A Pension Strategy That Could Backfire


Couples who qualify for an employer pension need to make a big decision before they retire. Should a retiree take a life-only annuity, which provides the highest monthly payout but ends when the pensioner dies? Or choose a joint-and-survivor benefit, which offers a lower payout but one that continues after the retiree dies for as long as the spouse is alive?

See Also: A Retirement Spending Blueprint Will Protect Your Nest Egg

If the employee due the pension is likely to die first, the joint pension is usually the best route. But some insurance agents may try to steer you to a strategy known as "pension maximization." It works like this: Take the higher life-only payout and use all or part of the extra income to buy life insurance. If you die first, your pension ends but your spouse will get a death benefit that supposedly will be enough to generate at least the same income she would have received under the joint pension. If she dies first, you cancel the insurance and continue to take the higher payout.

However, this strategy may not work out as planned. It's essential to examine the numbers closely before you sign away your rights to a joint pension. "If the goal is to have steady income for life, why jump through all these hoops?" says Rebecca Davis, legal director of the Pension Rights Center.

Mark Maurer, president of Low Load Insurance Services in Tampa, Fla., develops "pension max" strategies for clients of fee-only certified financial planners. He says that just 20% of the clients he reviews do better with pension max than with the joint-pension option.

Maurer offers an illustration of one plan he developed for a 61-year-old man and his 59-year-old wife. The husband's pension offered a choice of a monthly $4,356 life-only payout or a 100% joint benefit, which would pay $3,557 as long as one of the spouses lived.

Under pension max, the worker chooses the life-only benefit with its extra $799 a month. He uses $660 a month to pay premiums on three life insurance policies--a 10-year $200,000 term policy, a 20-year $200,000 term policy and a $370,000 universal life policy. He qualifies for low rates because he is healthy. "This won't work unless the client is a better-than-average healthy non-smoker," Maurer says.

Protecting the Surviving Spouse

A big issue for pension max plans: If the husband dies, will the death benefit be big enough? "You really want to see if the wife would be able to use the death benefit to buy a guaranteed fixed annuity that is greater than what she would get with the joint pension," says Steve Vernon, president of Rest-of-Life Communications, a consulting firm in Oxnard, Cal. He says he's "skeptical" that these plans work in the survivor's favor.

In Maurer's example, if the husband dies after 22 years, the 81-year-old wife could use the tax-free $370,000 death benefit to buy a fixed-payout annuity. At today's rates, the annuity would pay out $3,388 a month, according to ImmediateAnnuities.com. That's lower than the joint pension's $3,557.

But Maurer notes that with the pension, payments would be fully taxable and, at the 15% rate, would leave the widow with just $3,023 of after-tax spending money. With the annuity, most of each payout would be tax-free return of investment so, according to Maurer, the widow would have more spendable cash.

However, Vernon says that pension max plans are often based on assumptions that may not pan out. He has seen plans that provide just a 20-year term life insurance policy on the worker's life. If the husband lives longer, "he will have to buy term life insurance in his eighties, and that will be phenomenally expensive," he says. Some strategies use insurance with death benefits that grow based on market assumptions. If the market grows at a lower rate, the death benefit could be too low to cover the survivor's expenses.

Also, pension max plans often don't account for taxes. In Maurer's example, the couple must pay tax on the $4,356 payout, squeezing the after-tax cash on hand to cover the insurance premiums.

View Comments (1)

Recommended for You

  • Driver follows GPS off disused bridge, and wife dies, police say

    Technically Incorrect: Sheriffs in Indiana say that a man was following his GPS too slavishly and drove his car onto a ramp leading to a demolished bridge.

  • Hamilton ready to sign on the dotted line

    Formula One world champion Lewis Hamilton is ready to sign a new contract that, according to media reports, could net him more than $40 million a year. There's no reason why it shouldn't be," the Mercedes driver told British reporters after finishing second in Sunday's Malaysian Grand Prix.

  • NYC blast probe highlights problem of stealing gas

    NEW YORK (AP) — It was a run-of-the-mill complaint — a smell of gas — with a troubling explanation: Someone had improperly tapped into a Manhattan building's gas line, and it was leaking.

    Associated Press
  • Putin Barely Beats Obama as a More Imminent Threat to Americans in New Poll

    The Reuters/Ipsos poll that asked some 3,000 Americans what they consider to be the most imminent threat facing the country. Russian President Vladimir Putin, unsurprisingly, was ranked as an imminent threat by about 20 percent of Americans.

    The Fiscal Times
  • Rare Earths Problem Could Have A Nuclear Solution

    The rare earths market has been dominated by China in recent years, but the reemergence of molten salt reactors in the nuclear sector could bring that to an end

  • Texas Towns Under Pressure From Low Oil Prices

    In Texas, the heart of the U.S. shale boom, low oil prices have hammered several local economies while others have managed to diversify away from oil and are thriving

  • Play

    Let's make a deal ... with Iran

    Details on the approaching deadline for negotiating a nuclear deal with Iran. CNBC's Eamon Javers and Jim Walsh, MIT senior research associate, discuss.

    CNBC Videos
  • Four Great Companies That Should Boost Their Dividends Soon

    These companies from four different sectors have long track records of raising payouts.

  • Tiny Slice Of Americans Saves More Than 15 Percent Of Income

    “Middle-class Americans (have) to do the saving, because nobody is going to do it for them,” says Greg McBride, CFA, Bankrate’s chief financial analyst. “Between emergency savings and the ever-increasing burden of retirement savings that is on the individual, the goal should be 15 percent of your…

    Money Talks News
  • 5 Secrets You Didn't Know About Roth IRAs

    Between its generous tax benefits at retirement and no required minimum distributions, a Roth IRA is well worth considering if you're eligible to have one.

  • Play

    Retail impact on Q1

    Businesses are still feeling the impact of the shutdown at west coast ports. CNBC's Courtney Reagan tracks what it means for retailers and which names are bracing for a bigger hit to their bottom line.

    CNBC Videos
  • Ackman says shutting Herbalife down is key to him

    Hedge fund mogul William Ackman, who has spent more than two years accusing Herbalife Ltd of running a pyramid scheme, said on Monday that shutting down the company is the most important thing he can do. Speaking at a meeting of the Council of Institutional Investors' in Washington, Ackman said…

  • Play

    Outrageous Public Pensions Could Bankrupt These States

    Some of the worst public-sector pension problems in America are playing out in states and cities where legislation or local court rulings have granted extraordinary protections to workers’ retirement benefits—far beyond those enjoyed by private-sector employees. Illinois officials, for instance,…

    The Fiscal Times
  • Foreign Investors Are Cashing Out of China

    Foreigners sold a net 1.7 billion yuan ($274 million) of Chinese shares via the Shanghai-Hong Kong exchange link in the week through Monday, while the two biggest Hong Kong exchange-traded funds tracking mainland stocks had withdrawals of $622 million. Global investors are losing faith in the rally…

  • China, Japan, S.Korea halt Thai air route expansion on safety concerns

    By Khettiya Jittapong and Manunphattr Dhanananphorn BANGKOK (Reuters) - China has joined South Korea and Japan in stopping Thailand-based airlines from flying charters and new routes because of safety concerns highlighted by an international audit, Thai officials said on Monday. The move will come…

  • Ex-CFO who slammed Chick-fil-A now on foodstamps

    Man who slammed restaurant chain in video that went viral has been out of work ever since.

  • SEC files fraud charges against Lynn Tilton, firms

    WASHINGTON (AP) — Federal regulators filed civil fraud charges against prominent Wall Street executive Lynn Tilton and her investment firms, who are accused of concealing the poor performance of fund assets linked to loans to distressed companies.

    Associated Press
  • Is Chesapeake Energy a Bargain Worth Buying?

    Any time I go shopping with my wife she's almost immediately drawn to the rack that has a big 50% off sign above it. She, like most of us, loves a good bargain. If the stock market had such a rack that's ...