Appeals court to review approval of BP settlement

Michael Kunzelman, Associated Press

NEW ORLEANS (AP) -- A year ago, lawyers for BP and Gulf Coast residents and businesses took turns urging a federal judge to approve their settlement for compensating victims of the company's massive 2010 oil spill.

On Monday, however, the one-time allies will be at odds when an appeals court hears objections to the multibillion-dollar deal. That's because several months after U.S. District Judge Carl Barbier approved the settlement, BP started complaining that the judge and court-appointed claims administrator were misinterpreting it. The London-based oil giant is worried it could be forced to pay billions of dollars more for bogus or inflated claims by businesses.

Plaintiffs' attorneys who brokered the deal want the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to uphold the class-action settlement.

As of Friday, payments have been made to more than 38,000 people and businesses for an estimated $3.7 billion. Tens of thousands more could file claims in the coming months.

The settlement doesn't have a cap, but BP initially estimated that it would pay roughly $7.8 billion to resolve the claims. Later, as it started to challenge the business payouts, the company said it no longer could give a reliable estimate for how much the deal will cost.

The dispute centers on money for businesses, not individuals. Awards are based on a comparison of revenues and expenses before and after the spill. BP says a "policy decision" that claims administrator Patrick Juneau announced in January has allowed businesses to manipulate those figures in a way that leads to errors in calculating their actual lost profits.

Last month, a different 5th Circuit panel threw out Barbier's rulings on the dispute and ordered him to craft a "narrowly-tailored" injunction that modifies the damage calculations.

The lead plaintiffs' attorneys said the panel's decision has no effect on the separate appeal of Barbier's December 2012 approval of the settlement.

"The processing and payment of (business) claims has not in any way affected the fair, reasonable and adequate compensation paid under the Settlement Agreement's transparent and objective criteria to any Objector or any other member of the class," they wrote.

BP wants the court to adopt its interpretation of the settlement terms for businesses. If it does, the "otherwise fatal obstacles" would be eliminated and the entire settlement could be upheld, the company told the 5th Circuit.

BP is not the only one questioning Barbier's December 2012 approval of the settlement. Attorney Brent Coon, of Beaumont, Texas, argued that a rush to "close the deal" resulted in a settlement program "mired in implementation problems." He did not have a role in negotiating the settlement but filed one of several formal objections, seeking revisions to the agreement.

"Too much random guess work was needed to determine whether an individual's claim was eligible for settlement funds or not," he wrote.

Juneau's office began issuing settlement payments on July 31, 2012. As of Friday, tens of thousands of claimants have received settlement offers worth more than $4.9 billion.

BP spokesman Geoff Morrell said the 5th Circuit's ruling last month concluded that Juneau's interpretations of the settlement "do not withstand scrutiny under the law."

"If they are not corrected, the settlement class cannot be certified and the settlement should be set aside, ending what once promised to be an historic effort to benefit those who experienced losses as a result of the spill," he said in a statement.

  • News

    Ford Recalls Over 88K Vehicles Due to Stalling Problem

    Ford is recalling more than 88,000 cars and SUVs in North America because the engines can stall without warning due to a fuel pump problem. The recall covers certain Ford Taurus and Police Interceptor sedans, Ford Flex wagons, Lincoln MKS sedans and Lincoln MKT SUVs from the 2013 through 2015 model years. All have 3.5-liter turbocharged six-cylinder engines. Ford says the fuel pump control modules can fail, and the engines may not start, or they could stall, leaving drivers without the ability to restart them. The company says it's not aware of any crashes or injuries from the problem. Dealers will replace the control module at no cost to owners.

    ABC News
  • News

    Please stop suggesting these inventions to Ford

    If you’ve ever had an idea that you think would change the way we get around, Ford would like to hear it. The company has a portal open to employees and the public where anyone can suggest an idea to Ford, and, if the company likes it, it may work with the person to help them secure the intellectual property. On the site, Ford has a list of a few suggestions that it would really prefer if you didn’t send them, because the company is either already working on similar ideas, or it’s just heard it a ton of times before and can’t do anything with. “We do not want you to waste your time submitting these ideas (or our time reviewing them), as we will reject your submission,” Ford says on the site.

    Quartz
  • Business

    The Collection Account That Just Won't Die

    Whatever the case, it was years ago and, try as you may, this old collection account keeps reappearing on your credit report. You're frustrated because you know that mistake all those years ago is still a red flag for lenders (and even landlords and utility companies) because it's lowering your credit scores. One thing to keep in mind is that there's little you can do to remove an accurate collection account from your credit reports before the collection account "ages out," which is typically seven years after the account first goes to collections.

    Credit.com
  • Entertainment

    Courteney Cox on ‘Running Wild’: ‘This is the Worst Thing I’ve Ever Done’

    On Monday’s Running Wild With Bear Grylls, Courteney Cox stopped running and started fearing for her life. Bear Grylls knew how to traverse the gap and explained that he would toss his ice pick over a boulder, rappel to the other side, and send a zipline back to Cox.

    Superfan
  • Business

    5 Dividend Stocks to Consider Selling Now

    With interest rates in the basement and likely to stay there for some time, investors have, for good reason, flocked to dividend-paying stocks. But demand has pushed up the prices of many popular payers to possibly unsustainable levels. These stocks could be vulnerable to steep declines. People who can live off of their dividend income and can ignore share-price fluctuations may not have to worry much about a market reversal. After all, given enough time, the price of a good company will eventually recover. But investors who can’t stomach a downturn—even if it proves temporary—may want to lighten up on some overpriced dividend stocks. We’ve identified five dividend payers that look overvalued

    Kiplinger.com
  • Business

    Lincoln, Honda, Toyota, BMW are tops in customer satisfaction (Acura, VW not so much)

    ACSI's 2016 Automobile Report polled 3,776 auto customers, asking them to evaluate their experiences with a wide range of car brands, using a scale of 0 (not at all satisfied) to 100 (over the moon). The 2015 ACSI survey saw continued declines in satisfaction, which was attributed to several years of high-profile recalls. On ACSI's 100-point scale, the average score in 2016 is 82, up 3.8 percent from last year.

    The Car Connection
  • Business

    How to Get Serious About Building an Emergency Fund

    You’ve heard it time and time again: Everyone should build an emergency fund. Easier said than done, right? Saving can feel like an impossible task when you’re just getting by each month. But even if you’re living paycheck to paycheck, it’s still possible

    Money
  • Entertainment

    Former Fox News Host Andrea Tantaros Files Suit Alleging Sexual Harassment

    Andrea Tantaros, a former host of Fox News Channel program like “The Five” and “Outnumbered,” is the latest female staffer at the popular cable-news outlet to levy sexual-harassment charges at the 21st Century Fox-owned property. In a lawsuit filed Monday in the Supreme Court of the State of New York, Tantaros alleged that senior executives at the network retaliated against her after she complained about being inappropriate remarks made to her by Roger Ailes, the former chairman and chief executive of the network. Ailes left Fox News last month in the wake of an internal investigation that is believed to have turned up evidence of several female employees at the operation being harassed sexually during their time of employment.

    Variety
  • News

    World's largest aircraft damaged on 2nd test flight

    The developer of the world's largest aircraft says the blimp-shaped airship sustained damage after it made a bumpy landing Wednesday on its second test flight in eastern England. Hybrid Air Vehicles said it is trying to figure out what caused the rough landing of the 302-foot (92-meter) Airlander 10 during its 100 minute flight Wednesday in Bedfordshire, north of London. "The Airlander experienced a heavy landing and the front of the flight deck has sustained some damage, which is currently being assessed," the company said.

    Associated Press
  • GWP.L

    Will GW Pharmaceuticals (GWPH) Crush Estimates at Its Next Earnings Report?

    Looking for a stock that might be in a good position to beat earnings at its next report? Consider GW Pharmaceuticals plc GWPH, a firm in the Medical Products industry, which could be a great candidate for another beat. This company has seen a nice streak of beating earnings estimates, especially when looking at the previous two reports.

    Zacks
  • News

    Cramer: Yellen could trigger a historical decline. Here's...

    Jim Cramer provides his playbook for action in the event that the bears grip the market on Friday.

    CNBC Videos
  • Politics

    Lawmakers demand information on EpiPen price increase

    Sen. Charles Grassley, R-Iowa, wrote Mylan, the company that manufactures the devices, and asked for more information on why the prices have increased. Two other senators, Democrats Mark Warner of Virginia and Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut, also wrote the company about the high prices. Warner said in a letter Tuesday that the issue is personal for him.

    Associated Press
  • Business

    5 Ways to Avoid Taxes on Your Social Security Benefits

    How are taxes on Social Security benefits calculated? Are there any strategies that would help me avoid paying taxes on my benefits? Whether your Social Security benefits are taxed depends on your "provisional income." Your provisional income is your adjusted gross income, not counting Social Security benefits, plus nontaxable interest and half of your Social Security benefits. If it's below $25,000 and you file taxes as single or head of household, or less than $32,000 if you file a joint return, you won't owe taxes on your benefits. If your provisional income is between $25,000 and $34,000 if you're single, or between $32,000 and $44,000 if you file jointly, up to 50% of your benefits may be

    Kiplinger.com
  • Business

    The unrelenting hunt for yield may end in tears, says James Grant

    Listening to Wall Street pundit James Grant ought to make investors feel uneasy. The prominent author of Grant’s Interest Rate Observer is starting to sound a lot like many permabears roaming this yield-parched world. Grant told Swiss business paper Finanz und Wirtschaft in a Q&A published on Monday that he’s scooping up shares of gold GCZ6, -1.40%  and gold miners GDX, -7.06% because he fears that the world will lose faith in central banks, or as he terms it “monetary management.” That call makes Grant sound a lot like Peter Schiff, chief executive of Euro Pacific Capital, who harbors a low opinion of the U.S. Federal Reserve, and central banks in general, and who has a longstanding love affair

    MarketWatch
  • SBUX

    No, Starbucks isn't cheating customers by adding ice to drinks, judge says

    It seems that Starbucks (SBUX) can put as much ice as it wants in your beverage. A judge in California dismissed a case that accused the coffee chain of under-filling its iced drinks, saying the plaintiff had "not alleged any viable claims" against the company. "If children have figured out that including ice in a cold beverage decreases the amount of liquid they will receive, the Court has no difficulty concluding that a reasonable consumer would not be deceived into thinking that when they order an iced tea, that the drink they receive will include both ice and tea and that for a given size cup, some portion of the drink will be ice rather than whatever liquid beverage the consumer ordered," wrote Percy Anderson, the U.S. District Judge presiding over the case in his dismissal of the lawsuit last Friday.

    CNBC
  • News

    Airlander 10: Longest aircraft damaged during flight

    The world's longest aircraft - the Airlander 10 - has been damaged after nosediving on landing during its second test flight. The 302ft (92m) long aircraft - which is part plane and part airship - was damaged during the flight from Cardington Airfield in Bedfordshire. The £25m craft sustained damage to its cockpit when it hit the ground at about 11:00 BST. HAV, the developer, said all the crew were "safe and well". A spokesman said: "The flight went really well and the only issue was when it landed." The company has denied claims from a witness that a line hanging down from the vehicle hit a telegraph pole about two fields away from its landing. In a statement, Hybrid Air Vehicles (HAV), said:

    BBC News
  • Politics

    Campaign's rising rent at Trump Tower came as space expanded

    Donald Trump's campaign is taking up more space inside Trump Tower in New York -- and paying a lot more in rent. The Republican presidential nominee's campaign paid $35,457 per month for rent and utilities to Trump Tower Commercial LLC between last August and this April, Federal Election Commission reports show. The rent hike at the Manhattan skyscraper came as the Trump team expanded from using only the fifth floor to add two additional levels, according to a statement Tuesday from the campaign.

    Associated Press
  • Politics

    Will 15,000 New Emails Be Clinton’s ‘October Surprise’?

    In the latest chapter of the long saga of Hillary Clinton’s woeful mishandling of highly sensitive government documents and email, the government confirmed on Monday that the FBI uncovered nearly 15,000 previously undisclosed documents that Clinton sent or received during her four years as secretary of state. The 14,900 Clinton documents that the Justice Department revealed in federal court are nearly half again as many as the roughly 30,000 emails that Clinton’s lawyers assessed as “work related” and delivered to State in December 2014 as part of a federal probe into Clinton’s use of a private email server in her home. FBI Director James Comey said in July that investigators found “several thousand” more emails that were not included in the December batch.

    The Fiscal Times
  • Business

    Seadrill Ltd. Just Got Even Riskier -- The Motley Fool

    So much for a drilling recovery just yet. On Monday , offshore driller Seadrill Ltd. (NYSE:SDRL) announced that it had received notice from Pemex that it was canceling its contract for the West Pegasus semi-submersible drilling vessel, yet another reminder that the offshore drilling environment remains in a serious downturn. But here's what makes this particular cancellation unusual: Pemex and Seadrill had just signed the contract in the first quarter of 2016. Overall, it's a troubling reminder how far we may be from a recovery. And that's particularly bad news for Seadrill, which has a lot of debt coming due and newbuilds on track to be delivered in the near term.  Let's take a closer look at

    The Motley Fool
  • Business

    Former IRS chief says Trump has no excuse to not release his tax returns

    Much has been said and written about Donald Trump 's refusal to release his tax returns. Tax returns paint a revealing picture of who we are. But nothing prevents us as taxpayers from choosing to release our tax returns — and those who aspire for the highest public office have done so for decades.

    CNBC
  • AAPL

    According to this chart, Apple shares are approaching a critical breaking point

    For Jonathan Krinsky, technical analyst MKM Partners, Apple's chart has become a heated battleground between bulls and bears. But he observes that Apple shares, which are up about 10 percent in the past month, have recently reached up to the top of this channel. The story of the $90 level on Apple's chart starts in April 2012, when the stock topped out at $92 — which was then actually $644, as it was before Apple's 7-to-1 stock split.

    CNBC
  • Business

    UBS leads team of banks working on blockchain settlement system

    Swiss bank UBS is leading a team of four of the world's biggest banks developing a system to enable financial markets to make payments and settle transactions quickly using blockchain technology. UBS has developed a "Utility Settlement Coin" (USC), which is a digital cash equivalent of each of the major currencies backed by central banks, such as the dollar or euro, rather than a decentralised new digital currency such as bitcoin. The USC would be convertible at parity with a bank deposit in the corresponding currency, making it fully backed by cash assets at a central bank.

    Reuters
  • Business

    Costco Wholesale Corporation's Biggest Win in 2016 So Far

    For Costco (NASDAQ: COST), it needed to make a change to its credit card provider to get a better deal for itself and its customers. The warehouse club had to negotiate with providers other than the incumbent American Express (NYSE: AXP), and opening the door to another card company winning the business meant change was possible. Citigroup (NYSE: C) ultimately won Costco's business, meaning its loyalty reward program members would see their American Express cards replaced with Visa (NYSE: V) cards.

    Motley Fool
  • Business

    Turkish Military Campaign Against Islamic State Pressures Stocks

    Turkish stocks slumped the most among global equity markets as the country’s armed forces began bombing Islamic State positions in Syria, stoking concerns among investors about a worsening security situation.The Borsa Istanbul 100 Index fell 2.4 percent

    Bloomberg