A Flat Tax: The Good, the Bad and Why It Probably Won’t Happen

Money Talks News

With tax season upon us, you may be wondering why the government has to make things so complex.

According to the CCH Standard Federal Tax Reporter, the tax code clocks in at an astounding 73,954 pages as of 2013. It includes seven tax rates, four standard deductions and at least a dozen tax credits for individuals. Then there are the exemptions, the itemized deductions and the special tax rules.

And when you think you’re starting to understand how the system works, the government likes to throw in a few curveballs, like the alternative minimum tax.

Wouldn’t it be easier if we eliminated 73,950 pages of hoops and simply taxed everyone using the same percentage?

Well, that depends on who you ask.

Basics of our progressive system

Before delving into the pros and cons of a flat tax, let’s go over how the current system works first. The current federal income tax system is progressive, meaning the more you earn, the higher percentage of taxes you pay.

Here are the brackets for your 2013 taxes (those would be the ones you’re working on right now):

  • 10 percent.
  • 15 percent.
  • 25 percent.
  • 28 percent.
  • 33 percent.
  • 35 percent.
  • 39.6 percent.

Your tax bracket is determined by both your income and your filing status. Your bracket can also depend on your exemptions and deductions, which bring your taxable income down.

In addition, it’s important to know that the tax rates above are marginal. That means, if you fall into the highest tax bracket, you aren’t paying 39.6 percent on all of your income. You only pay that rate on the portion of your income that falls into that tax bracket. For a single filer, that means you would pay 39.6 percent in taxes on any income in excess of $400,000 for 2013.

To help put it into perspective, here’s an example published in Forbes last year that assumes you earn $100,000 and are in the 28 percent tax bracket.

You would owe 10 percent of $8,925, 15 percent of $27,325 (the difference between the top and the threshold of the second tax bracket), 25 percent of $51,600, and 28 percent of $12,150 (the difference between your income and the threshold of the third tax bracket). That calculation results in $21,293, or an effective (not marginal) tax rate of 21.2 percent.

Why having a flat tax would be awesome

If that all seems about as clear as mud, then you have stumbled upon one of the key reasons some people advocate for a flat tax: simplicity.

A flat tax would make taxes easy. No matter what you earn, you would pay one rate for all your income. A pure flat tax would also eliminate deductions and credits to further streamline tax filing and payment. In arguing for his flat tax proposal three years ago, Texas Gov. Rick Perry said taxes would become so simple that taxpayers would be able to “complete their returns in minutes and submit them on a postcard.”

Proponents of the flat tax also say that beyond being simple, it’s also fair. Since everyone would pay the same tax rate, all would be contributing an equal proportion of their income to the maintenance of government services.

Finally, flat tax supporters say a simplified, uniform tax rate would encourage economic growth. They say that many fast-growing economies are found in countries that have flat, rather than progressive, tax systems.

Why having a flat tax would be awful

Opponents of the flat tax say supporters are blowing smoke and are actually intent on creating a system that favors the wealthy.

While flat tax supporters point to former Soviet countries as examples of nations that saw tremendous economic growth after enacting a flat tax, opponents say the success in Eastern Europe has been overblown. In addition, some countries that had enacted a flat tax are now repealing those laws.

What’s more, opponents say a flat tax may simplify the tax code, but it would do so at the expense of lower- and middle-class families. Most flat tax proposals set taxes in the range of 17 to 20 percent, meaning low earners could pay more while wealthy families get a break. This may be especially true if a pure flat tax is enacted – that is, one that includes no deductions or credits.

Not only would a flat tax widen wealth inequality in the country, opponents say it might allow the rich to duck paying taxes on a large portion of their income. Many proposals exempt investment income, which can be a major source of money for some affluent households. Small businesses may also suffer under a flat tax if they are unable to deduct expenses that cut into profits.

And why you may never see a flat tax

While the debate regarding the flat tax can be interesting and heated, it’s largely theoretical at this point. Consider how many politicians and economists have advocated for a flat tax during the past 30-plus years. Here’s a sampling, compiled by NPR:

  • 1981. Hoover Institution economists promoted a 19 percent flat tax that would exempt lower-income households, such as families of four earning less than $25,500 annually.
  • 1992. California Gov . Jerry Brown, a Democrat, proposed a 13 percent flat tax with limited exemptions. He also suggested we scrap the Social Security tax.
  • 1996. Republican Steve Forbes made a flat tax one of the centerpieces of his presidential bid. His plan would allow standard and dependent deductions while instituting a 17 percent flat tax.
  • 2011. Several Republican presidential candidates embraced the flat tax that year. Herman Cain recommended it be set at 9 percent while Rick Perry proposed an optional 20 percent tax.

However, these proposals and others like them have failed to gain traction. It’s not necessarily because people love the current tax system. Even those who oppose the flat tax say our current tax code is broken.

However, when our Congress can’t even agree on an annual budget, it seems unlikely it will be able to crack open the tax code and make meaningful changes, whether that would be to simplify the current version or replace it altogether.

So for now, it appears we are stuck with 73,954 pages of tax time fun. To make preparation a little less painful this year, check the Money Talks News series on Tax Hacks 2014, which include, among other things, information on how to avoid expensive mistakes and audit-proof your return.

As for the flat tax, what do you think? Do you prefer the simplicity of a flat tax or do you think those with more money should pay more taxes? Let us know in the comments below or on our Facebook page.

This article was originally published on MoneyTalksNews.com as 'A Flat Tax: The Good, the Bad and Why It Probably Won’t Happen'.

More from Money Talks News

View Comments

Recommended for You

  • 5 Ways to Run Out of Money in Retirement

    Retirement is a balancing act. So what throws people off balance in retirement? If you approach retirement income this way, you can get yourself in trouble. Your retirement income gas gauge isn't only there to tell you when to slow down -- it can also tell you when there is room to step on the gas.

    U.S.News & World Report LP
  • Ford to offer 50th anniversary Mustang

    NEW YORK (AP) — Ford is celebrating the 50th anniversary of the Mustang with a limited-edition model and a display atop the Empire State Building.

    Associated Press
  • Anti-Aging Creams of 2014

    The retinol cream that stands the test of time. Discover why dermatologists recommend this wrinkle product more than cosmetic injections.

    AdChoices LifeCellSponsored
  • Why Rich People Feel Poor

    An adjusted gross income of $389,000 puts you in the top 1 percent of earners in 2011, according to the latest IRS data. Even the House Republicans have been silent lately on taxes on top earners, as Bloomberg's Richard Rubin notes.

  • Business Insider
  • 'Final Fantasy' Comes to an End for Sony

    Following a string of sales from prime properties to its Vaio personal computer brand, Sony says it's now letting go of its stake in videogame publisher Square Enix.

    The Wall Street Journal
  • China Film takes 1st stake in Hollywood movies

    HONG KONG (AP) — China's state-owned film distributor is making its first investment in Hollywood movies by taking a stake in two Legendary Entertainment productions.

    Associated Press
  • Toyota Responds to Hyundai’s Sonata With Refreshed Camry

    Toyota Motor Corp. (7203) is making rare styling changes in the Camry sedan just halfway into the car's usual design cycle, a sign the automaker is eager to stem gains made by Hyundai Motor Co. (005380)'s ...

  • Immigration activists urge Obama to act boldly

    WASHINGTON (AP) — Latinos and immigration activists are warning of political peril for President Barack Obama and Democrats in the fall election unless the president acts boldly and soon to curb deportations and allow more immigrants to remain legally in the U.S.

    Associated Press
  • Brain Training Games

    Challenge your brain with games from Lumosity.com, the personal trainer for your brain.

    AdChoices LumositySponsored
  • Play

    March Consumer Price Index up More Than Expected

    Sital Patel takes a look at the markets, including three stocks to watch today. Photo: Getty.

    WSJ Live
  • Donald Rumsfeld declares war on IRS

    Did you file your taxes correctly? That's a known unknown

  • Aston Martin Unveils Sub-$100,000 Edition for North America

    Aston Martin Lagonda Ltd., the British maker of the luxury sports cars driven by James Bond, is unveiling two special edition vehicles at the New York International Auto Show this week. Aston Martin will ...

  • If filed, plane lawsuits might not get heard in US

    BEIJING (AP) — Since Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 went missing, some lawyers have claimed they can get several millions of dollars in damages for each lost passenger by taking the cases to the United States. But past lawsuits show U.S. federal courts are more likely to throw such cases out if the…

    Associated Press
  • 6 Retirement Concerns Couples Need to Address

    Being married is wonderful, as the pair of you can help support one another through the good and bad times. Marriage also helps on the financial side too, because life together is often less expensive ...

    U.S.News & World Report LP
  • German company starts gas deliveries to Ukraine

    BERLIN (AP) — German utility company RWE said Tuesday it has started sending natural gas to Ukraine, a move that could support the country if Russia acts on its threat to cut off supplies because of a massive debt for past deliveries.

    Associated Press
  • New Site Grants Access to Anyone's Public Record

    Did you know that your record in online and anyone can see it? Search through millions of public records and see what you can find.

    AdChoices Instant Checkmate Sponsored
  • Chinese gold demand may rise 20% by 2017: industry body

    London (AFP) - China's annual demand for gold could jump around 20 percent by 2017 as more of its increasingly wealthy population seek new ways to make money, the World Gold Council predicted on Tuesday.

  • Why Your Neighbors Will Finance Solar Panels for Your Roof

    Here’s another reason to be nice to the neighbors: They might just give you a no-money-down, low-cost loan to put solar panels on your roof, and once you pay off that debt you’ll get essentially free electricity as long as you own your home. In the coming months, the environmentally minded can go…

    The Atlantic
  • Play

    Yahoo Earnings Boosted by Alibaba Numbers

    For the first time in more than a year, Yahoo is growing, buoyed by strong numbers at Alibaba. Miriam Gottfried joins MoneyBeat.

    WSJ Live
  • Fuji Heavy plans factory to make Boeing 777X wing boxes: Nikkei

    (Reuters) - Japan's Fuji Heavy Industries Ltd plans to open a plant as early as next year to build wing boxes for Boeing Co's 777X passenger jet, the Nikkei reported. Fuji Heavy, which makes Subaru cars, will likely spend more than 10 billion yen ($98 million) to construct the factory at the same…

  • The 5 Dumbest Credit Moves

    Consider, if you will, some of the more ridiculous examples of people who needlessly put their credit in jeopardy, and how you can avoid their mistakes.

  • Play

    How to Get Income, and More, From a Fund

    Dividend funds are complicated. This income-producing Vanguard portfolio offers exposure to stocks with Buffett-esque qualities.

    WSJ Live
  • Bad News for Agents, Great for Virginia Drivers

    If you are currently insured, have no DUI's, and drive less than 50 miles per day, you may be paying too much for auto insurance. Find out now.

    AdChoices FreeRateReport.comSponsored