When your team is behind, your aspiration to win is extinguished with each out, not unlike each reporting quarter with Barnes & Noble
The immediate and profound sell-off after the announcement was a clear sign of smart money actively exploiting positive news to liquidate their shares. You don't have to take my word for it though, according to Yahoo Finance, institutions sold almost half their holdings in the prior quarter.
On Tuesday, Barnes & Noble only lost about 16.5% from Monday's close. I say only because after the earnings release horror show, shareholders were lucky (so far). Take a look at the revenue, gross profit, and earnings per share chart.
BKS Revenue Quarterly data by YCharts
Notice the pattern of higher revenue coupled with flat gross profit and shrinking bottom-line earnings per share profit. You can see the red line peaks (earnings per share) falling year after year. The first takeaway is they are growing revenue due to competitors leaving the space, but margins are squeezed.
As soon as revenue peaks (and it appears it has), the earnings per share will implode. Some may argue that losing $2.11 "is" an implosion, but they're not listening to Barnes & Noble's CEO William Lynch who stated during the conference call:
"As we announced in this morning's year-end results, Barnes & Noble Retail and Barnes & Noble College delivered a very solid performance in fiscal year 2013..."
I can say my son and the Lowes Creek Red Wings had a very solid performance in the last little league season too, but with more credibility. Barnes & Noble reported an acceleration of losses combined with shrinking revenue. We can agree it was a solid acceleration of losses; doubling from $1.06 a share during the corresponding quarter last year with the performance of 7.3% lower sales.
If I was William Lynch, I too would focus the earnings call on Barnes & Noble College. It's the bright spot in the Barnes & Noble family. Unfortunately, you can't count on that segment to flourish, and I will explain why.
How long do you think it will take before the majority of schools are using tablets instead of books? The transformation is already beginning. There should be no question in your mind that digital books cost less. No shipping, distribution, printing, or binding is required, and Barnes & Noble is part of distribution.
The way content is delivered is changing, and the half-life of physical paper books is probably not much more than five years. Why buy a physical copy of a college book for $125 when you can buy the same text in digital form for $70? I'm sure some will prefer the paper version regardless of cost, but isn't a model you want to invest in.
Some colleges include books as part of tuition. You can count on colleges to be keenly interested in the cost savings of issuing one tablet versus the current costs of physical books. As content delivery shifts to a digital format, what value does Barnes & Noble add that justifies anywhere near the current margins enjoyed now? What will stop professors and other authors from selling directly or when a publisher is employed, having the publisher sell directly?
The company reported Barnes & Noble College full year comps decreased 1.2%. As an investor, you should anticipate continued revenue and margin contraction. Even if they can hang on to their niche, the only way you can believe the margins won't get squeezed is to bet on Amazon
My opinion of Amazon's share price notwithstanding, the number one online retailer didn't achieve its position because it lacks initiative. I'm not suggesting the world belongs to Amazon, and this is a cage match where only one can exit, but you're setting yourself up for failure if you're counting on any part of this business model to flood the coffers with cash. I would sooner bet on team coaches Brad, Darrin, and Shanda to turn the Lowes Creek Red Wings into the little league champs.
BKS EPS Diluted Annual data by YCharts
At the time of publication the author held no positions in any of the stocks mentioned.
This article is commentary by an independent contributor, separate from TheStreet's regular news coverage.
- 5 Coolest 2013 Cars under $18,000
- Apple TV Gets a Major Upgrade (Update 1)
- 5 Housing Markets Where You'll Break Even Fast When You Buy
- Investment & Company Information