Chart: Frequency of Alan Greenspan's Laughter Predicted the Housing Bubble

The Atlantic

In the infamous transcript of the Federal Reserve's first meeting in 2006, the word "[Laughter]" appeared at least 45 times. In one case, Fed Chair Alan Greenspan mocked his fellow economists' ability to predict the future, and the board laughed. Two years later, the global economy fell apart due to a housing meltdown that many Fed economists noted, but discounted. I counted the top ten most ironic laugh lines of the meeting here.

The Daily Stag Hunt did one better: It counted the word "[Laughter]" in every Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) transcript between 2001 and 2006 -- the bubble years for the housing market. Then they graphed the results.

View gallery

.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/rf/image_606w/WashingtonPost/Content/Blogs/ezra-klein/StandingArt/FOMC%20Funnies%20v2.0.jpg?uuid=Rl7D6EN-EeGuleP9QvU3_w


Does that picture remind you of something? Here's a look at home prices between 2001 and 2006:

View gallery

.
case shiller 1.png

Pull back the lens, and here's what happened to home prices when the laughter stopped:

View gallery

.
case shiller 2.png
FOMC laughter: Totally random incidence of economic giggling, or the very best coincident indicator we have? You be the judge.







More From The Atlantic
View Comments