Mon, May 28, 2012, 8:07 PM EDT - U.S. Markets closed for Memorial Day

Social Media: Virtue or Vice? Pinterest Tops the 2012 Lenten Index

By contributors@theatlantic.com (Megan Garber) | The Atlantic – Thu, Feb 23, 2012 1:05 PM EST

facebook_fade615 copy.jpg

Lent is upon us. For the next 39 days, Christians (and non-Christians who find appeal in the idea of strategic self-denial) will give up something they love -- or at least something they tend to over-indulge in -- in the name of personal and social improvement. 

Traditional sacrifices include: meat, sugar, coffee, booze, TV-watching, snacking, gossiping, lying, procrastinating, and complaining. And while, recently, Lenten forfeitures have come to include additions to, rather than subtractions from, people's daily routines -- "I'll exercise more," "I'll eat more vegetables," "I'll make a point of paying someone a compliment every day" -- for the most part, the sacrifices made during the 40 days before Easter rely on the classic dialectic between addiction and destruction. You give something up both because you love it ... and because you know it's bad for you.

So it's interesting that the list of Lenten sacrifices has recently expanded to include another category: social media. People, taking the facebook_fade615 copy.jpg

Lent is upon us. For the next 39 days, Christians (and non-Christians who find appeal in the idea of strategic self-denial) will give up something they love -- or at least something they tend to over-indulge in -- in the name of personal and social improvement. 

Traditional sacrifices include: meat, sugar, coffee, booze, TV-watching, snacking, gossiping, lying, procrastinating, and complaining. And while, recently, Lenten forfeitures have come to include additions to, rather than subtractions from, people's daily routines -- "I'll exercise more," "I'll eat more vegetables," "I'll make a point of paying someone a compliment every day" -- for the most part, the sacrifices made during the 40 days before Easter rely on the classic dialectic between addiction and destruction. You give something up both because you love it ... and because you know it's bad for you.

So it's interesting that the list of Lenten sacrifices has recently expanded to include another category: social media. People are giving up Facebook. They're giving up Twitter. They're giving up -- sort of -- Pinterest. And if the love it/leave it dichotomy holds true, their self-imposed abstinence from those platforms indicates not only sacrifice, but also the general sense that the services being sacrificed are, on some level, destructive. Their popularity as sacrifices suggests, actually, the negative feelings people have about social media services. Lenten abstinence, in other words, can offer an unscientific-but-still-revealing insight into how people are feeling about social media. A Big Mac Index for our feelings about Facebook.

So how did the services stack up? I did a search of tweets posted over the past day; and, within that day, there have been tons of references to giving up Facebook.

There are fewer, but still substantial, references to giving up Twitter.

Foursquare got a few sacrificial shout-outs, as well.

And so did Tumblr.

But! Take a look at the results for Pinterest. Some people are, indeed, giving up the service:

On Twitter, though, the general consensus seems to be that Pinterest is too valuable to give up, even for six weeks:

Yep: That would be crazy.

Image: Shutterstock/Pan Xunbin.

">digital sabbath concept to a days-long level, are giving up Facebook. They're giving up Twitter and Tumblr and Foursquare. And if the love it/leave it dichotomy holds true, their self-imposed abstinence from those platforms indicates not only sacrifice, but also the general sense that the services being sacrificed are, on some level, destructive. Their popularity as sacrifices suggests, actually, the negative feelings people have about social media services. 

Lenten abstinence, in other words, can offer an unscientific-but-still-revealing insight into how people are feeling about social media. A Big Mac Index for our feelings about Facebook.

So how did the services stack up? I did a search of tweets posted over the past day; and, within that day, there have been tons of references to giving up Facebook.

There are fewer, but still substantial, references to giving up Twitter.

Foursquare got a few sacrificial shout-outs, as well.

And so did Tumblr.

But! Take a look at the results for Pinterest. Some people are, indeed, giving up the service:

But the general consensus seems to be that Pinterest is too valuable to give up, even for six weeks:

So people can spend 40 days deprived of TV and dessert and (yes, even!) coffee, and of Tumblrs and tweets and Facebook's photos and messages. Pins, on the other hand? That's a sacrifice most aren't willing -- or able -- to make. 


Image: Shutterstock/Pan Xunbin.



More From The Atlantic
 

There are no comments yet

 
Symbol Price Change % Chg 
Your most recently viewed tickers will automatically show up here if you type a ticker in the "Enter symbol/company" at the bottom of this module.
You need to enable your browser cookies to view your most recent quotes.
Save List to Portfolio »
 
Sign-in to view quotes in your portfolios.

Trading Center

Yahoo! Finance on Facebook

  YAHOO! FINANCE ON TWITTER