How to Choose Between a Roth and Traditional IRA

US News

Should you open a traditional or Roth individual retirement account? Choosing a traditional IRA means you don't pay taxes upfront on your contribution, but you will pay taxes when you withdraw money. If you open a Roth IRA, you pay taxes upfront based on your after-tax income, but then your investments grow tax-free, so you can collect your money later on without having to pay any other taxes on it.

The maximum an individual can currently contribute to an IRA for 2013 is $5,500 (or $6,500 if you are age 50 or older). When choosing between whether to open a traditional or Roth IRA, consider these three factors:

1. Taxes. Theoretically, if your tax rate stays the same as it is now as when you retire, a Roth or traditional IRA would be financially equivalent. However, contributing to a Roth IRA would be a better option if your tax rate increases, while contributing to a traditional IRA would be preferable if your tax rate decreases.

Excluding the likelihood that national tax rates are going to rise as a result of high national debt, there is the added assumption that as you get older, advance your career and earn more money, you will be placed in a higher tax bracket. However, it's also possible that when you retire you may have a lower income and be in a lower tax bracket than you are in now.

It's ultimately a judgment call. Since projecting the future is uncertain, some consumers decide to diversify their tax exposure by contributing to a combination of Roth and traditional IRAs.

2. Early withdrawals. Traditional IRAs charge a 10 percent federal penalty tax on early withdrawals prior to 59.5 years old. Meanwhile, Roth IRAs are more flexible, allowing investors to make withdrawals without getting slapped with a penalty - although earnings on contributions for Roth IRAs are still subject to the 10 percent penalty tax. However, there are some exceptions, such as withdrawing up to $10,000 for first-home purchases or paying post-secondary education expenses.

3. Required minimum distributions. Traditional IRAs require you to begin taking minimum distributions at age 70.5, while Roth IRAs have no required minimum distributions. Since many Americans plan to start living off retirement savings by their 70th birthday, the mandatory withdraw policy on traditional IRAs may not be a deal breaker for a number of consumers. However, if you think you may want to hold off on accessing your savings until you get older, it's something worth taking into consideration.

Income limits. While there are income limits on IRA contributions, a backdoor Roth IRA is an option for consumers of all income brackets. This means you can still have a Roth IRA regardless of your income by contributing to a non-deductible traditional IRA, and then converting that right away to a Roth IRA. The only tax you will have to pay is on increases in value of your investment from the time you make your first contribution to the time when you convert. However, if you make the conversion right away, no taxes should be applied.

Neda Jafarzadeh is a financial analyst with NerdWallet Investing. NerdWallet Investing helps consumers make better financial decisions, such as finding the best Roth IRA account provider for their needs.



More From US News & World Report

Rates

View Comments (1)

Recommended for You

  • Will Apple's digital wallet kill the card swipe?

    Will Apple's digital wallet kill the card swipe? NEW YORK (AP) — Apple wants the plastic credit card to become as rare as the paper check. On Tuesday, the company announced Apple Pay, a digital payment system that lets people pay for retail store purchases using their phones rather than cash or…

    Associated Press
  • AT&T® Business Wireless

    New prices on our Mobile Share Value Plans on the nation's most reliable 4G LTE network.

    AdChoicesAT&T® Small BusinessSponsored
  • Asian stocks tumble on disappointing China data

    Asian stocks tumbled Monday on weak Chinese economic data as investors looked ahead to a U.S. China's Shanghai Composite Index shed 0.3 percent to 2,326.06. CHINESE SLOWDOWN: Weak data released on the weekend fueled concern China's economic slowdown is deepening.

    Associated Press
  • Dutch stage tomato fight against Russian sanctions

    Hundreds of young Dutch men and women turned Amsterdam's central Dam square into a blizzard of red goop on Sunday, as they pelted each other mercilessly with overripe tomatoes. The Netherlands vies with Mexico as the world's largest tomato exporter, and it sent $100 million worth to Russia last year.

    Associated Press
  • Play

    The Perils of Our Lopsided Income Growth

    The Fed's latest U.S. consumer finance report showed decent income growth overall--but not across the board.

    Morningstar
  • More lenders are offering student-loan consolidations

    Dear Liz: I have four private student loans that I would love to consolidate so that I can have one medium-size monthly payment instead of four large ones. Answer: If you have good credit and sufficient income — or a willing co-signer — several lenders now offer private student loan consolidation.…

    Los Angeles Times
  • CyberArk IPO Gets Boost as Breaches Trigger Industry Gain

    The data breaches that have rocked corporate America in recent weeks couldn’t have come at a better time for CyberArk Software Ltd . The Israeli data security company, which is seeking to raise as much as $80 million in an initial public offering in the U.S., is marketing its shares to investors…

    Bloomberg
  • Hundreds of workers on strike at Lear Corp. plant

    Hundreds of workers protesting what some are calling fast-food-like wages walked off the job Saturday at a Lear Corp. plant in northwest Indiana that makes automotive seats, beginning a strike that could affect a major Ford assembly plant in Chicago. The plant, about 28 miles southeast of Chicago…

    Associated Press
  • A Lot's Changed Since You Graduated High School

    Including the cost of college tuition. Start saving for a child's education today with the MEFA® U.Fund College Investing Plan.

    AdChoicesFidelity InvestmentsSponsored
  • Asian stocks tumble as China anxiety saps confidence

    By Ian Chua SYDNEY (Reuters) - Asian stocks stumbled to their lowest in five weeks on Monday after a batch of weak data out of China raised the spectre of a sharp slowdown in the world's second-biggest economy. The Australian dollar, considered a liquid proxy for China plays, also took a hammering…

    Reuters22 mins ago
  • Global Banks' Lending Returns to `Substantial' Growth

    Cross-border lending by global banks rose by $580 billion in the first quarter, the first “substantial” increase since 2011, the Bank for International Settlements said. Cross-border claims of banks reporting to the BIS rose 2 percent to $29.4 trillion in the three months through March, the Basel,…

    Bloomberg
  • Gold Industry Needs ‘Cleansing’ of Weakest, Fidelity Says

    The gold industry, recovering from the worst slump in prices in 30 years, needs more mergers to help improve investor returns and eliminate unprofitable mines, Fidelity Investments said. About a third of gold production is probably money-losing when the price of the metal is lower than $1,250 an…

    Bloomberg
  • Morgan Stanley Seven-Year Curse Spells Decline: Australia Credit

    Morgan Stanley says Australian bonds, the worst-performing government debt in the past month, have further to decline as investment-grade securities globally will stagnate for the next seven years. Australian sovereign debt due in more than a year lost 0.7 percent in the month ended Sept. 12, the…

    Bloomberg
  • If a Company Won’t Talk, Its Former Employees Will

    The Haggler has striven in recent months to get someone at Conn’s, a Texas-based chain that sells appliances and furniture, on the phone. What kind of place is Conn’s, and how does it operate? One of the customers is Justin Raizk of Tucson, Ariz., who last year walked into a Conn’s in his hometown…

    The New York Times
  • Central banks in driving seat this week

    Three central bank meetings will likely top the agenda for Asian markets this week, with particular focus on the U.S. On Wednesday, the Federal Open Market Committee ends its two-day review and traders are bracing for an increasingly hawkish tone from Fed Chair Janet Yellen. Last week, global…

    CNBC
  • A Lot's Changed Since You Graduated High School

    Including the cost of college tuition. Start saving for a child's education today with the Delaware College Investment Plan.

    AdChoicesFidelity InvestmentsSponsored
  • China's Alibaba sets new path with US IPO

    China's Alibaba sets new path with US IPO New York (AFP) - With a possible record-breaking stock offering, Chinese online giant Alibaba is set to boost its role as a global company with a massive expansion potential. The initial public offering (IPO), expected to raise between $19 billion and $24…

    AFP
  • Scottish independence could mean messy divorce

    If Scots vote yes to separation on Thursday, a clock starts ticking down to March 24, 2016 — the independence day declared by the Scottish government. The British and Scottish administrations have agreed that they will recognize the outcome of the referendum and appoint negotiators to work out the…

    Associated Press
  • Are You Prepared for a Market Correction?

    When a bull market is roaring, preparing your portfolio for a correction or bear market might seem like closing the storm shutters on a sunny day. Although you don't need a financial adviser to do any of this, you will want to take a page from their book by building in some protection and sticking…

    Morningstar
  • Bank of Portugal picks new CEO for BES successor Novo Banco

    By Andrei Khalip LISBON (Reuters) - The Bank of Portugal on Sunday picked a new chief executive for Novo Banco, successor to Banco Espirito Santo (BES), following the embarrassing resignation of its three top managers appointed only two months ago. Eduardo Stock da Cunha, 51, an experienced…

    Reuters
  • Hedge Funds Cut Bullish Crop Bets to Lowest Since January

    Hedge funds cut bullish wagers on agricultural commodities to the lowest since January before the U.S. Department of Agriculture said Sept. 11. Three months of rain and mild weather created almost ideal growing conditions, spurring price declines that drove the Bloomberg Commodity Index to a…

    Bloomberg
  • How Ferrari Fits Into the Plan for Fiat Chrysler IPO

    Luca Cordero di Montezemolo, chairman of iconic Italian automaker Ferrari, will leave his job on October 13, the day that the combination of Fiat and Chrysler is expected to begin trading as Fiat Chrysler Automotive on the New York Stock Exchange. Montezemolo has been Ferrari’s chairman for nearly…

    24/7 Wall St.
  • Experience The Advantages of USAA Auto Insurance

    Members who switch to USAA Auto Insurance see an average savings of $426 a year. You may save even more when you own another USAA product. Learn more.

    AdChoicesUSAASponsored
  • Retirees' big move (or not): What to consider

    Retirees' big move (or not): What to considerShould I stay or should I go? Many people nearing retirement grapple with this decision. Choosing whether to retire "in place" or move to a new location could make or break your nest egg. There are many factors

    CNBC