Part of the reason for designing this tracking portfolio was to get a sense of whether small tech names are truly cheap, or whether they just appear to be. Sometimes companies appear to be bargains but really aren't. All of the names in this portfolio had the following attributes in common:
While two months is but a day to a value investor, it's time to do a brief review of the portfolio, which is comprised of the following names: Benchmark Electronics (BHE), Ingram Micro (IM), Tech Data (TECD), Electro Scientific Industries (ESIO) and SYNNEX (SNX). Since I wrote that initial BITES column, the portfolio is down 2.5%, while the Russell 2000 is up 2.9%, and S&P Small Cap Index is up 3.5%. That's certainly nothing to write home about. Two of the names Benchmark (+5.8%) and Tech Data (+4.8%) are in positive territory, while Synnex (-10%), Ingram (-7.8%) and Electro Scientific (-5.3%) have all been negative. BHE data by YCharts
SNX data by YCharts
Of course, the portfolio still appears to be exceedingly cheap, and the metrics are very similar to what they were in March. Weighting all five of the names equally, the portfolio trades at just 1.37 times net current asset value, 0.96 times book value, 0.44 times price to sales, and a forward price earnings ratio just over 10. The average market cap is about $1.46 billion. The companies are also remain cash rich, with each having at least 17% of their current market cap in cash, or an average of $338 million per company.
As a value investor, I often fish in ponds that are overlooked, or out of favor with others, and this group of small technology names certainly fits that mold. I don't expect quick results here; in fact I never do, and am usually surprised when names I buy take off quickly. When that happens, it usually demonstrates luck and not skill, not that I would complain in those situations.
Its' still too early to tell whether these companies represent real bargains, or whether valuations have shifted to the point that the market is deeply discounting them. They certainly look cheap, and smell cheap, but it may take quite a while to know for sure.
Welcome to the wonderful world of value investing, where only the most patient among us need apply.
At the time of publication the author was long IM, ESIO.
This article is commentary by an independent contributor, separate from TheStreet's regular news coverage.
- Minimum Market Cap of $250 million
- Trading for less than two times net current asset value
- Profitable during trailing 12 months
- Forward Price earnings ratio is less than current PE
- Long-Term Debt to Equity is less than 30%
- All are technology related names