ETF Or ETN? What's The Difference?

Investopedia

Exchange traded funds (ETFs) are the hottest thing since the mutual fund. In fact, the investment product is on track to replace mutual funds with its often-lower fee structure and easier-to-understand stock-like price action.

ETFs have a not-so-well-known cousin. The exchanged traded note (ETN) is something that many, if not most, retail investors know nothing about. It is time to shed some light on the ETN and decide if this product has a place in your portfolio.

Top Investment Trends For 2013: We go over a few investment trends for you to think about for 2013.

How Are They different?
In practice, the two are very similar. Both are designed to track an underlying asset, both often have lower expense ratios than actively managed mutual funds, and both trade on the major exchanges just like stock.

The main difference is under the hood. When you invest in an ETF, you are investing into a fund that holds the asset it tracks. That asset may be stocks, bonds, gold or other commodities, or futures contracts.

An ETN is more like a bond. It's an unsecured debt note issued by an institution. Just like with a bond, an ETN can be held to maturity, bought or sold at will, and if the underwriter (usually a bank) were to go bankrupt, the investor would risk a total default.

SEE: ETN Credit Risk may Outweigh Benefits For Some

For that reason, before investing in an ETN, research into the credit rating of the underwriter is an important metric. If the underwriter were to receive a credit downgrade, shares of the ETN would likely experience a downturn unrelated to the underlying product it's tracking.

Tax implications come into play with ETNs. In this case, lack of clarity may be a problem. The IRS hasn't provided clear guidance related to ETNs, but for now, tax treatment seems to be more favorable. Just like with any investment, if you sell for more than you purchased, you trigger capital gains taxes, but inside the fund is where the differences lie.

Because an ETN doesn't buy and sell assets within the funds like an ETF, taxes are not triggered until the fund is sold - often years later. This will trigger long-term capital gains (which have a lower tax rate) rather than short-term capital gains.

SEE: How To Reduce Taxes On ETF Gains

No Tracking Errors
Another advantage to ETN investing is the lack of tracking errors. There are more than 1,400 ETFs currently on the market. They achieve varying levels of success when tracking their respective index. Because of expenses, investors will notice some amount of divergence from the index they track, making the fund underperform the index over time.

This does not happen with ETNs. Because an ETN does not rely on the buying and selling of the underlying asset, expenses are not amassed. An ETN simply pays investors once the fund matures based on the price of the asset or index. There's no tracking error because the fund itself isn't actively tracking. Market forces will cause the fund to track the underlying instrument, but it's not the fund doing the tracking.

Which Is Better?
If you follow the age-old rule that says you should invest only into what you understand, ETFs are a better choice. Part-time investors have an easier time understanding products with stock-like characteristics. Since an ETN has bond-like characteristics, it's more complicated.

The most popular exchange traded products are ETFs. One of most popular ETNs is the JP Morgan Alerian MLP Index ETN (ARCA:AMJ), but this fund only has an average volume of 295,000 shares. The SPDR S&P 500 (ARCA:SPY) ETF, by contrast, has an average daily volume of 137 million shares. This clearly shows that investor appetite is heavily weighted toward ETFs.

Don't count out ETNs. These funds are more efficient than some ETFs and have, at least for now, favorable tax treatment for longer-term investors.

The Bottom Line
ETFs are exponentially larger in collective volume than ETNs, but much like stocks versus bonds, stocks receive more attention from retail investors because they are easier to understand. Deciding that ETNs are right for your portfolio is appropriate, provided you have done research and gained an appropriate level of understanding with which to make that determination.



More From Investopedia
View Comments

Recommended for You

  • First lady gets resume from girl with jobless dad

    WASHINGTON (AP) — Michelle Obama's annual question-and-answer session with the children of Executive Office employees took a serious turn Thursday when a 10-year-old girl in the front row told the first lady that her dad had been out of work for three years. Then the girl popped up to hand the…

    Associated Press
  • In Disney's shadow, homeless families struggle

    KISSIMMEE, Fla. (AP) — When they moved from Georgia to the theme park playground of central Florida four years ago, Anthony and Candice Johnson found work at a barbecue restaurant and a 7-Eleven. Their combined salaries nevertheless fell short of what they needed to rent an apartment, so the couple…

    Associated Press
  • Musk’s Tesla Income Plummets 99.9% to Less Than $70,000

    Elon Musk, Tesla Motors Inc. (TSLA) ’s chief executive and one of the wealthiest U.S. entrepreneurs, saw his take-home pay from the automaker plunge by more than 99.9 percent last year after a surge in his 2012 stock options. Compensation for the leader of the youngest publicly held U.S. automaker…

    Bloomberg
  • Putin Says Visa and MasterCard Will Lose Market Share

    Russian President Vladimir Putin said Visa Inc. (V) and MasterCard Inc. (MA) will lose market share in Russia after they blocked some transactions because of U.S. sanctions on individuals and banks. “We don’t see any steps to punish unconscionable partners, but they are undermining trust, hence…

    Bloomberg
  • Play

    Best Credit Card for Travel Rewards?

    WSJ travel columnist Scott McCartney discusses the new Orbitz reward credit card and others that up the ante for the travel rewards category on Lunch Break.

    WSJ Live
  • Here's why the biotech bounce may be short lived

    Will biotech get its mojo back or is it a dead cat bounce?

    Talking Numbers
  • Cramer: Tech stock heading to $70

    Jim Cramer looks at many metrics as he decides where to put money. And in the case of this tech firm, he's spotted something very bullish.

    CNBC
  • Why it may be time to fold on casinos

    Casino stocks have been on a winning streak. But is it time to fold them?

    Talking Numbers
  • Russia's Putin calls the Internet a 'CIA project'

    MOSCOW (AP) — President Vladimir Putin on Thursday called the Internet a CIA project and made comments about Russia's biggest search engine Yandex, sending the company's shares plummeting.

    Associated Press
  • North Dakota finds more radioactive oil waste

    BISMARCK, N.D. (AP) — North Dakota confirmed Thursday the discovery of a new radioactive dump of waste from oil drilling, and separately a company hired to clean up waste found in February at another location said it removed double the amount of radioactive material originally estimated to be there.

    Associated Press
  • Business Insider
  • Buffett disapproves of Coca-Cola's pay plan

    NEW YORK (AP) — Warren Buffett criticized Coca-Cola's pay plan for its executives on Wednesday.

    Associated Press
  • Play

    Wall Street Bracing for Key Tech Earnings

    Polya Lesova takes a look at the markets, including three stocks to watch today. Photo: Andrew St. Clair for The Wall Street Journal.

    WSJ Live
  • Pros and Cons of Paying Off Your Student Loans Early

    While paying off your student loans early seems like a no-brainer, it might not always be the best financial decision. Here are some of the pros and cons to paying off your student loans early, and some tips on how to pay them off. Paying off your student loan debt early can save you a good chunk…

    The Fiscal Times
  • US oil stockpiles hit record amid production boom

    US commercial oil stockpiles hit a new record last week on the strength of continued growth in oil and gas production in the world's biggest oil-consuming country. Commercial stocks rose 3.5 million barrels to 397.7 million barrels for the week ended April 18, according to US Energy Information…

    AFP
  • Microsoft's Surface Tablet Sales Tanked

    Sales of Microsoft's Surface tablet were way...

    Business Insider
  • Amazon launches grocery service for Prime members

    NEW YORK (AP) — Amazon is taking aim at grocery stores and discounters like Wal-Mart with a grocery service that lets its Prime loyalty club members fill up to a 45-pound box with groceries and get it shipped for a flat rate of $5.99.

    Associated Press
  • Ex Wal-Mart CEO's deferred pay: $140 million

    Wal-mart CEO got $140 million in deferred pay, $20 million in stock gains

    USA TODAY
  • Study: US manufacturers gaining competitiveness

    WASHINGTON (AP) — U.S. manufacturers have grown more competitive over the past decade compared with factories in China, Brazil and most of the world's other major economies.

    Associated Press
  • Play

    Microsoft Posts Smaller-Than-Expected Profit Decline

    The first earnings report for Microsoft under new CEO Satya Nadella showed strong fiscal third-quarter sales from office tools, database and others programs for computer centers. WSJ's Shira Ovide and Scott Thurm report. (Photo: AP)

    WSJ Live