CITI: Japan May Have A Crafty Trick Up Its Sleeve That Would Let It Buy Foreign Bonds

Business Insider

The Japanese yen is strengthening today after Japanese Finance Minister Taro Aso said that the Bank of Japan would not be buying foreign bonds (one of its options for weakening the yen further).

Aso's comments follow a statement put out by G7 finance ministers last week that included the line (emphasis added), " We reaffirm that our fiscal and monetary policies have been and will remain oriented towards meeting our respective domestic objectives using domestic instruments, and that we will not target exchange rates."

However, Citi analyst Michael Plavnik was on CNBC this morning with Kelly Evans, and he said that regardless of posturing, he thinks Japan will do whatever it takes to weaken the yen 40-50 percent, foreign bond purchases included.

Plavnik told CNBC:

I think [Japanese government officials] have a goal to hit 2-percent inflation. They're not going to be able to hit 2-percent inflation without significant yen weakness. The pass-through [from yen devaluation to inflation] is about 15-20 percent, so they need the yen to weaken about 40-50 percent in order to get 4-percent inflation over a 2-year period.

So, if you reverse engineer from there, you say, "Well, what do you need to do to get the yen weakness?" And, quite frankly, I think they are willing to do anything it takes.

So, how does Japan get around the no-foreign-bond-purchases rule?

Plavnik says the Japanese government may set up a sovereign wealth fund:

I think what the bond market is saying – what the yields are saying – is [the Japanese government is] willing to do whatever it takes. So, if today they take foreign bond purchases off the table, then they are going to have to do it through quantitative easing, which means significant bond purchases.

Furthermore, personally I think foreign bond purchases are not out of the question. Coming out after the weekend of G7 and G20, it's pretty difficult for them to come out and say, "Yes, we are going to do this significantly."

I don't think they are going to have the BoJ do it. The more crafty way to do it – Abe is extremely strong on international [policy]; he's made the yen an international policy.

I think the way they do it is they will start a sovereign wealth fund.  They will buy Treasuries, and they will buy European bonds – they already buy U.S. Treasuries and EFSF bonds.

So, if they set up a sovereign wealth fund and say, "This is what we're going to do – we're going to buy foreign bonds," it's pretty difficult for the international community to come back and say, "Please don't do this," because there are already other countries that do this.

A sovereign wealth fund could be a game-changer for the Japanese government, which seems to be increasingly hamstrung by the international community in its quest to achieve inflation. However, such a plan could eventually spark the same sort of blowback Japan faces now.



More From Business Insider

Rates

View Comments (0)