Megabanks are still growing after Dodd-Frank, but their slightly smaller competitors are growing much faster

Quartz

The United States’ biggest banks—the ones that were “too big to fail” during the financial meltdown they helped to cause—have grown even larger since the crisis. The Wall Street reforms of the Dodd-Frank Act, critics argue, clearly aren’t working.

That might be the case, but the real story is a little more complex. Assets at the seven biggest banks like Bank of America, Citibank, and JP Morgan Chase (which all have assets over $500 billion), have grown about 3% from the second quarter of 2010 when Dodd-Frank passed to the end of 2012, according to data from strategy firm Hamilton Place Strategies (HPS).

But the real winners over the same time period have been the 18 medium-large banks with $100-$500 billion under management—companies like Ally Financial, TD Bank, and PNC Financial Services Group—which have grown by 70%. They’ve also increased their market share from 13% to 19%—at the expense of their bigger competitors. Banks with $1 to $100 billion in assets also saw gains.

“These are mostly regional players, maybe entering the national market,” says Patrick Sims, who directs policy research at HPS. He ties this directly to the impact of Dodd-Frank. “Because of regulation there’s more growth coming in at the middle, and that’s because of scale.”

Although the biggest regulatory hammer falls on financial institutions with $50 billion or more in assets, banks of all sizes must adhere to more in-depth reporting requirements—which incurs bigger lawyer fees. Medium-sized banks are in the sweet spot—big enough to absorb the costs of regulatory compliance, but not so big that they attract intense attention like the seven biggest banks.

As we wrote last week, the clear losers are the banks at the very bottom of the size scale with assets of less than $1 billion, which have seen assets shrink by 8% because they’re too small to handle compliance costs.



More from Quartz
View Comments

Recommended for You

  • First lady gets resume from girl with jobless dad

    WASHINGTON (AP) — Michelle Obama's annual question-and-answer session with the children of Executive Office employees took a serious turn Thursday when a 10-year-old girl in the front row told the first lady that her dad had been out of work for three years. Then the girl popped up to hand the…

    Associated Press
  • In Disney's shadow, homeless families struggle

    KISSIMMEE, Fla. (AP) — When they moved from Georgia to the theme park playground of central Florida four years ago, Anthony and Candice Johnson found work at a barbecue restaurant and a 7-Eleven. Their combined salaries nevertheless fell short of what they needed to rent an apartment, so the couple…

    Associated Press
  • Musk’s Tesla Income Plummets 99.9% to Less Than $70,000

    Elon Musk, Tesla Motors Inc. (TSLA) ’s chief executive and one of the wealthiest U.S. entrepreneurs, saw his take-home pay from the automaker plunge by more than 99.9 percent last year after a surge in his 2012 stock options. Compensation for the leader of the youngest publicly held U.S. automaker…

    Bloomberg
  • Putin Says Visa and MasterCard Will Lose Market Share

    Russian President Vladimir Putin said Visa Inc. (V) and MasterCard Inc. (MA) will lose market share in Russia after they blocked some transactions because of U.S. sanctions on individuals and banks. “We don’t see any steps to punish unconscionable partners, but they are undermining trust, hence…

    Bloomberg
  • Cramer: Tech stock heading to $70

    Jim Cramer looks at many metrics as he decides where to put money. And in the case of this tech firm, he's spotted something very bullish.

    CNBC
  • Why it may be time to fold on casinos

    Casino stocks have been on a winning streak. But is it time to fold them?

    Talking Numbers
  • Play

    Best Credit Card for Travel Rewards?

    WSJ travel columnist Scott McCartney discusses the new Orbitz reward credit card and others that up the ante for the travel rewards category on Lunch Break.

    WSJ Live
  • Here's why the biotech bounce may be short lived

    Will biotech get its mojo back or is it a dead cat bounce?

    Talking Numbers
  • Russia's Putin calls the Internet a 'CIA project'

    MOSCOW (AP) — President Vladimir Putin on Thursday called the Internet a CIA project and made comments about Russia's biggest search engine Yandex, sending the company's shares plummeting.

    Associated Press
  • North Dakota finds more radioactive oil waste

    BISMARCK, N.D. (AP) — North Dakota confirmed Thursday the discovery of a new radioactive dump of waste from oil drilling, and separately a company hired to clean up waste found in February at another location said it removed double the amount of radioactive material originally estimated to be there.

    Associated Press
  • Business Insider
  • Buffett disapproves of Coca-Cola's pay plan

    NEW YORK (AP) — Warren Buffett criticized Coca-Cola's pay plan for its executives on Wednesday.

    Associated Press
  • Postal workers' unions protest Staples program

    CONCORD, N.H. (AP) — Postal workers in cities big and small protested in front of Staples stores on Thursday, objecting to the U.S. Postal Service's pilot program to open counters in stores, staffed with retail employees.

    Associated Press
  • Play

    Wall Street Bracing for Key Tech Earnings

    Polya Lesova takes a look at the markets, including three stocks to watch today. Photo: Andrew St. Clair for The Wall Street Journal.

    WSJ Live
  • Pros and Cons of Paying Off Your Student Loans Early

    While paying off your student loans early seems like a no-brainer, it might not always be the best financial decision. Here are some of the pros and cons to paying off your student loans early, and some tips on how to pay them off. Paying off your student loan debt early can save you a good chunk…

    The Fiscal Times
  • US oil stockpiles hit record amid production boom

    US commercial oil stockpiles hit a new record last week on the strength of continued growth in oil and gas production in the world's biggest oil-consuming country. Commercial stocks rose 3.5 million barrels to 397.7 million barrels for the week ended April 18, according to US Energy Information…

    AFP
  • United loses $609M in 1Q; fares don't cover costs

    United Airlines is the one U.S. carrier that can't seem to get its act together.

    Associated Press
  • Study: US manufacturers gaining competitiveness

    WASHINGTON (AP) — U.S. manufacturers have grown more competitive over the past decade compared with factories in China, Brazil and most of the world's other major economies.

    Associated Press
  • Amazon launches grocery service for Prime members

    NEW YORK (AP) — Amazon is taking aim at grocery stores and discounters like Wal-Mart with a grocery service that lets its Prime loyalty club members fill up to a 45-pound box with groceries and get it shipped for a flat rate of $5.99.

    Associated Press
  • Ex Wal-Mart CEO's deferred pay: $140 million

    Wal-mart CEO got $140 million in deferred pay, $20 million in stock gains

    USA TODAY