A 'Potent One-Two Punch' Has Wal-Mart Execs Freaking Out In Internal Emails

Business Insider

Emails dug up by Bloomberg News have revealed that Wal-Mart is having a terrible start to the month.

Execs were freaking out.

One called it a "total disaster," and said that it was the worst start to a month that he'd seen in seven years at the retailer,   according to the emails .

Two execs identified a pair of factors that are causing this to happen.

Finance and logistics VP Jerry Murray and U.S. replenishment SVP Cameron Geiger called out increased payroll taxes and delayed tax returns as the culprits.

Geiger called them "a potent one-two punch" in one of the leaked emails.

So, what's going on here?

  1. In 2012, shoppers had received nearly $20 billion more in tax refunds by this time of the year, according to Wal-Mart Global Customer Insights & Analytics division.  Now, Wal-Mart expects returns to be delayed by three to four weeks.
  2. Back on December 31, a payroll tax break expired, and Americans started to pay 2 percent more in Social Security taxes.  For someone making $40,000 a year, it's about $15 more a week. Or, for a family making $30,000, it's about a year of car insurance, according to Wal-Mart.

Now, look back to January. Consumers still hit the stores despite the tax hike and general merchandise came out okay — spending rose about 1 percent, according to Marketwatch.

The Census Bureau reported that  overall retail sales rose a seasonally-adjusted 0.1 percent   during the month, which was in line with expectations.

But this doesn't paint the full picture.

January has always been considered a heavy "clearance" month. Retailers traditionally mark down a lot of their wares in order to get rid of winter merchandise left over from the Christmas rush.

For instance, look at this massive 75 percent off clearance day Wal-Mart had at the beginning of January.

It's a particularly appealing time to shop for those who don't have much left in their wallets.

"Consumers were shopping and hunting for those clearance items," Michael Niemira, chief economist at the ICSC, told the AP. "Despite the strong reading, January may be one of the highest points of the year."

And now, those two punches noted by Wal-Mart execs seem to be hitting in force, without the big clearances of old holiday merchandise to prop it up.

Which raises the question: If a mega-giant like Wal-Mart is struggling in the face of these external factors, what about its weaker competitors?  

"It could mean that more retailers are researching and will put out major earnings warnings," said NBG Productions chief equities analyst Brian Sozzi. "There's no reason to be optimistic."

We'll get a lot more information on February 21 when Wal-Mart reports its Q4 earnings.

Watch Below: Economist Paul Krugman Explains How We Should Be Taxing The Rich

  //
Please enable Javascript to watch this video


More From Business Insider
View Comments