Stephen Hawking Calls for Alan Turing's Pardon

Rebecca J. Rosen

The popular physicist has joined with other scientists and British leaders to ask Prime Minister David Cameron to "formally forgive this British hero."


Steve Parker/Flickr

At the end of World War II, mathematician and early computer scientist Alan Turing was a hero. He had led the British in breaking the Engima code, an effort that was hailed for bringing the war to a close.

But not long after the war, in 1952, he was arrested for what was then a crime in England: his sexuality, or, in legalese, "acts of gross indecency between adult men." He had a choice: imprisonment or estrogen. He chose the hormone treatment, which made him impotent and caused him to grow breasts. Two years later, he died in what is widely believed to have been a suicide.

In more recent times, England has sought ways to repent for what it did to Alan Turing. In 2009 Prime Minister Gordon Brown issued a formal apology. But official forgiveness remains in the offing: Earlier this year, members of parliament introduced legislation to pardon Turing. Now, several of the nation's top scientists, including Stephen Hawking, and other leaders have written a letter to the Telegraph, throwing their support behind the bill.

They write:

SIR - We write in support of a posthumous pardon for Alan Turing, one of the most brilliant mathematicians of the modern era. He lead the team of Enigma codebreakers at Bletchley Park, which most historians agree shortened the Second World War. Yet successive governments seem incapable of forgiving his conviction for the then crime of being a homosexual, which led to his suicide, aged 41.

We urge the Prime Minister formally to forgive this British hero, to whom we owe so much as a nation, and whose pioneering contribution to computer sciences remains relevant even today. To those who seek to block attempts to secure a pardon with the argument that this would set a precedent, we would answer that Turing's achievements are sui generis. It is time his reputation was unblemished.

Lord Currie of Marylebone
Lord Grade of Yarmouth
Lord Faulkner or Worcester
Lord Rees of Ludlow

Astronomer Royal
Lord Sharkey
Lord Smith of Finsbury
Baroness Trumpington

Sir Timothy Gowers
Rouse Ball Professor of Mathematics, Cambridge University
Dr Douglas Gurr
Chairman, Science Museum Group
Professor Stephen Hawking
Sir Paul Nurse
President, the Royal Society

Various arguments of, not surprisingly, varying strengths have been made against the pardon. The justice minister, for example, has argued that pardons are not meant for people who were properly convicted of what was then a crime, no matter if we today look back on those laws with opprobrium. To pardon Turing would, in a sense, take England off the hook for its shameful history. Others, such as gay-rights activist Peter Tatchell, have questioned the wisdom of singling out Turing, when perhaps as many as 100,000 men were convicted under that same statute.

But these arguments lose sight of the point of the pardon. What good is it to pardon a man who has been dead nearly six decades? It is not for his benefit, and it does not undo the past, somehow redeeming England through its words. No, its value is merely symbolic, a statement that England recognizes the error of its ways and champions its progress since. As for the other 100,000 convicted men, heck, pardon them all -- and let Turing be once again the man who has led the way to victory.

More From The Atlantic

  • 8 Things You Should Never Keep in Your Wallet

    8 Things You Should Never Keep in Your Wallet

    That overstuffed wallet of yours can’t be comfortable to sit on. It’s probably even too clunky to lug around in a purse, too. And with every new bank slip that bulges from the seams, your personal information is getting less and less safe. With just your name and Social Security number, identity thieves can open new credit accounts and make costly purchases in your name. If they can get their hands on (and doctor) a government-issued photo ID of yours, they can do even more damage, such as opening new bank accounts. These days, con artists are even profiting from tax-return fraud and health-care fraud, all with stolen IDs. We talked with consumer-protection advocates to identify the eight things

  • Lifestyle
    ABC News

    Before You Hire a Contractor, Learn From Couple's Basement Woes

    THE ABC NEWS FIXER — Oct 22, 2016, 8:37 AM ET Read Jerry’s original letter to the ABC News Fixer below, and see how The Fixer helped get their money back. Also, check out The Fixer’s tips for the next time you need to hire a contractor for work on your home. Dear ABC New Fixer: We hired a contractor to design and build a bar for our basement. He took our $4,000 deposit and never provided the design and gave us the runaround for months. We've asked for our money back multiple times, but every time, he says he doesn’t have it or it's “a cash flow issue." Interestingly, he has his own reality show on the Discovery Channel about building high-quality bars. He also opened a tavern next to his workshop.

  • Hasta la vista Microsoft: Why IBM's switch from Windows to Macs is one of its greatest decisions
    International Business Times UK

    Hasta la vista Microsoft: Why IBM's switch from Windows to Macs is one of its greatest decisions

    IBM says that it has saved millions of dollars by getting employees to use Apple Macs rather than Windows PCs, as Windows machines apparently cost three times more in support than Macs. Fletcher Previn, IBM's vice president of workplace as a service, is essentially the head of the conglomerate's IT department, and after years of experience in managing Windows PCs for large corporations, he decided things needed to change. In October 2015, Previn told the Jamf 2015 conference audience that 30,000 IBM employees were now using Macs, and when it came to support for employee computers, while 40% of all Windows users required someone to be sent out to fix the problem in person, which costs a lot more than a support call, in comparison, the same level of assistance was only required by 5% of Mac users. IBM's employees and contractors in North and South America, Europe, China, India, Asia Pacific, Middle East and Africa are using about 604,000 laptops, consisting of 442,000 Windows PCs, 90,000 Macs and 72,000 Linux PCs, and each of the operating systems have separate customer support and firmware needed.

  • Millennials told JPMorgan they want to retire by 60, but they're in for a rude awakening
    Business Insider

    Millennials told JPMorgan they want to retire by 60, but they're in for a rude awakening

    Millennials are way too bullish on their financial future. On Tuesday, JPMorgan Chase released a study about the savings trends of millennials as opposed to baby boomers. Among other details, the survey found that millennials started saving for retirement at 23, and that 82% of millennials are comfortable about talking about money.

  • New NYC law, San Francisco lawsuit highlight global risks for Airbnb

    New NYC law, San Francisco lawsuit highlight global risks for Airbnb

    Airbnb is also engaged in a pitched battle in its home of San Francisco, where the company has also sued to block a new requirement that it reject booking fees from property owners who have not registered with the city. The New York and San Francisco legal fights are a crucial test of Airbnb’s business model. Other cities looking to rein in Airbnb are watching the San Francisco proceedings and looking to the city's law as a potential model, said James Emery, deputy city attorney of San Francisco.

  • News
    Yahoo Finance Video

    There's a big problem with Clinton's plan to raise taxes on corporations

    When it comes to their economic plans—and particularly their tax plans—the differences between Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton are stark.

  • Elections shaping up to be a lose-lose for the stock market, expert says

    Elections shaping up to be a lose-lose for the stock market, expert says

    He's also concerned about the earnings picture right now, noting that top line revenues are starting to "scare" him. He pointed to General Electric's result as a case in point. On Friday, it trimmed its full-year revenue forecast from 2 percent to 4 percent to flat to 2 percent growth. "These top line revenues have to increase. We have to see better numbers come out of corporate America or we are too expensive from a valuation standpoint," Bouroudjian said. Rene Nourse, managing director at Urban Wealth Management, said she feels comfortable getting back into the market now that she thinks it is signaling a likely outcome in the election. She told "Closing Bell" she particularly likes financials,

  • The No. 1 Rule of Balance Transfer Credit Cards

    The No. 1 Rule of Balance Transfer Credit Cards

    In order to pay off credit card debt, some people turn to a balance transfer credit card. While it may seem like a strange idea to move your credit card debt from one credit card to another, doing so can be a good option. As we mentioned, balance transfer credit cards typically come with a promotional APR period, during which you won't accrue more interest charges each month.

  • Salesforce boss: CEOs are afraid to know how much their female employees make
    Yahoo Finance

    Salesforce boss: CEOs are afraid to know how much their female employees make

    Salesforce CEO Marc Benioff discussed diversity in the workplace on Friday at The Grace Hopper Celebration of Women in Computing, held this year in Houston, Tex. When it comes to the sensitive topic of diversity in tech, Salesforce (CRM) CEO Marc Benioff has some choice words for his counterparts at other companies: Don’t be afraid. At the Grace Hopper Celebration for Women in Computing, an annual conference held this year in Houston, Texas, the 52-year-old chief executive contended one of the largest reasons the gender pay gap remains at many businesses is that their CEOs are in fact too afraid to “push the button” and discover what women employees make compared to their male colleagues.

  • Obama Is Making Two Huge Mistakes in the War on ISIS in Mosul
    The Fiscal Times

    Obama Is Making Two Huge Mistakes in the War on ISIS in Mosul

    The long-anticipated battle to retake Mosul, Iraq’s second-largest city, is the biggest test to date for President Obama’s strategy against ISIS and other terrorist groups active in the Middle East. Paradoxically, the forces assembled against the Islamic State may succeed only to hand Obama another Mideast failure. Related: The Battle for Mosul: Has the US Backed an Incompetent Commander in Iraq?

  • Business
    Money Talks News

    9 Tips to Ensure You’ll Have Enough to Retire

    Life expectancy for women and men in 1970 was just short of 71 years, for example, so retirement funds did not have to see most people to age 90 or 100. Today, those of us approaching retirement are playing a very new game. Will Social Security be your primary source of income in retirement?

  • Elizabeth Warren takes on Wells Fargo's new management in scathing letter to bank
    San Francisco Business Times

    Elizabeth Warren takes on Wells Fargo's new management in scathing letter to bank

    The resignation of former CEO John Stumpf from Wells Fargo is "not enough" to assuage lawmakers that the company has purged itself of a culture that encouraged aggressive sales tactics and illegal activity, two senators said Wednesday. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) and Robert Menendez (D-N.J.) issued a letter Thursday to Stephen Sanger, who is the new chairman of Wells Fargo’s board of directors. “Given the scope of wrongdoing on his watch, Mr. Stumpf’s resignation is entirely appropriate,” the senators wrote in the letter. “But a resignation alone is not enough to assure proper accountability at Wells Fargo,” it said. “Instead, it raises additional questions.” They also questioned if the bank's

  • Cramer: Microsoft is 'on fire' thanks to CEO Satya Nadella

    Cramer: Microsoft is 'on fire' thanks to CEO Satya Nadella

    CNBC's Jim Cramer praised Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella Friday after the company hit an all-time high following an earnings beat on Thursday afternoon. "This is one where they are on fire," Cramer said on " Squawk on the Street " of the company. "It's really incredible how quickly [Nadella] turned this company around.

  • Is Gold's Real Value $2,000 an ounce?
    The Street

    Is Gold's Real Value $2,000 an ounce?

    KITCO NEWS - Gold steadies and is set to end the week higher, on track for its first weekly gain in four weeks and one expert sees the cards stacked in the metal's favor. Ken Hoffman of Bloomberg Intelligence released a report this month, which shows the current pressure in gold prices is namely driven by the looming rate hike - but those Fed concerns are just masking long-term positives for the metal. Gold was on track Friday to post its first positive weekly close in three weeks, many analysts suspect that the correction --which started with a 5% drop at the start of the month -- has run its course. December gold futures settled the day at $1,267.70 an ounce, up nearly 1.2% since Monday's open.

  • Business

    Understanding 401(k)s and All Their Benefits

    While you’ve undoubtedly heard of these wildly popular employer-sponsored retirement plans, fully understanding 401(k)s is another story. More than 50 million workers are active participants in their employers’ 401(k) plans today, with over half a million different company plans in place. Representing 18% of all retirement assets held in the nation, 401(k) plans in the U.S. hold a total of $4.5 trillion in assets. So why are these retirement plans all the rage with American employees? Keep reading to learn more about 401(k)s and the valuable advantages these plans provide. Understanding 401(k)s Named after a section of the Internal Revenue Code, 401(k)s are defined contribution plans sponsored

  • News
    WSJ Live

    Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte Makes His Mark

    Tough-talking populist Rodrigo Duterte has wasted no time in making his mark since being elected president of the Philippines in May. But souring relations with the U.S. are threatening to upend an alliance central to America's interests in Asia. Video: Warangkana Chomchuen/WSJ, Photo: Erik De Castro/REUTERS

  • Major California river adding key ingredient: water
    Associated Press

    Major California river adding key ingredient: water

    A decade ago, environmentalists and the federal government agreed to revive a 150-mile stretch of California's second-longest river, an ambitious effort aimed at allowing salmon again to swim up to the Sierra Nevada foothills to spawn. A major milestone is expected by the end of the month, when the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation says the stretch of the San Joaquin River will be flowing year-round for the first time in more than 60 years. "I think we all had hoped we'd be further along," said Doug Obegi, an attorney with the Natural Resources Defense Council, which led the lawsuit that produced the deal with the government to bring back salmon.

  • News

    AT&T to buy Time Warner for $85 billion, create telecom-media giant

    AT&T Inc said on Saturday it agreed to buy Time Warner Inc for $85.4 billion (70 billion pounds), the boldest move yet by a telecommunications company to acquire content to stream over its high-speed network to attract a growing number of online viewers. The biggest deal in the world this year will, if approved by regulators, give AT&T control of cable TV channels HBO and CNN, film studio Warner Bros and other coveted media assets. The tie-up will likely face intense scrutiny by U.S. antitrust enforcers worried that AT&T might try to limit distribution of Time Warner material.

  • World

    Cameroon train derails; at least 55 dead, hundreds injured

    By Sylvain Andzongo ESEKA, Cameroon (Reuters) - Fourteen people remained trapped on Friday under the wreckage of a packed passenger train that derailed en route between Cameroon's two largest cities, killing at least 55 and injuring 575, the government said in a communique read on state television. The Camrail inter-city train was travelling from the capital, Yaounde, to the port city of Douala when the accident occurred around 11 a.m. local time (1000 GMT) near the train station in the town of Eseka, around 120 km (75 miles) west of the capital. Before its departure from Yaounde, he said that a railway employee said additional wagons had been added to the train to accommodate extra passengers, though it was unclear if that played a role in the accident.

  • U.S. mall investors set to lose billions as retail gloom deepens

    U.S. mall investors set to lose billions as retail gloom deepens

    NEW YORK (Reuters/IFR) - The dramatic shift to online shopping that has crushed U.S. department stores in recent years now threatens the investors who a decade ago funded the vast expanse of brick and mortar emporiums that many Americans no longer visit. Some $128 billion of commercial real estate loans - more than one-quarter of which went to finance malls a decade ago - are due to refinance between now and the end of 2017, according to Morningstar Credit Ratings. Wells Fargo estimates that about $38 billion of these loans were taken out by retailers, bundled into commercial mortgage-backed securities (CMBS) and sold to institutional investors.

  • Bombardier to cut 7,500 more jobs through 2018, mostly in rail

    Bombardier to cut 7,500 more jobs through 2018, mostly in rail

    Bombardier Inc said on Friday it would cut 7,500 jobs, mostly in its train-making division, in a second round of layoffs announced this year, following extended delays and budget overruns in its aerospace business. About two-thirds of the jobs are in Bombardier Transportation, the Germany-based rail unit which had already been slated to eliminate about 3,500 workers. Bombardier, which ended 2015 with 70,900 employees, said in February it would cut 10 percent of its workforce over two years, with nearly half of those jobs in the rail unit.

  • 5 Simple Mistakes That Could Ruin Your Retirement

    5 Simple Mistakes That Could Ruin Your Retirement

    You can make a lot of mistakes in your youth … and assuming none of them get you killed or put in prison, you can generally recover from them. Time is on your side. But the closer you get to retirement, the less room for error you have. You can make a lot of mistakes in your youth … and assuming none of them get you killed or put in prison, you can generally recover from them. Time is on your side. But the closer you get to retirement, the less room for error you have. As your nest egg gets larger, investing mistakes cost you a lot more. Think about it. If you lose 30% on a $10,000 portfolio, you’re out $3,000. That might be a single after-tax paycheck when you’re young. But imagine losing 30%

  • Business

    China to allow coal output hike to meet winter demand - state planner

    China will allow coal mines in areas with short supply to increase their production to help cope with an expected increase in demand for heating and power during winter and spring, the state planner said. Coal mines that are currently under construction will also be encouraged to complete construction and begin production of coal, the National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC) said on its website on Saturday, citing a meeting held on Friday to discuss energy supply and demand during the colder seasons. China's electric power utilities are scrambling to get coal from anywhere they can, but are coming up short as efforts to boost supply take time to come into effect.

  • Business

    Indian Card Breach Seen Hindering Modi’s Quest to Go Cashless

    India’s quest to become a cashless economy has been dealt a blow by a data breach that compromised as many as 3.2 million debit cards. Prime Minister Narendra Modi urged Indians in a radio address in May to use cashless payments to discourage corruption and keep track of money. Convincing them may get harder after India’s national card payments network said that the data violation led to fraudulent transactions, mainly in China and the U.S.

  • Technology
    Associated Press

    Counterterrorism prosecutors seek access to encrypted data

    Prosecutors from France, Belgium, Spain and Morocco called Friday for the ability to unlock phones and computers and to gain access to encrypted communications to aid in the fight against terrorism. Following a two-day meeting in Paris, prosecutors in charge of counterterrorism investigations in the four countries issued a joint statement Friday to "alert" national and international authorities, internet providers, software makers and telecommunication operators about the obstacles posed by data encryption and the locking systems of smartphones and computers. The issue needs a global response since the concerned companies are often not based in the country where an investigation is taking place, French prosecutor Francois Molins said.