Puerto Rico teeters on fiscal edge over pensions

Puerto Rico's pension system in peril; thousands of workers fear loss of benefits

Associated Press
Puerto Rico teeters on fiscal edge over pensions

View photo

A retiree carries a sign that reads in Spanish “Do not play with my pension” during a protest outside the government pension headquarters in San Juan, Puerto Rico, Wednesday, Jan. 30, 2013. Puerto Rico is confronting what economists and financial analysts say is a ticking fiscal time bomb: A public pension system with a $37.3 billion unfunded liability that must be addressed soon, at a time when the U.S. island territory's government has little money to spare, or thousands of retirees could start to see benefit cuts. (AP Photo/Ricardo Arduengo)

SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico (AP) -- Office clerk Lillian Marti hopes to retire one day with a decent pension. Now, like many other employees of Puerto Rico's government, she's beginning to fear she might not get that chance.

"Of course, I'm worried," said the 61-year-old, who has worked for the government for 20 years.

Some experts are calling for cutting benefits to help Puerto Rico confront what economists and financial analysts say is a ticking fiscal time bomb: A public pension system with a $37.3 billion unfunded liability that must be addressed soon, at a time when the U.S. island territory's government has little money to spare.

The unfunded liability, which is spread across three public pension systems, is almost four times the annual government budget for the island of nearly 4 million people. Only a few much larger U.S. states, such as California and Illinois, face bigger unfunded liabilities.

Puerto Rico's problem stems from decades of neglect as politicians facing budget deficits were unwilling to set aside money for the growing ranks of retired police, firefighters, teachers and office workers. Now many analysts and even some government officials concede it is the most critical issue facing the administration of newly elected Gov. Alejandro Garcia Padilla.

"This is the most important financial issue right now," said Gustavo Velez, a prominent Puerto Rican economist. "They have to find a solution. They have to create a plan in the next three months."

Velez and others suggest that Puerto Rico should immediately reduce benefits, raise the retirement age and demand increased contributions from current employees, ideas that don't sit well with people like Marti.

"Imagine, I'm going to be left without a big chunk of money that I contributed," she said.

Garcia, who defeated the incumbent with support of the public employee unions, has formed a committee to come up with suggestions. He has not yet said how he will address the situation. Simply taking the money from the island's general fund is out of the question: Puerto Rico has a projected deficit this year of $1.2 billion.

"It's a very complex situation," Garcia said at a recent news conference. "We will respect the pensions of those who contributed and built this country."

The island only recently emerged from a six-year recession and the unemployment rate is 14 percent, higher than any state. Manufacturing, the largest segment of the economy, has been in decline for years. Former Gov. Luis Fortuno laid off more than 20,000 government workers. His predecessor, Anibal Acevedo Vila, was forced to partially shut down the government for two weeks in May 2006 in a standoff over budget talks with the legislature.

In the meantime, the pension system's deficit kept growing.

"It's not that we're bad off. We're broke," said Miguel Morales, a consultant to a permanent committee charged with regulating the pension system. "The concern is that there will come a day when the government cannot respond and everyone will be left out on the street."

Nearly all of the problem centers on two pension systems — one for teachers and one for other government workers — that stopped accepting new beneficiaries in January 2000. They serve more than 273,000 active and retired government workers.

Those initially allowed workers to retire at age 55 with 25 years of service or at age 58 with 10 years of service. In 1990, legislators made significant changes, reducing benefits and increasing the retirement age from 55 to 65 years for newly hired workers.

As liabilities mounted, legislators scrapped that system 13 years ago, creating a new system that is more like a 401(k)-type plan in which workers must make their own contributions.

The newer defined-contribution plan is considered financially stable. But the older plan will have used up its assets "within several years," said Karen Krop, a senior director of public finance at Fitch Ratings.

If the system does collapse, the island's general fund is supposed to honor those collections. "But the general fund doesn't have that money," Velez said.

Nearly three years ago, former Gov. Fortuno established a committee charged with solving the pension fund's problems, noting that the overall system was paying $679 million more a year than what it received in contributions.

"Absent any corrective measures, the systems could be left without funds in or before 10 years," he stated in a March 2010 executive order.

That study led lawmakers to increase employee contributions to the system and they transferred $162 million into the retirement system so that officials could buy a capital bond expected to generate $1.5 billion in 40 years. But it wasn't enough to solve the problem.

Puerto Rico's public pension problems also have damaged the island's bond ratings, which remain significantly lower than any U.S. state, raising the island's cost of borrowing.

In December, Moody's lowered Puerto Rico's credit rating, stating in part that it doesn't have a clear idea as to how and when the government will solve the retirement systems' problems. It warned of an additional credit rating downgrade if no reforms are undertaken.

Complicating the territory's financial situation is its $69 billion public debt.

"Puerto Rico debt levels are well, well in excess of what we see in other states," Krop of Fitch Ratings said.

Most states have an average 3 percent of tax-supported debt as a percentage of personal income. Nine percent is considered high. Puerto Rico is at 80 percent, Krop said. The per capita debt is more than $12,000 per person, excluding pension, she added.

Given those numbers, Marti said she doesn't believe she'll have enough money to retire. She went back to work in part to collect more Social Security, but even then, she said the federal fiscal situation doesn't give her much hope.

"Things are not easy," she said. "You don't know what's going to happen with Social Security either."


View Comments (33)

Recommended for You

  • Financial reforms will make the next crisis even messier

    There is a time-honoured way of protecting taxpayers from picking up the bill for the failure of a systemically important financial institution. It involves central banks and finance ministries pressing ...

    Financial Times
  • Elantra Takes On The Competition

    See how Elantra's features measure up to their competitors. Explore all the features and benefits at the Hyundai Official Site.

  • Pot shops shunned by banks haul in the cash

    Conflicting laws, hazy regulatory guidance leaves legal pot shops flush with money.

  • Wealthy Chinese offer rich pickings

    BNY Mellon's impending exit from its Chinese asset management joint venture after seven years marks another Sino-western marriage failure within the financial services sector. At a deeper level, it may ...

    Financial Times
  • Play

    Will Asia’s Currency Rally Continue?

    Global investors keep flooding into Asia and pushing the region’s currencies higher. WSJ’s Jake Lee speaks to Sacha Tihanyi, Senior Currency Strategist at Scotiabank.

    WSJ Live
  • Japan firm showcases 'touchable' 3D technology

    Technology that generates touchable 3D imagery was unveiled in Japan Monday, with its developers saying users could pull and push objects that are not really there. "Touching is an important part of human communication but virtual reality has until now been lacking it," its chief executive Natsuo…

  • This Number Could Help Predict Your Happiness Later In Life

    According to one financial expert, how happy...

    Business Insider
  • Samsung pushes ahead with group-wide restructuring

    Samsung Group is to merge its shipbuilding and engineering units in its latest restructuring as the South Korean conglomerate prepares to transfer power to the next generation of its founding family. Group-wide ...

    Financial Times
  • Four Things That Can Send Your Resume to the Trash

    We asked recruiting managers and career experts about resume errors that cause them to crumple and toss a resume - their answers may surprise you.

  • Indian start-up launches shoes that show you the way

    The shoes come with a detachable Bluetooth transceiver that links to a smartphone app to direct the wearer using Google maps, sending a vibrating signal to indicate a left or right turn. They are the brainchild of 30-year-old Krispian Lawrence and Anirudh Sharma, 28, two engineering graduates who…

  • Belka Nudges Banks to Phase Out FX Loans Before Politics

    Poland ’s central bank Governor Marek Belka is “nudging” banks to phase out Swiss franc mortgages before lawmakers decide to force a swap that may cause losses. Foreign currency loans could tempt populist politicians to take a cue from Hungary’s Prime Minister Viktor Orban, who imposed billions of…

  • Gold Drops From 1-Week High as Global Data Assessed With Ukraine

    Gold extended a retreat from a one-week high, dropping for a third day, as investors weighed the health of the global economy against tension between Ukraine and Russia . Bullion for immediate delivery lost as much as 0.2 percent to $1,282.96 an ounce and was at $1,283.66 at 9:50 a.m. in Singapore,…

  • Dollar Near One-Year High Against Euro on U.S. Economy, Ukraine

    The dollar reached the highest level in almost a year against the euro as signs of U.S. A manufacturing index today may add to the case for the European Central Bank to expand stimulus. Australia's dollar remained lower as a report showed manufacturing slowed in China, its biggest trading partner.…

  • Sony wooing Japanese to PS4 with Dragon Quest

    TOKYO (AP) — Sony is trying to woo Japanese game fans to the PlayStation 4 home console that went on sale in November in the U.S. and Europe, but didn't arrive at stores here until February.

    Associated Press
  • Ruble Hits New Record Low Against Dollar as Ukraine Fighting Continues

    The Russian ruble hit a fresh record low against the dollar, burdened by continued fighting in Ukraine over the weekend.

    The Wall Street Journal
  • American Express Cards

    Earn Cash Back, Travel, or Points. Find the Card That's Right For You!

    AdChoicesAmerican ExpressSponsored
  • Twenty years on, Schaeuble pleads again for core Europe

    German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble renewed a call for a core group of European Union countries to move ahead faster with economic and political integration, 20 years after his ground-breaking proposal fell on deaf ears in key partner France. In an article published in the Financial Times on…

  • Play

    Don't Forget the Funds That Didn't Make It

    As liquidated or merged funds fall off the record, fund category returns and fund company literature don't tell the whole story.

  • Russia breaks ground on new gas pipeline to China

    Russia launched construction Monday of a 770 billion ruble ($20.8 bn) gas pipeline that will help bring gas from the far east of the country to China.

  • How to build credit if you have a small income

    Building, maintaining a good credit score is one of the best moves you can make for your financial health.

  • Board director has no right to conceal condo's mold problem

    Question: Does a board director of Homeowner Association "One" have the right to tell a condo owner in a completely different Homeowner Association "Two" not to let a neighbor into ...

    Los Angeles Times
  • Dubai Mall developer Emaar to list on stock market

    DUBAI, United Arab Emirates (AP) — Emaar Properties, the developer behind one of the world's largest shopping malls and the world's tallest tower, said Sunday it will launch an initial public offering for part of its retail business in Dubai next month.

    Associated Press
  • Summer means sizzling savings at Sears.com

    Save big on appliances, apparel, lawn and garden, tools and more. For fun in the sun or a project in the shade, start your search at Sears.

  • Tantrums, concubines, hotpot burns and smog: China insurers have it covered

    Similarly, buy cover against your bride becoming pregnant before the honeymoon, your team being knocked out of the soccer World Cup, burning your tongue eating hotpot or if smog ruins your holiday. Quirky, maybe, but China's insurers are turning to ever more creative ways to drum up business in a…