Morgan Stanley lends to Lotto winner to boost tailored loans

The corporate logo of financial firm Morgan Stanley is pictured on a building in San Diego
The corporate logo of financial firm Morgan Stanley is pictured on a building in San Diego, California September 24, 2013. REUTERS/Mike Blake

By Lauren Tara LaCapra

NEW YORK (Reuters) - Early this year, a New York State Lottery winner in Brooklyn approached Morgan Stanley with a problem: he needed to borrow hundreds of thousands of dollars before he collected his prize money.

The man, a Russian immigrant, wanted money to help move his family to a secure location before he redeemed his ticket and possibly became famous, according to people familiar with the matter who spoke on the condition of anonymity. He also wanted advice about what to do with his prize money, which was in the hundreds of thousands of dollars.

The bank's wealth management unit decided to make the loan to win a new customer, a step it is increasingly willing to make as it builds up its brokerage unit.

Making unusual loans is critical for Morgan Stanley. The bank has bet its future in large part on its wealth management business, which produces more stable revenue than the trading unit that nearly wiped out Morgan Stanley during the financial crisis. Providing unconventional loans is a reliable way to win customers, and keep them.

Morgan Stanley is playing catch-up against rivals including JPMorgan Chase & Co, Citigroup Inc, Deutsche Bank AG and Credit Suisse Group AG, which offer loans collateralized by everything from art collections to cases of wine.

Industry sources said they had never heard of a loan against a lottery ticket, though they cited other examples of atypical collateral that other banks have loaned against, including a client in Texas who borrowed against the future offspring of his prize bulls, and a client who borrowed against future ticket sales of a professional sports team he owned.

"We've got 3 million clients, and they've got borrowing needs," Eric Heaton, who runs Morgan Stanley's private bank, said in an interview.

Reuters attempted to track down the Lotto winner by the description provided by sources familiar with the matter but was unable to confirm his identity.

Tailored loans are lucrative for the bank, which can help Morgan Stanley reach its profitability targets for wealth management. Morgan Stanley's pretax profit margin target is 22 percent to 25 percent by the end of next year, compared with a current level of 20.6 percent, assuming interest rates do not rise.

To spearhead Morgan Stanley's efforts to build up what it calls "tailored lending," the bank hired a team from Deutsche Bank led by Marcus Mitchell. Although Morgan Stanley has been making these loans since 2010, it is ramping up its efforts now. It can make more loans now because it received extra deposits when it bought the portion of Citigroup's retail brokerage that it did not already own last year -- Morgan Stanley now has $130 billion of deposits.


Morgan Stanley spent billions of dollars buying the Smith Barney retail brokerage business from Citigroup between 2009 and 2013, and adding it to its own wealth management unit. In public presentations, executives have continually trumpeted the reliable earnings that wealth management offers, as opposed to businesses like trading, where profit can oscillate wildly. Investment management and retail brokerage accounted for about 30 percent to 40 percent of the bank's quarterly revenue in 2007, a figure that grew to more than half in the second quarter of 2014.

As its lending effort has gotten under way over the past year or two, Morgan Stanley has about $2 billion of tailored loans outstanding, which now account for about 5 percent of the total loans outstanding at its wealth management unit.

Heaton and other executives who spoke to Reuters said they expect tailored lending to remain a relatively small sliver of the wealth management unit's loans. Mortgages in contrast account for about a third of loans at the unit. But tailored loans can be much more profitable-- for some, banks can earn 7.5 percentage points more than their funding costs, said one adviser at a rival firm, who spoke on the condition of anonymity. Morgan Stanley said its profits are much lower on the loans.

But even if the bank's margins on these loans are less than 7.5 percent, industry experts said they are likely much higher than margins on mortgages, which tend to be one percentage point or less.

The wider margins on tailored loans come in part because the loans are so unique. Morgan Stanley mitigates its risk by making sure it has access to collateral that can be sold quickly to recoup the cost of the loan, or that loans have a guarantor with enough assets to repay. It hires appraisers to assess the value of assets it is lending against.

Wealth management clients can borrow against one-of-a-kind assets like rare coins, but tailored loans can also be for assets like commercial real estate, which make up about a quarter of Morgan Stanley's tailored loan book. For loans that fall outside of the bank's comfort zone, like auto loans, the bank refers clients to other lenders, Heaton said.

In the case of the lottery winner, while Morgan Stanley executives would not acknowledge having any relationship with such a client, they did stress that the bank usually has ample collateral, and would not rely on expected lottery winnings alone to back a loan.

"We don't chase Lotto winners in hopes of establishing a relationship," said Heaton. "But if there's a client that comes in with a liability need, we'll look at their financial position and see what we can do to help."

(Reporting by Lauren Tara LaCapra; Editing by Dan Wilchins and John Pickering)

  • Business

    The American retirement crisis is real

    Left-leaning groups and writers have been arguing for years now that America is looking down the barrel of a retirement crisis. "[T]here's very little evidence for any kind of broad retirement crisis," Kevin Drum of Mother Jones argues, needling this "common view on the left, usually delivered with no evidence." So compiling data, he shows that 401(k)s and other retirement accounts have smoothly replaced traditional pensions, and that future income projections forecast a brighter future for retirees. Careful analysis shows that 401(k)s and individual accounts are still far inferior to traditional pensions for most people, and that the future projection relies on a lot of unrealistically rosy assumptions. Let's start where Drum does, with the idea that American retirement is already in a better position than it's given credit for.

    The Week
  • Science

    Meet the (alleged) aliens of Proxima b

    This week, humans announced the discovery of Proxima b, an exoplanet orbiting Proxima Centauri just four light years away, and began immediately speculating about what life it might host and how to visit. The announcement comes decades after the publication of "evidence" that "Cenos" aliens from a planet in the Proxima Centauri system had already made the trip between our planets. According to this evidence, the aliens are about 8 to 8.5 feet tall, humanoid in shape and five times stronger than a human. Super UFO enthusiast Scott Waring posted the Taiwan sighting, which also seems easily explained as some odd light artifacts in a photograph, but you can judge for yourself by watching the local news report below.

  • ACE

    Sears Puts Kenmore, Craftsman Up for Grabs

    Sears Holdings (NASDAQ:SHLD), which booked another loss in the second quarter, has received interest from a variety of companies eyeing the floundering retailer’s familiar appliance, tool and auto brands. The Illinois-based company has grappled with challenges at Sears and Kmart, two chains that struggling to turn things around in a tough environment for retailers. Sears is facing some broader issues.

    Fox Business
  • Entertainment

    Record-holding Batman costume stocked with 23 working Bat-gadgets

    There are normal Guinness World Records, like "most dominoes stacked in 30 seconds" and "largest bubblegum bubble blown." And then there are are some obscure ones, like "most apples crushed with the bicep in one minute" and "most functional gadgets on a cos-play suit." The latter honor goes to Julian Checkley, the man inside a totally bonkers Batman suit loaded with 23 working gadgets. Guinness refers to Checkley as a "special creature effects expert," which sounds like an amazing job. Checkley didn't make the 3D-printed hard armor parts of the suit himself, but his company, Order 66 Creatures and Effects, created all the prop gadgets. Here's just a partial list of the gadgets: Bat-sign projector,

  • Business

    A new study should have Coke and Pepsi terrified

    People in Berkeley, California, significantly cut back on soda after the city introduced a tax on sugary beverages. That's according to a study of low-income neighborhoods that was published in the American Journal of Public Health on Tuesday. The study found that soda consumption dropped 22% after Berkeley imposed a penny-per-ounce tax on sugar-sweetened beverages. The city's tax passed in 2014 and went into effect in May 2015. The new tax made a 20-ounce bottle of Coke 20 cents more expensive for distributors. This extra cost is passed on to consumers. Researchers tracked changes in soda consumption after the tax went into effect, comparing surveys of Berkeley residents' reported beverage consumption

    Business Insider
  • Business

    Macy's is closing 100 stores — here's where they will likely shut down

    Macy's recently revealed plans to shut down 100 stores as it battles slowing sales and growing online competition. The retailer didn't say which stores would close or how many employees would be affected, though laid-off workers will likely number in the tens of thousands. Macy's employs more than 150,000 people, and the closures represent 15% of its store base.  Many Macy's employees have been posting in online message boards asking if anyone knows which stores will close. The business analytics firm 1010data looked into it and compiled a list of cities where closures are most likely. The firm identified the most at-risk areas based on a review of consumer spending data that showed where Macy's

    Business Insider
  • Business

    Mylan CEO Blamed Obamacare for EpiPen Sticker Shock

    The price of the EpiPen has soared 500% since generic drug company Mylan bought the treatment nine years ago. On an earnings call earlier this month, Bresch blamed EpiPen sticker shock in part on Obamacare. Mylan is no stranger to controversy (see my profile last year, “Why Wall Street Loves to Hate Mylan’s CEO”).

  • News

    Good and bad news for Ryan Lochte

    Brazilian police want American swimmer Ryan Lochte charged with filing a false false robbery report. Meanwhile, Lochte picked up a new endorsement deal after losing all of his major sponsors.

    Yahoo Finance Video
  • Business

    Japan's ANA cancels Dreamliner flights over engine trouble

    Japan's All Nippon Airways said Thursday it is cancelling some Boeing Dreamliner flights owing to a problem with the plane's engine, and warned of more groundings. The carrier, the biggest worldwide Dreamliner operator with a fleet of 50 jets, said nine domestic flights scheduled for Friday would be halted so it could fix a problem with a Rolls Royce-produced engine. The move came after ANA grounded a domestic Dreamliner flight earlier Thursday, also citing an unspecified engine problems.

  • TGT

    The Target boycott is costing more than anyone expected

    A boycott against Target over its bathroom policy seems to be costing the retailer more than anyone expected. The boycott started in April after Target announced that it would welcome transgender customers to use any bathroom or fitting room that matched their gender identity. Critics said the policy opened the door for sexual predators to victimize women and children inside the retailer's bathrooms, and more than 1.4 million people signed a pledge to stop shopping at Target unless it reversed the policy.

    Business Insider
  • Lifestyle

    Why Emergency Funds Are A Bad Idea

    Along with changing your oil every 3,000 miles and checking your child’s trick-or-treat bag for weaponized apples, the common advice to create an emergency fund is overly prudent. All you need is an objective understanding of risk to realize that there are far better places to put your money than an inert account that can’t enrich you. The most recognizable personal finance mavens are almost unanimous in their advocacy of the emergency fund as a vital part of any common-sense financial plan. Their recommendations differ only on size – three months’, six months’, perhaps eight months’ worth of living expenses are enough to accommodate whatever misfortune might befall you. But to what end? And

  • Business

    Uber lost at least $1.27 billion in first half of 2016: Bloomberg

    The subsidies Uber grants its drivers was the main reason for the loss, finance head Gautam Gupta told investors in a quarterly conference call, Bloomberg said, citing sources. The company lost about $520 million in the first quarter of the year and another $750 million in the second quarter, Bloomberg said. Uber, which is now valued at roughly $69 billion, lost at least $2 billion in 2015, the report said.

  • Business

    Two of China's Biggest Banks Hold Back Bad-Debt Tide

    Aug. 26 -- Two of China’s biggest banks -- China Construction Bank Corp. and Bank of Communications Co. -- reported that their bad-loan ratios had stopped climbing after previously rising like clockwork. Bloomberg's Stephen Engle reports on "Daybreak Asia."

    Bloomberg Video
  • Politics

    Eric Trump says his father’s tax returns are ‘five feet tall’ and should not be released

    Eric Trump said Wednesday it would be “foolish” for his father to release his tax returns and subject them to scrutiny by people who don’t know what they are looking at. “You would have a bunch of people who know nothing about taxes trying to look through and trying to come up with assumptions on things they know nothing about,” Trump said on CNBC. “It would be foolish to do. I’m actually the biggest proponent of not doing it.” The Republican presidential candidate has said he can’t release his tax returns until the Internal Revenue Service completes an audit. His son reiterated that reason Wednesday, saying there is “no tax attorney in the world who will tell you to release your tax returns

  • SHLD

    Sears is running out of money — and will likely shut down stores as a result

    Sears is running out of money. The company's cash and equivalents have fallen to $276 million from $1.8 billion one year ago, Sears said Thursday. As a result, the retailer was forced to accept $300 million in financing from Sears CEO Eddie Lampert's hedge fund, ESL Investments.

    Business Insider
  • Technology

    Activist discovers iPhone spyware, sparking security update

    The suspicious text message that appeared on Ahmed Mansoor's iPhone promised to reveal details about torture in the United Arab Emirates' prisons. All Mansoor had to do was click the link. Mansoor, a human rights activist, didn't take the bait.

    Associated Press
  • KR

    Kroger is taking drastic measures to slash prices — and Walmart should be terrified

    The grocery store chain recently cut the cost of 1,000 popular items in 120 of its stores, retail consultant David Merrefield writes on industry website The Robin Report. Kroger has annual sales of $115 billion, about half of Walmart's US sales. Walmart is reacting to Kroger's success by investing more heavily in its grocery experience, the Cincinnati Business Courier reports.

    Business Insider
  • Politics

    Biden warns Europe against Russian energy reliance

    U.S. Vice President Joe Biden has cautioned Europe against a new natural gas pipeline planned to stretch from Russia to Germany, saying it "looks like a fairly bad deal" for Europe because it further increases its energy dependency on Moscow. Biden said Thursday that to lock Europe "into greater reliance on Russia at this moment ... will fundamentally destabilize Ukraine," but stressed that European Union leaders must make their own decisions on the issue.

    Associated Press
  • COST

    Furious Costco customers are still threatening to cancel memberships over credit card 'fiasco'

    When Costco began transitioning from American Express to Visa as its exclusive credit card partner in June, delays and confusion had customers threatening to cancel their memberships. Now, two months later, some Costco members say that major problems remain — and that Citi, the card issuer, and Costco aren't doing enough to fix them. In addition to making Visa the only credit card customers can use at Costco, the transition meant that 11 million of Costco's 81 million members worldwide with Costco cobranded credit cards had to switch from the TrueEarnings American Express Costco card to the Costco Anywhere Visa.

    Business Insider
  • GE

    Warren Buffett Could Lose an $8-Per-Second Windfall on His Dow Chemical Stock

    Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway Inc. continues to reap rich dividends from a canny loan extended to Dow Chemical Co. seven years ago. Shares of Dow have spent much of the past month hovering above $53—perilously close to a level that would cause Berkshire to lose a $255 million-a-year dividend. Since 2009, when Berkshire lent Dow Chemical $3 billion to help finance its purchase of Rohm & Haas, Dow has been on the hook for paying an 8.5% annual dividend on three million shares of preferred stock.

    The Wall Street Journal
  • AAPL

    Cramer: What Apple should do to make investors fall in love with it again

    It is no secret that investors no longer love Apple (AAPL) like they used to. Jim Cramer believes the tech titan should put that massive $231 billion cash hoard to work and buy Sirius XM (SIRI). Apple CEO Tim Cook made headlines recently when he estimated that Apple's service stream revenue could become as big as a Fortune 100 company next year.

  • Business

    Oil prices fall as Saudi Arabia dampens prospects of output freeze

    Oil fell on Friday and was set for its largest weekly decline in a month after the Saudi energy minister watered down expectations that the world's largest producers might agree next month to limit their output. Brent crude oil futures were down 32 cents at $49.35 per barrel by 1144 GMT, while U.S. West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude was down 22 cents at $47.11 a barrel. Members of the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries will meet on the sidelines of the International Energy Forum, which groups producers and consumers, in Algeria Sept. 26-28.

  • Business

    5 Stocks With Rising Dividends for 50 Years in a Row

    There’s no question that dividends can be a powerful part of any long-term investor’s portfolio. There are very few things that are guaranteed in the investing world, but the best dividend stocks always come through for shareholders quarter after quarter. The biggest concern for investors searching for dividend stocks is that a company will cut its dividend at the first sign of financial hardship. As impressive as is for companies to maintain its dividends through thick and thin, some companies kick dividend reliability up a notch higher. Remarkably, a handful of blue-chip dividend stocks have an impeccable track record of more than 50 consecutive years of dividend hikes. That’s right, the Vietnam
  • MYL

    Cramer on Mylan CEO: 'Whatever you can get away with'

    CNBC's Jim Cramer fired back Thursday on comments from Mylan (MYL) CEO Heather Bresch about pricing of the auto-injection device EpiPen. Mylan said it would make expansions to its already existing cost-cutting programs. Shares of Mylan rose after the announcement.

  • MYL

    Mylan says it just cut the price of EpiPens in half — but here's the fine print

    Mylan Pharmaceuticals said Thursday that it would be giving a $300 "savings card" discount to patients buying a two-pack of EpiPens, which has a retail price of around $600. The pivot came amid pressure to cut the price of the drug, which is up 500% since Mylan acquired it in 2007. Look, first and foremost we want everyone with an EpiPen to have one.

    Business Insider