners besides the traveling public are the airframe manufacturers Boieng and Airbus.
  • NotPC  •  5 months ago
    I hate everyone of these articles where the writer swallows the management lies about high labor costs. I know for a fact that, adjusted for inflation, the pilots at American Airlines are making the same pay that they were in 1995, while the executives are making hundreds of times more. What's true of the pilots wages is true of the flight attendants and all the other labor groups at American Airlines.
  • Daniel  •  Fort Worth, Texas  •  5 months ago
    Yes, they all came out of Finance--the beginning of the end. They forgot about leadership, engineering, customer service--but they knew how much the #$%$ rags cost. That was Bob Crandall in a nut shell. AA was one of the most micromanaged companies I ever worked for. People were afraid of Crandall and his minions and Fang liked it that way. His minions have done no better (and Tom Horton is out of the same school--the man who moved an entire department from Tulsa to Dallas to justify his own move back to headquarters from his isolated post in Oklahoma.) Its a helluva a legacy. Mr. Casey would not have approved.
  • Donnie Baseball  •  Bristol, Connecticut  •  5 months ago
    I am not getting this at all. Most smart guys on Wall Street don't invest in airline stocks. The pedestals erected for these guys should be made of powder. If these people were the smartest guys in the room, I would hope the room were really, really tiny.
  • Victor the Worker  •  5 months ago
    So here we have a bunch of young men who never built or created anything of substance other than running an adding machine and calculator and who turned a vibrant but troubled industry into a shadow of it's former self. Yep,the accountants do it again and the author of this story glorifies their failure. What a joke. Send them back to engineering school if they weee so smart or out to the field where they can learn how the real world works. Because they sure didn't know enough to keep the airlines from going belly-up.
  • Bill 1  •  Hudson, Ohio  •  5 months ago
    And how do career politicians come "of age?"
  • Brett  •  Arlington, Virginia  •  5 months ago
    The 80's were not Americans Heyday. That happened long before under C.R. Smith. Also, American didn't start the hub and spoke concept. It was around WAY before the 80's and was in fact in place before the Airline Dergulation act of 1978. A good author doesn't just conveniently create facts.
  • DJTexn1  •  5 months ago
    There was no limit! That was the problem. No one was held responsible for their actions. The 'bottom line' was the only goal. PROFIT!!!
  • chas  •  4 months ago
    Sounds like to me these very smart guys completely destroyed the airline industry in about 25 years.
  • Tomas  •  Pleasanton, California  •  5 months ago
    This article makes me sick. No matter what industry you have worked in, these greedy, 'aggressive' #$%$ accountant types have come in and gutted out companies in the name of 'profit for shareholders' which amounts to a bonus for themselves. Unless this country starts valuing the 'greater good' for society again, America is doomed. I am encouraged to see most everyone else react the same way.
  • Robert  •  San Rafael, California  •  5 months ago
    It would be one thing if the physicists at CERN were describing themselves as being in a magical time, or their colleagues in terms of "you knew you were hanging around with a bunch of smart guys. But my guess is that those truly gifted and hard working scientists are, well, working very hard with their gifts.

    To me, this article makes clear that either we have lost our collective ability to understand what competence and effective leadership is, or, have given up entirely.

    Perhaps saddest of all is reading the comments from "the director of the Center for Leadership and Change Management" from one of America's most influential business schools. If this kind of leadership and associated change is what we have to look forward to, maybe we are in worse shape than I thought.

    I wonder what Southwest's founder and former CEO, Herb Kelleher, thinks of these magical thinkers.
 
Recent Quotes
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
 
Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.

Trading Center

Yahoo! Finance on Facebook

  YAHOO! FINANCE ON TWITTER