Taxes when broker botched your Roth IRA transfer

Judy O'Connor
Judy O'Connor
Judy O'Connor

Dear Tax Talk,
I have a dandy of a question regarding penalties and options. With the help of our broker in June 2013, $6,000 was transferred out of my wife's (age 58) Roth IRA and transferred not to her Roth at another brokerage, but to my (age 59 1/2) Roth IRA.

I'm thinking I should expect taxes and penalty for my wife's transfer out. I am retired and had no earned income and did not qualify for a contribution. My only income was pension and dividend income. What taxes and penalties should I expect to pay, and do I have an option of reversing or correcting erroneous transfers? Do I have to pay for a broker's mistake with a Roth IRA transfer?

Lesson learned: Pay close attention to your brokerage statements!
-- Terry

Dear Terry,
I agree with you on paying close attention to your brokerage statements. This is considered an excess contribution to your Roth IRA account. It is a good thing that you saw the error because you have time to get this fixed, and that will save you the 6 percent excise tax that applies to excess contributions. You have until on or before the due date of your 2013 Form 1040 (including extensions) to get this corrected.

You need to contact the broker as it is not just the $6,000 that was incorrectly deposited into your account that needs to be removed. The earnings on the $6,000 will need to come out of your account also and will be treated as earned and received in 2013. I would get started on this right away and confirm that everything is done correctly and timely by the broker.

Good luck and thanks for your question.

Ask the adviser

To ask a question on Tax Talk, go to the "Ask the Experts" page and select "Taxes" as the topic. Read more Tax Talk columns.

To ensure compliance with requirements imposed by the IRS, we inform you that any U.S. federal tax advice contained in this communication (including any attachments) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recommending to another party any transaction or matter addressed herein. Taxpayers should seek professional advice based on their particular circumstances.

Bankrate's content, including the guidance of its advice-and-expert columns and this website, is intended only to assist you with financial decisions. The content is broad in scope and does not consider your personal financial situation. Bankrate recommends that you seek the advice of advisers who are fully aware of your individual circumstances before making any final decisions or implementing any financial strategy. Please remember that your use of this website is governed by Bankrate's Terms of Use.

More From

  • 8 Things You Should Never Keep in Your Wallet

    8 Things You Should Never Keep in Your Wallet

    That overstuffed wallet of yours can’t be comfortable to sit on. It’s probably even too clunky to lug around in a purse, too. And with every new bank slip that bulges from the seams, your personal information is getting less and less safe. With just your name and Social Security number, identity thieves can open new credit accounts and make costly purchases in your name. If they can get their hands on (and doctor) a government-issued photo ID of yours, they can do even more damage, such as opening new bank accounts. These days, con artists are even profiting from tax-return fraud and health-care fraud, all with stolen IDs. We talked with consumer-protection advocates to identify the eight things

  • Can I Tap My Retirement Savings Penalty-Free at Age 55?

    Can I Tap My Retirement Savings Penalty-Free at Age 55?

    Q.: I want to retire at 55 and was under the impression I had to wait until I was 59½ years old to avoid the 10% early withdrawal penalty on my retirement savings. A.: 403(b) plans are retirement savings accounts for certain employees in the nonprofit sector and public schools. “That’s something a lot of people don’t understand,” says Mike Piershale, president of Piershale Financial Group in Crystal Lake, Ill.

  • Jess Lee of Polyvore joins Sequoia Capital as its 11th investing partner

    Jess Lee of Polyvore joins Sequoia Capital as its 11th investing partner

    Sequoia Capital has brought aboard Jess Lee as its eleventh investing partner in the U.S., becoming the firm’s first senior female U.S. investor in its 44-year-old history. Lee was a former Google product manager turned CEO of the fashion site Polyvore, which was acquired for $230 million in cash by Yahoo last year. She had stayed on with Yahoo, which is now being sold, maybe, to Verizon, the parent company of TechCrunch. Lee seemed to demonstrate a strong eye for startups long ago. Indeed, in 2008, as an avid user of Polyvore, which was then just months old,  Lee wrote to its founder, Pasha Sadri, with whom she shared mutual friends. After offering him her unsolicited feedback via email about

  • OBAMA ON OBAMACARE: You're getting better health insurance 'even if you don't know that Obamacare is doing it'
    Business Insider

    OBAMA ON OBAMACARE: You're getting better health insurance 'even if you don't know that Obamacare is doing it'

    President Barack Obama in a speech in Florida on Thursday defended his signature healthcare law, touting its benefits while attacking Republicans for opposing it. Obama hit on the various benefits of the Affordable Care Act, more commonly known as Obamacare, such as allowing children to stay on their parents' health insurance until age 26 and preventing insurers from denying people with preexisting conditions. "You're getting better quality, even though you don't know that Obamacare is doing it," Obama said.

  • BAT offers to buy U.S. tobacco firm Reynolds in $47 billion deal

    BAT offers to buy U.S. tobacco firm Reynolds in $47 billion deal

    British American Tobacco (BATS.L) has offered to buy out U.S. cigarette maker Reynolds American Inc (RAI.N) in a $47 billion takeover that would create the world's biggest listed tobacco company with brands including Newport, Lucky Strike and Pall Mall. The cash-and-stock deal would mark the return of BAT to the lucrative and highly regulated U.S. market after a 12-year absence, making it the only tobacco giant with a leading presence in American and international markets. A Reynolds takeover by BAT, which already owns 42 percent of the U.S. group, has long been seen as part of an inevitable wave of global consolidation in a mature industry.

  • A recession is coming — so hide in gold, says influential investor Raoul Pal

    A recession is coming — so hide in gold, says influential investor Raoul Pal

    Mirror, mirror on the wall, which asset is most mispriced of all? According to a Goldman Sachs alum who predicted the financial crisis in 2008, it’s gold. The precious metal should be a lot more expensive when the likelihood of a global financial collapse and a move toward negative interest rates is accounted for, says Global Macro Investor founder Raoul Pal, who now sees a U.S. recession within 12 months. Recent losses for gold may have dented investor confidence. Gold GCZ6, -0.09%  is up 18% this year, but the first full week of October marked its worst seven-day performance in over three years; it also posted a three-month loss of nearly 6% on a continuous basis. Uncertainty about Brexit and

  • Jailed 96 days on bogus charge: It is no one's fault?
    Associated Press

    Jailed 96 days on bogus charge: It is no one's fault?

    Pulled over for traffic violations, Jessica Jauch was held for 96 days in a Mississippi jail without seeing a judge, getting a lawyer or having a chance to make bail. "I think each state suffers from the symptoms we see in Mississippi," said Brandon Buskey, a senior staff attorney for the ACLU's Criminal Law Reform Project.

  • T-Mobile fined $48M over slowing 'unlimited' data plans
    Associated Press

    T-Mobile fined $48M over slowing 'unlimited' data plans

    T-Mobile, the country's No. 3 wireless carrier, will pay $48 million for not clearly telling customers how "unlimited" data plans weren't really, well, unlimited. The Federal Communications Commission said Wednesday that T-Mobile had a policy to slow down the speeds of customers who were the heaviest data users. The FCC said T-Mobile started doing a better job with disclosures in June 2015.

  • Why Jim Chanos is thoroughly unimpressed by Tesla
    Yahoo Finance

    Why Jim Chanos is thoroughly unimpressed by Tesla

    Influential short-seller Jim Chanos, who runs hedge fund Kynikos Associates, has been betting against two companies founded by billionaire serial entrepreneur Elon Musk — Tesla Motors (TSLA) and SolarCity (SCTY). “The fact of the matter is this is a company — in Tesla’s case — that’s now really going to need to step up the production.

  • US confirms 11th death due to Takata air bags
    Associated Press

    US confirms 11th death due to Takata air bags

    A 50-year-old woman who died after a car wreck last month in California is the 11th U.S. victim of Takata Corp.'s defective air bag inflators. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration confirmed the woman's death on Thursday but didn't release her name. Up to five people also may have been killed by the air bags in Malaysia, bringing the number of deaths globally to as many as 16.

  • Apple: Many 'genuine' Apple products on Amazon are fake
    Associated Press

    Apple: Many 'genuine' Apple products on Amazon are fake

    Apple says it has been buying Apple chargers and cables labeled as genuine on and has found nearly 90 percent of them to be counterfeit. The revelation comes in a federal lawsuit filed by Apple against a New Jersey company on Monday over what Apple says are counterfeit products that were sold on Amazon. In the lawsuit, Apple says Mobile Star imprinted Apple logos on cables and chargers that "pose a significant risk of overheating, fire, and electrical shock." It says the chargers and cables were being sold on Amazon as genuine Apple products.

  • AT&T, Time Warner in talks for potential merger: Report

    AT&T, Time Warner in talks for potential merger: Report

    AT&T and Time Warner are beginning talks for a potential merger, according to a report from Bloomberg. Bloomberg reported senior executives from both companies have met to discuss business strategies including talks of a potential merger. The talks were "informal" at this time and no financial advisers have been hired, the sources said. Sources previously told CNBC that AT&T was in the market to purchase a media property soon. In order to stay competitive with the likes of Verizon and Comcast, the telecommunications company needs to move into the media space. Doing so would give it the resources to become an advertising giant, because it would own not only Internet and cable access but content

  • Microsoft stock just beat its all-time high, set in 1999
    Business Insider

    Microsoft stock just beat its all-time high, set in 1999

    Microsoft shares popped up to an all-time high of above $60 on Thursday as strength in its cloud business helped propel it past Wall Street financial targets in its fiscal first quarter. Microsoft stock was up over 5% on the solid beat on the top and bottom lines in after-hours trading. Investors are looking for signs of continued growth in Microsoft's all-important cloud computing businesses, as it shifts away from selling boxed software and into a subscription- and usage-based billing model.

  • Rite Aid pops 6% after delay in Walgreens merger

    Rite Aid pops 6% after delay in Walgreens merger

    Rite Aid stock jumped 6 percent Thursday, following a mutual decision with Walgreens Boots Alliance to delay their merger agreement until January 27. The merger agreement was previously scheduled to be completed on October 27. The companies entered into a definitive agreement in October 2015, under which Walgreens would acquire all outstanding shares of Rite Aid for $9 a share. The original terms of the agreement allowed either party to delay the merger until January. Walgreens Boots Alliance is the largest retail pharmacy chain in the U.S. and Europe. Walgreens' stock was trading more than 4 percent higher Thursday. Shares of Walgreens Boots Alliance and Rite Aid have fallen more than 4 percent

  • Business

    Indian Card Breach Seen Hindering Modi’s Quest to Go Cashless

    India’s quest to become a cashless economy has been dealt a blow by a data breach that compromised as many as 3.2 million debit cards. Prime Minister Narendra Modi urged Indians in a radio address in May to use cashless payments to discourage corruption and keep track of money. Convincing them may get harder after India’s national card payments network said that the data violation led to fraudulent transactions, mainly in China and the U.S.

  • News
    Bloomberg Video

    Why Verizon's Subscriber Growth Is Slowing

    Oct. 20 -- Verizon Communications reported subscriber growth that fell to its lowest level in six years during the third quarter as its rivals took a more competitive stance on pricing. Bloomberg Intelligence's John Butler reports on "Bloomberg Daybreak: Americas."

  • Technology
    Associated Press

    Counterterrorism prosecutors seek access to encrypted data

    Prosecutors from France, Belgium, Spain and Morocco called Friday for the ability to unlock phones and computers and to gain access to encrypted communications to aid in the fight against terrorism. Following a two-day meeting in Paris, prosecutors in charge of counterterrorism investigations in the four countries issued a joint statement Friday to "alert" national and international authorities, internet providers, software makers and telecommunication operators about the obstacles posed by data encryption and the locking systems of smartphones and computers. The issue needs a global response since the concerned companies are often not based in the country where an investigation is taking place, French prosecutor Francois Molins said.

  • Politics
    Associated Press

    NY poised to crack down on illegal Airbnb rentals

    New York state may soon enact one of the nation's toughest restrictions on short-term rentals offered on online sites like Airbnb. Legislation awaiting action by Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo would authorize fines of up to $7,500 for listings that violate a 2010 state law forbidding rentals of less than 30 days when the owner or tenant is not present. The supporters — including labor unions often allied with Cuomo — say Airbnb hurts existing hotels while taking apartments off the long-term rental market, potentially driving up already high housing prices for the people who live in New York City.

  • Church bells around the world toll for civilian casualties in Aleppo

    Church bells around the world toll for civilian casualties in Aleppo

    Churches across the world are joining a Helsinki parish in ringing their bells daily to commemorate civilians killed in the battle for the Syrian city of Aleppo. "After reading the news that day, of Aleppo, we decided to ring funeral bells at 5 p.m. to remember the death. First I just asked a few local churches to join us," Teemu Laajasalo, vicar of the Kallio parish told Reuters.

  • McDonald's sales beat estimates as turnaround gathers pace

    McDonald's sales beat estimates as turnaround gathers pace

    (Reuters) - McDonald's Corp's (MCD.N) turnaround gained momentum in the latest quarter as sales growth at established restaurants beat analysts' estimates, sending the company's shares up almost 4 percent in premarket trading on Friday.

  • Business

    China central bank learns lessons as deflates money market risk

    Three years ago, China's central bank engineered a cash crunch to force commercial banks to reduce their reliance on short-term money markets. Interest rates spiked, spooking global markets who feared a banking crisis was imminent. Once again, the People's Bank of China (PBOC) faces the same problem of too many banks relying on short-term borrowing.

  • Business

    Ireland to hit foreign investors with new tax on real estate deals

    Non-resident investors in Irish real estate funds will have to pay a 20 percent withholding tax from next year on certain deals, the finance ministry said on Thursday, in a further clampdown on structures used to minimise tax bills. Ireland last month proposed to amend tax laws for "Section 110" special purpose vehicles and widened the net on Thursday to include all funds where 25 percent of their value is made up of Irish real estate assets. Such a change targets two other popular types of funds used by foreign investors to buy up swathes of Irish property in recent years: Irish Collective Asset-management Vehicles (ICAVs) and Qualifying Investor Alternative Investment Funds (QIAIFs).

  • Politics

    Factbox: UK heads for Brexit showdown with EU - what's at stake

    Prime Minister Theresa May will come under pressure from other European Union leaders on Thursday to say what kind of deal she wants for Britain when it leaves the bloc. May, attending her first EU summit since becoming prime minister in July, has so far given only glimpses of her vision for Britain's future relationship with the EU.

  • Business

    Accounting watchdog urges UK to stick with global rules

    Britain should not go it alone by adopting its own book-keeping rules after it leaves the European Union, though the global regulations in place could be tailored, the UK's accounting watchdog said on Friday. Listed companies in Britain and across the EU apply the accounting standards adopted by the International Accounting Standards Board.