Citigroup Inc. (C) Q3 2013 Fixed Income Investor Review Conference Call October 23, 2013 10:00 AM ET
Peter Kapp - Head of Fixed Income Investor Relations
John Gerspach - Chief Financial Officer
Eric Aboaf - Treasurer
Ryan O'Connell - Morgan Stanley
Brian Monteleone - Barclays
Hello and welcome to Citi’s Fixed Income Investor Review with Chief Financial Officer, John Gerspach; and Treasurer, Eric Aboaf. Today’s call will be hosted by Peter Kapp, Head of Fixed Income Investor Relations. (Operator Instructions) Also as a reminder, this conference is being recorded today. If you have any objections, please disconnect at this time. Mr. Cath, you may begin.
Thank you, Brent. Good morning and thank you all for joining us. On our call today, our CFO, John Gerspach will speak first, then Eric Aboaf, our Treasurer will take you through the Fixed Income Investor presentation, which is available for download on our website, citigroup.com. Afterwards, we will be happy to take questions.
Before we get started, I would like to remind you that today’s presentation may contain forward-looking statements, which are based on management’s current expectations and are subject to uncertainty and changes in circumstances. Actual results and capital and other financial condition may differ materially from these statements due to a variety of factors, including the precautionary statements referenced in our discussion today and those included in our SEC filings including, without limitation, the Risk Factors section of our 2012 Form 10-K.
With that said, let me turn it over to John.
Okay, thank you, Peter and good morning, everyone. We are very pleased to be hosting our Fixed Income Investor Review this quarter. Today, we are going to update you on our continued progress in several areas. Eric Aboaf, our Treasurer, is going to review some specifics on our strong balance sheet, liquidity profile and capital position as well as our recent issuance activity and funding plans for the remainder of 2013.
Before I turn it over to Eric, however, there are some key points from our third quarter results that I would like to highlight on Slide 2. We reported $3.3 billion of net income for the third quarter of 2013, excluding CVA and DVA and a tax benefit in the quarter. Our results reflect the challenging operating environment including a slowdown in capital markets activity as well as lower mortgage refinancing volume. However, even in this challenging environment, we continue to make progress on our execution priorities. We remain on track to achieve the savings from the repositioning efforts we announced last December. We continue to reduce the earnings drag associated with Citi Holdings and holdings assets declined to $122 billion or 6% of our total balance sheet.
Legal costs remained elevated, but our agreement with Freddie Mac marks further progress in resolving legacy issues. Regarding DTA, we utilized $500 million in the third quarter bringing the total utilized to $1.8 billion year-to-date. Our credit quality continued to perform favorably with net credit losses down 38% year-over-year. Our capital and liquidity remained strong as our Basel III Tier I common ratio increased to an estimated 10.4%, our supplementary leverage ratio increased to an estimated 5.1% and we ended the quarter with an estimated LCR of a 113%. Turning to slide 3, we summarized Citigroup’s financial results for the quarter. We are in 3.3 billion in the third quarter roughly flat to last year as lower operating expenses and lower credit cost were offset by a decline in revenues as well as a higher tax rate.
As I discussed the revenue environment was challenging in the third quarter but we maintained our focus on expense discipline. Year-to-date revenues grew 2% while expenses declined 1% and credit cost also improved driving 14% net income growth year-over-year and as Eric will cover in more detail Citigroup end of period loans were flat year-over-year at 658 billion as growth in Citi Corp was offset by the continued decline in Citi Holdings and deposits grew to $955 billion and with that let me turn it over to Eric Aboaf.
Thank you John. Let me start on slide 4 where I would like to review our continued progress in building our Citi Corp franchise by winding down Citi Holding. Citi Corp assets have grown since the end of 2012 as we continue to lend to both consumer and corporate clients. At the same time holding assets declined by 9 billion this quarter and by nearly 50 billion in the past year to a 122 billion or 6% of our consolidated balance sheet.
The 9 billion reduction of the third quarter reflected 4 billion of asset sales and 5 billion of net pay downs. The Citi Holdings risk weighted assets declined by 14 billion to approximately 233 billion or 20% of our total Basal III risk weighted assets. We also continue to reduce the earnings drag associated with holdings. Pretax losses in holdings have declined sequentially for each of the last three quarters to approximately 500 million this quarter even excluding the release of roughly 300 million of incremental mortgage reserves.
While we expect legal and related cost to remain elevated in the near term our agreements with Freddie Mac in September, Fannie Mae in June and the FHFA in May indicate our continued progress in resolving our legacy legal matters.
On slide 5, we show credit trends in the Citi Holdings North America mortgage portfolio which is our largest remaining legacy pool. We ended the quarter with 76 billion of North American mortgages down 20% from a year ago and 4% quarter-over-quarter. We sold roughly 500 million of mortgages this quarter most of which were non-performing for a total of 6.3 billion of mortgages sales year-to-date.
Credit trends continue to be favorable in the third quarter with net credit losses declining to just over 400 million down 50% from last year and down 24% from last quarter. We utilize existing reserves to offset NCL [ph] and release an incremental 300 million of reserves as well driven by continued improvements in delinquencies and home prices year-to-date.
Our current reserves against this portfolio are 5.7 billion representing 40 month of NCL coverage and a 115% of 30 days delinquent loans. Looking to the fourth quarter assuming the U.S. economic environment remains favorable, we expect to utilize loan loss reserves to offset virtually all our mortgage net credit losses but we do not currently anticipate additional reserve or leases beyond that point. The NCL rate improved by nearly 50 basis point sequentially to 2.1%. Our $76 billion portfolio includes approximately 12 billion of legacy Citi Financial loans the majority of which are residential first mortgages while the NCL rates on to the financial loans have improved the loss rates on these loans tend to be higher at just over 5% in the third quarter as compared to less than 1% for residential first mortgages originated by Citi Mortgage. We have also witnessed a significant decline in the balance of the word delinquencies in this portfolio with three day delinquencies down 40% since last year and 9% sequentially to 5 billion of improvement across all our delinquency buckets.
Within this portfolio we have seen the most significant balance reductions in the buckets with the highest LTV and lowest FICOs as you can see in detail on Slide 26 in the appendix.
Let me now turn to Slide 6 with a review of how we are managing our overall balance sheet to achieve our return targets. Over the last two years, we have managed our balance sheet down from the $2 trillion average we had been running while adding both client loans and deposits in a disciplined manner. This quarter we again maintained our average and end-of-period GAAP assets at approximately $1.9 trillion. We believe that by managing a compact balance sheet, we can focus on our net interest margin which helps improve our returns, while continuing to operate at appropriate levels of leverage. Sequentially, total assets increased as our cash balances were up due to deposit inflows and the depreciation in the dollar increase the value of our other non-dollar assets. Sequentially, loans grew by $15 billion during the third quarter as we increased lending to our core client base and added the Best Buy cards portfolio.
On the liability side to the right, we have maintained our deposits at roughly half of our balance sheet. Sequentially, deposits increased $17 billion as we experienced significant inflows of corporate deposits both during and late in the quarter, a trend we have seen recently. Our long-term debt was flat in the third quarter and our equity base grew by $5 billion due to our retained earnings, a $1 billion improvement in our AOCI and our issuance of $1 billion of preferred stock. Overall, our balance sheet structure provides a stable funding mix and has allowed us to maintain a relatively stable net interest margin in the face of declining interest rates globally.
On Slide 7, let me summarize the regional composition of our loan portfolio as we deploy capital in support of our core client activities. Excluding FX in our consumer businesses, we saw year-over-year growth in all regions. North America consumer loans grew 3% year-over-year primarily reflecting the addition of nearly $7 billion of receivables from our Best Buy portfolio acquisition. International consumer banking loans increased 5% year-over-year led by double-digit growth in Mexico, Hong Kong and Singapore and offset by our ongoing repositioning in South Korea.
Our overall corporate loan portfolio grew 9% year-over-year, excluding FX with 9% growth in Asia and 7% growth in Latin America. Overall, our loan portfolio and transaction services grew 20% reflecting origination growth and a consolidation of our trade loan portfolio North America last quarter. We saw more modest 2% growth in our traditional corporate lending portfolio. Loan demand reminds me that given corporate clients, high cash balances, access to alternative means of liquidity in the corporate bond market and general macroeconomic uncertainties.
Turning to Slide 8. I would like to review the credit trends on our Citicorp consumer and corporate loan portfolios globally. So you can see how our geographically diversified portfolios have performed over time. The top half of the page illustrates Citicorp’s consumer credit trends across our four regions. In the third quarter, total consumer credit losses continued to fall reaching 2.4% of the portfolio which reflects the high quality of our loans. We have approximately $11 billion of reserves against this portfolio or 19 months of coincident NCL coverage.
Credit quality in North America continued to improve in the third quarter with a decline in the NCL rate reflecting both underlying improvement in the portfolios and the impact of the purchase accounting for Best Buy portfolio acquisition. In Asia and EMEA, we also saw stable to improving credit trends. And in the Latin America, the net credit loss rate has remained fairly flat for the past several years – I am sorry past several quarters. We expect the fourth quarter NCL rate in Latin America to remain roughly flat to the third quarter levels. However, as we discussed last week, we have added reserves for exposure to the top three Mexican homebuilders as well as for the potential effects of recent hurricanes, each of which could possibly increase our NCL rate in the coming quarters.
The bottom half of the page highlights the quality of our corporate portfolio. Non-accrual loans as a percentage of corporate loans continues to improve and as of the third quarter was approximately 67 basis points for the entire portfolio. Current loan loss reserves allocated to our corporate loan portfolio provide non-accrual loan coverage of approximately 1.4 times. We believe our portfolio is high-quality and well-diversified. Approximately 70% of the portfolio’s investment grade in no country outside of the U.S. or the UK is greater than 5% of the total corporate loan portfolio. On slide 9, I like to provide some further texture around the largest emerging market exposures in our consumer corporate credit portfolios. We believe emerging markets GDP growth will continue to outpace the developed markets growth even though recent EM growths have slowed and we’re uniquely positioned to benefit from this opportunity.
We target high quality consumer and corporate segments globally and we benefit from long established franchises in the emerging markets which provide us with the local market expertise to manage these portfolios. In the consumer business we’re focused on high quality consumer segments in the 150 largest cities in the world. In general these customers have proven to be more resilient through economic cycles.
As you can see on the top half of the page 42% of our consumer loans are in the emerging markets for the largest five emerging markets representing 28% of loans. The largest of these exposures are in Mexico and South Korea, NCL trends in Mexico have remained fairly stable for the past few quarters for the loss rate of just under 4%.
And in Korea while we’re currently repositioning that market to better reflect our franchise around the world which is having an impact on revenue credit trends have remained favorable with an NCL rate of 1.2% in the third quarter. Singapore, Hong Kong and India round out our Top 5 EM exposures and our consumer NCL rate in each of these countries was 80 basis points or less in the third quarter as you can see on slide 34 in the appendix.
On the bottom of the page we cover our institutional business. Our core clients here are top multinational corporates. These clients value both our international network and the depth of our local capabilities. Just under half of our corporate loans are in the emerging market for no country accounts for more than 5% of the total of our EM loans 45% are generated by our transaction services business mostly trade finance which is generally short-term secured loans, and about 40% of the EM portfolio is traditional corporate lending. Generally, the global multinationals and large locally based multinational corporations. While the composition of the corporate loan portfolio varies by market you can see the breakdown of our largest EM exposures in Brazil, India and China on slide 35 in the appendix. Importantly, you can also see on that slide that our next credit losses year-to-date in these markets have been low. Emerging market growth rates have slowed and will likely remain uneven. While this has affected our revenue growth in certain markets the credit quality of our portfolio has remained broadly stable. This is a function of both our focus on target clients as opposed to mass-market approach as well as the improved resiliency of these markets. As compared to a decade or two ago, many emerging markets are in better fiscal health and therefore better able to manage through economic cycles and other global events.
Turning to slide 10 let’s spend a moment looking at deposits which serve as our primary source of funding for our bank. Average deposits were roughly flat year-over-year notwithstanding the transfer of $23 billion of deposits to Morgan Stanley during the third quarter. Year-over-year consumer banking deposits increased 2% ex-effect [ph] as 8% domestic growth was offset by declines in Asia where we consciously reduce our cost of funds and lower or high deposit to loan ratio Corporate deposits increased 1% year-over-year, transaction services deposits increased 4% percent year-over-year or 15 billion with strong deposit growths in North America and EMEA. In Asia we purposely reduced our high cost time deposits. Deposit growth in transaction services was offset by an 8% or 9 billion decline in securities and banking. Within this segment, private bank deposits continue to grow while we reduce deposit balances with our market counterparties. Although our average deposits for approximately flat sequentially or end of period deposits increased by $17 billion driven by underlying business growth as well as some episodic inflows in our transaction services business around quarter end. As expected some of these episodic deposits have already flowed out.
Our deposit base remains a low-cost, and flexible source of funds. Cost have declined significantly in recent quarters so a new low of 53 basis points this quarter. Now let me turn to slide 11 to cover our long-term debt, which is the primary source of funding for our non-bank subsidiaries and provide supplemental funding for our banking subsidiaries. This chart shows the composition of our long-term debt outstanding with a breakdown of parent company and bank level debt. As you can see, we have reshaped our long-term debt footprint to better match our funding needs as we have de-leveraged our balance sheet and reduced the size of Citi Holdings. This quarter, our total long-term debt balance remained flat as the continued reduction in unsecured debt at the parent company was offset by issuance of credit card securitizations at the bank.
In the fourth quarter, we expect these trends to continue with a modest further reduction in unsecured parent company debt offset by growth in our securitization activities at the bank. We have maintained our weighted average maturity in the seven-year range to ensure the stability of our long-term debt funding base. We will continue to optimize our funding profile tapping a variety of markets to achieve our funding cost liquidity and capital objectives. And of course, our debt profile will also depend on pending new regulatory debt requirements. During 2013, we reentered the credit card securitization issuance market after a multi-year absence.
On Slide 12, we offer some historical perspective on this portion of our bank level funding. During the last decade, Citibank was a leading issuer of credit card securitizations with firm issuances peaking at $18 billion in 2007. However, as our deposit balances grew and we optimize our balance sheet, we had little need for long-term borrowings at the bank. So we reduced outstandings in card securitization through runoff and buybacks from $62 billion in 2007 to $23 billion at the end of last year. As we look to optimize both our funding and liquidity position, we find that card securitizations are once again an attractive funding source to complement our deposit base.
We have issued $7.4 billion of term ABS out of CCCIT so far in 2013 diversifying our offerings across the range of maturities to accommodate various investor preferences. The funding cost in the securitization markets are very stable and are attractive relative to our other term funding sources while also providing term structure that helps us manage our liquidity profile. We wouldn’t expect our outstanding balances to reach the levels we saw in 2009, but we expect our borrowings in this market to grow over the next few years as we take advantage of this funding opportunity. Our U.S. Citi branded cards business manages nearly $70 billion of credit card receivables and achieved the net credit loss rate of 3.5% in the third quarter, down over 60 basis points year-over-year. We share data on our Credit Card Master Trust, which include a subset of our receivables on our Investor Relations website.
Slide 13 provides further context for issuance and buyback activity at our parent company. In 2012, we significantly reduced our debt outstanding through a combination of maturities and liability management initiatives offset by issuance for net long-term debt redemptions of $60 billion. In 2013, we followed a similar approach to reduce our parent long-term debt outstanding although at a much more moderate pace and expect approximately $20 billion of net redemptions for the full year. We expect full year 2013 maturities at the parent company of approximately $29 billion, of which $22 billion have already occurred and $7 billion mature in the fourth quarter. We are targeting buybacks, tenders and redemptions of $12 billion to $15 billion for the full year, which is slightly higher than what we said previously, because we have already completed $11 billion year-to-date, which leaves somewhere between $1 billion to $4 billion during the fourth quarter. As such, we expect our total issuance volume to also increase somewhat to $20 billion to $25 billion for the full year given the $19 billion we have issued during the first three quarters of 2013.
Our issuance for the fourth quarter will ultimately depend however to some extent on our liability management actions during the quarter. If we see attractive buybacks opportunities, our issuance for the quarter could be as much as $5 billion, including the $2 billion earlier this week. If these opportunities don’t materialize, our issuance for the quarter could be only a few billion dollars again including what we have done so far earlier this week. During 2013, we also exchanged $3 billion trust preferred the last of the securities held by the U.S. government and saw them place with private investors.
And let me also mention of our preferred stock issuance. During the third quarter we issued nearly a $1 billion of preferred stock with strong retail sponsorship to increase our total outstanding to $5 billion. We expect to issue additional preferred stock over the next few years as we ease into the Basel III capital requirements. We expect that issuance to occur at a measured pace in light of our overall capital strength and the extended timeline to full Basel III implementation through to 2019. Now that I've covered deposits and long-term debt, on slide 14 I would like to discuss our liquidity position. We currently have $410 billion of high quality unencumbered liquid assets, up from 404 billion a year ago and up from 388 billion last quarter. We size our liquid resources to ensure that we have sufficient liquidity available to meet our operating needs and to withstand a wide variety of stress market conditions.
As we have said previously, we expect to operate with a Basel III LCR in the range of 110% going forward with a potential for some modest variability as we saw this quarter. At the end of the third quarter our estimated LCR was approximately 113% representing excess liquidity of roughly 48 billion above the proposed fully phased in 100% LCR threshold. The quarter-over-quarter increase in our LCR was driven by the episodic corporate deposit inflows we experienced in late September, and since some of these deposits have already run off other things being equal, we would expect our fourth quarter LCR to return closer to our 110% target.
As you know our estimates of LCR based on the Basel Committee’s proposal from earlier this year. The FED has announced they will be considering proposed U.S. rules relating to quantitative liquidity requirements at a meeting tomorrow. We will of course be revealing any such proposed rules.
On slide 15, you can see how the [indiscernible] trends that we reviewed affect our net interest revenue and margin. In the third quarter net interest revenue of 11.5 billion was flat sequentially [indiscernible] well net interest margin decreased by 4 basis points to 2.81% reflecting lower loan yields and an increasing cash balances partially offset by an improvement in funding cost. Loan yields declined by 11 basis points in the quarter, our deposit cost continues to decline as well. Total deposit cost decreased to a new low of 53 basis points this quarter with improvements in both our U.S. and international deposit base looking at the fourth quarter we expect NIM to remain roughly flat.
As we have discussed on previous calls our net interest revenue and margin would benefit from rising rates. In a 100 basis point upward parallel rise in rates around the world, we estimate our net interest revenue would increase by $1.8 billion or an 11 basis point benefit to NIM in line with last quarter as our assets would reprice faster than our liabilities allowing us to reinvest at higher spreads.
Similar to last quarter, we remain more sensitive to rates move inside of five years into the longer end of the curve.
In this scenario, we estimate our OCI would decline by approximately 2.5 billion after tax as declines in our securities portfolio would partly offset by improvements and the OCI related to our pension plans. The net effect of this change in our OCI equates to a decline of approximately 35 basis points in our Basal III Tier I common ratio and remains an important component of how we size our capital buffers. Turning to slide 16, let me summarize our capital position which remains among the strongest in the industry as compared to both our U.S. and international banking peers. During the third quarter our capital ratios continue to strengthen driven by retained earnings and DTA utilization.
Under Basel III our estimated fully phased in Tier 1 common ratio increased to 10.4% up from 10% in the second quarter. Our reported Basel III capital ratios are based on our advanced approach methodology as that yields a lower capital ratio and under the standardized approach. As you know, the fully implemented U.S. rules require that we report the lower of the two ratios. Citigroup supplementary leverage ratio as calculated using the final U.S. Basel III rules was an estimated 5.1% for the third quarter and the SLR to the bank remained above 6%. Separately, we are still awaiting guidance on how the potential regulatory requirements under OLA could impact our capital structure. As we said last quarter and as we show on Slide 21 in the appendix, we believe that we are well-positioned for a range of proposals.
Moving on to our last slide let me summarize four major points. First, while the environment remains challenging, we continue to make progress in our execution priorities and we continue to grow Citicorp deposits and loans year-over-year. Second, we are well-reserved in our credit trends remains favorable reflecting the high quality of both our consumer and corporate portfolios. Third, our capital base continues to be one of the strongest in the industry. This is reflected across each of our significant capital ratios, including our Basel III Tier 1 Common which reached 10.4% at the end of the third quarter. Our liquidity remains strong and our estimated liquidity coverage ratio was 113% comfortably above the proposed minimum. Fourth and lastly, we have efficiently managed our balance sheet at approximately $1.9 trillion and expect to remain around this level. Our NIM outlook is stable for the fourth quarter and our estimated supplementary leverage ratio was 5.1%.
That concludes our fixed income review. John and I will be happy to take your questions.
Earnings Call Part 2:
- Investment & Company Information
- balance sheet