Why We’re So Down in the Dumps About the Economy

Eric Pianin
Why We’re So Down in the Dumps About the Economy

Nearly five years after the recovery began, Americans in alarming numbers believe the Great Recession permanently damaged the economy and that many aspects of the lifestyle they once enjoyed – a good job, income security and more – may never again be theirs. 

Even more troubling, most Americans don’t believe the economy has actually improved – or will improve – despite nearly half a decade of job growth and declining unemployment rates since the recession officially ended in June 2009.

Related: Depressed and Worried, Americans Blame Obama and Congress 

These and other findings are from a new study released Thursday morning by the John J. Heldrich Center for Workforce Development at Rutgers University.

“The slow, uneven and painful recovery left Americans deeply pessimistic about the economy, their personal finances and prospects for the next generation,” Carl  Van Horn, the center’s director and a co-author of the study, said in a statement.

The Heldrich Center is a leading research think tank that has tracked the economy and the American job force since 1997 and researched the effects of the recession. The center’s goals include strengthening workforce education, placement and training programs. It’s also done cutting-edge research on the declining morale and mental health of those who have lost jobs or are just hanging on. 

Related: Fed Study: One-Fourth of Americans ‘Just Getting By’ Financially 

The new findings are similar to those of other recent polls and studies attempting to plumb the public’s psyche over a long and uneven economic recovery. A recent Wall Street Journal-NBC News poll found 71 percent of Americans believe the country is on the “wrong track,” while 7 in 10 blame the malaise on President Obama and Congress more than on structural problems with the recovery.   

Just months before a critical mid-term election, respondents to the Heldrich survey again expressed little or no confidence that President Obama or Congress can or will do anything to help improve the economy. 

Among the survey’s key findings:

  • Seventy percent of Americans are convinced the economy has undergone permanent changes for the worse since the recession, while just 1 in 6 believes job opportunities for the next generation will be better than for theirs. Five years ago, 4 in 10 respondents held that more positive view. Many people today “have little or no confidence that the federal government will make progress on the nation’s most important problems over the next year,” the study found. 

Related: More Dismal Poll Numbers for Obama and Congress 

  • About one-quarter of those interviewed reported a major decline in their quality of life because of the recession, while 42 percent say they have less money in the bank than when the recession began. Some 16 percent of the public said they were “devastated” because they experienced “a major, permanent change in the quality of their life.”
  • A mere 1 in 3 believes the economy has gotten better in the last year and only a quarter of Americans think it will improve next year. “Just 1 in 6 Americans believe job opportunities will be better for the next generation of workers, down from 4 in 10 five years ago,” according to the report.

The authors of the report found that the public “paints an extremely negative picture of American work” when asked to choose from a list of a dozen words or phrases. Only 14 percent checked off “happy at work” and just 18 percent believe they are being well paid. 

Two-thirds say American workers are “not secure in their jobs” and “highly stressed.” Just 1 in 5 believes the average American worker is well educated or innovative; and just 1 in 3 checked off “ambitious” or “highly skilled.”

Related: The Mental Anguish of the Long-term Unemployed 

The authors said they were most surprised by how many respondents denigrated the average American worker. Just 1 in 3 checked off that the average American worker is “better than workers in other countries,” according to the report.

The widespread economic despair is born of fundamental inconsistencies in the long economic recovery, according to the study. Over the past 4 years, for example, nearly 10 million private sector jobs were added and the U.S. has enjoyed 53 consecutive months of economic growth – the longest period of consistent job growth on record. The unemployment rate fell from 8.2 percent in March 2013 to just 6.2 percent in July. 

But that growth “has been insufficient to produce enough full-time jobs for everyone who wants one,” the study notes. As of last month, nearly 9.7 million work­ers were unemployed, and many jobs that vanished during the recession paid good wages, while most growth during the recovery has been in low-wage jobs.

“Wages have increased modestly for many, but have not increased suf­ficiently to keep up with inflation,” the report stated. “Labor force participation rates are at the lowest levels in three decades. Long-term unemployment rates remain at unprecedented high levels, above pre-recession levels in over 40 states.”

Top Reads From The Fiscal Times:

  • Entertainment

    Former Fox News Host Andrea Tantaros Files Suit Alleging Sexual Harassment

    Andrea Tantaros, a former host of Fox News Channel program like “The Five” and “Outnumbered,” is the latest female staffer at the popular cable-news outlet to levy sexual-harassment charges at the 21st Century Fox-owned property. In a lawsuit filed Monday in the Supreme Court of the State of New York, Tantaros alleged that senior executives at the network retaliated against her after she complained about being inappropriate remarks made to her by Roger Ailes, the former chairman and chief executive of the network. Ailes left Fox News last month in the wake of an internal investigation that is believed to have turned up evidence of several female employees at the operation being harassed sexually during their time of employment.

  • COST

    Costco's credit card nightmare just got even worse

    Costco’s marriage to Visa has been rocky pretty much from the start — and this weekend shoppers faced a new problem, despite assurances that issues in the relationship were being ironed out. On Friday evening, a number of Costco members received emails from Citi, the issuer of the new Visa-Costco credit card, alerting them that their credit card accounts had been closed. Citi told Business Insider that Friday’s emails were intended to be sent to Costco shoppers whose memberships had lapsed to alert them they could no longer use their Costco Anywhere Visa cards.

    Business Insider
  • SBUX

    No, Starbucks isn't cheating customers by adding ice to drinks, judge says

    It seems that Starbucks (SBUX) can put as much ice as it wants in your beverage. "If children have figured out that including ice in a cold beverage decreases the amount of liquid they will receive, the Court has no difficulty concluding that a reasonable consumer would not be deceived into thinking that when they order an iced tea, that the drink they receive will include both ice and tea and that for a given size cup, some portion of the drink will be ice rather than whatever liquid beverage the consumer ordered," wrote Percy Anderson, the U.S. District Judge presiding over the case in his dismissal of the lawsuit last Friday. "The cups Starbucks uses for its cold drinks... are clear, and therefore make it easy to see that the drink consists of a combination of liquid and ice," Anderson wrote.

  • Business

    5 Ways to Avoid Taxes on Your Social Security Benefits

    How are taxes on Social Security benefits calculated? Are there any strategies that would help me avoid paying taxes on my benefits? Whether your Social Security benefits are taxed depends on your "provisional income." Your provisional income is your adjusted gross income, not counting Social Security benefits, plus nontaxable interest and half of your Social Security benefits. If it's below $25,000 and you file taxes as single or head of household, or less than $32,000 if you file a joint return, you won't owe taxes on your benefits. If your provisional income is between $25,000 and $34,000 if you're single, or between $32,000 and $44,000 if you file jointly, up to 50% of your benefits may be

  • Politics

    Lawmakers demand information on EpiPen price increase

    Sen. Charles Grassley, R-Iowa, wrote Mylan, the company that manufactures the devices, and asked for more information on why the prices have increased. Two other senators, Democrats Mark Warner of Virginia and Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut, also wrote the company about the high prices. Warner said in a letter Tuesday that the issue is personal for him.

    Associated Press
  • Business

    Bill Gates Is the Richest He’s Ever Been

    Bill Gates, the richest man in the world, reached a whole new level of wealth Friday, when his net worth hit $90 billion, thanks to “gains in public holdings including Canadian National Railway Company and Ecolab Inc,” Bloomberg reports. The Microsoft founder’s net worth is $13.5 billion bigger than Amancio Ortega, the second wealthiest person in the world, per Bloomberg’s Billionaire Index. Ortega is the Spanish mogul behind fast fashion retailer Zara.

  • Business

    Seadrill Ltd. Just Got Even Riskier -- The Motley Fool

    So much for a drilling recovery just yet. On Monday , offshore driller Seadrill Ltd. (NYSE:SDRL) announced that it had received notice from Pemex that it was canceling its contract for the West Pegasus semi-submersible drilling vessel, yet another reminder that the offshore drilling environment remains in a serious downturn. But here's what makes this particular cancellation unusual: Pemex and Seadrill had just signed the contract in the first quarter of 2016. Overall, it's a troubling reminder how far we may be from a recovery. And that's particularly bad news for Seadrill, which has a lot of debt coming due and newbuilds on track to be delivered in the near term.  Let's take a closer look at

    The Motley Fool
  • Technology

    T-Mobile strikes a nerve with move to single unlimited data plan

    Has T-Mobile finally jumped the shark with its latest "Uncarrier" move? The wireless carrier's industry-shaking announcements, such as eliminating phone subsidies and offering free international data roaming, helped it amass a legion of followers over the last three years. But the backlash was swift and harsh for T-Mobile's Uncarrier 12, which scraps its lineup of wireless plans in lieu of a single unlimited option. Within hours, critics took to the T-Mobile Reddit thread to rant about the changes (they've since been consolidated into one "megathread"). What really ticked people off is that customers who'd prefer a cheaper, limited option have to pay up for the new plan. This marks the first

  • AAPL

    According to this chart, Apple shares are approaching a critical breaking point

    For Jonathan Krinsky, technical analyst MKM Partners, Apple's chart has become a heated battleground between bulls and bears. But he observes that Apple shares, which are up about 10 percent in the past month, have recently reached up to the top of this channel. The story of the $90 level on Apple's chart starts in April 2012, when the stock topped out at $92 — which was then actually $644, as it was before Apple's 7-to-1 stock split.

  • Business

    Lincoln, Honda, Toyota, BMW are tops in customer satisfaction (Acura, VW not so much)

    ACSI's 2016 Automobile Report polled 3,776 auto customers, asking them to evaluate their experiences with a wide range of car brands, using a scale of 0 (not at all satisfied) to 100 (over the moon). The 2015 ACSI survey saw continued declines in satisfaction, which was attributed to several years of high-profile recalls. On ACSI's 100-point scale, the average score in 2016 is 82, up 3.8 percent from last year.

    The Car Connection
  • Business

    U.S. Trade Rep approves import ban on Arista devices, says rival Cisco

    The U.S. Trade Representative has upheld an import ban on Arista Networks Inc's ethernet switches following a federal commission's finding in June that the company's products infringed patents owned by rival Cisco Systems Inc, Cisco said. The decision by the U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC), which investigates purported violations of U.S. intellectual property, stemmed from a complaint Cisco filed in December 2014 about the switches, which are used in computer data centers and servers. In a blog post on the company's website on Monday, Cisco general counsel Mark Chandler said the import ban was to start on Tuesday.

  • World

    California high court upholds ban on dredges to extract gold

    California's ban on the use of suction dredges to extract gold from rivers is legal and not overridden by a 19th century federal law that allows mining on federal land, the California Supreme Court ruled Monday. The court's unanimous decision was a victory for environmentalists and a blow to miners, who argued that the ban essentially stopped gold mining because doing it by hand is labor intensive and makes the enterprise unprofitable. Environmentalists say suction dredge mining risks killing fish and stirring up toxic mercury.

    Associated Press
  • Business

    What Costco's Inventory Turnover Says About Its Moat -- The Motley Fool

    Though Costco (NASDAQ:COST) may be known for "frills" like above-average employee pay, when it comes to managing its balance sheet, it is ruthlessly efficient. This can be observed in the company's inventory turnover ratio, or the number of times it sells its average level of inventory over the course of a year. What is inventory turnover? The inventory turnover ratio can be defined as the amount of inventory sold, divided by average inventory during the period. With Costco's financials in hand, one can quickly calculate its inventory turnover ratio with just three pieces of data, shown below in the table. Our numerator for this ratio is $101,065, or the cost of goods sold in 2015 in millions

    The Motley Fool
  • News

    Philippine President Duterte Stokes Controversy

    Rodrigo Duterte, who became president of the Philippines in June, has already made a number of controversial moves, from waging a violent war on drug and crime and publicly accusing individuals of aiding druglords to threatening to leave the United Nations. Photo: EPA

    WSJ Live
  • Health

    AstraZeneca to Sell Molecule Antibiotics Business to Pfizer

    Pharmaceutical company AstraZeneca plans to sell its molecule antibiotics business to Pfizer in a deal that will be valued in excess of $1.5 billion when rights, royalties and other payments are included. The sale marks a thawing of relations between the British company and New York-based Pfizer after an acrimonious battle to avoid a takeover just a few years ago. Under the deal, AstraZeneca will sell the commercialization and development rights in most markets globally outside the United States. It includes an upfront payment of $550 million. Luke Miels, the head of the antibiotics business unit at AstraZeneca, says the company is "pleased that our strong science in antibiotics will continue

    ABC News
  • Entertainment

    Courteney Cox on ‘Running Wild’: ‘This is the Worst Thing I’ve Ever Done’

    On Monday’s Running Wild With Bear Grylls, Courteney Cox stopped running and started fearing for her life. Bear Grylls knew how to traverse the gap and explained that he would toss his ice pick over a boulder, rappel to the other side, and send a zipline back to Cox.

  • Politics

    Campaign's rising rent at Trump Tower came as space expanded

    Donald Trump's campaign is taking up more space inside Trump Tower in New York -- and paying a lot more in rent. The Republican presidential nominee's campaign paid $35,457 per month for rent and utilities to Trump Tower Commercial LLC between last August and this April, Federal Election Commission reports show. The rent hike at the Manhattan skyscraper came as the Trump team expanded from using only the fifth floor to add two additional levels, according to a statement Tuesday from the campaign.

    Associated Press
  • Politics

    How Trump’s Need for Vengeance Is Killing His Campaign

    Donald Trump is notoriously thin-skinned. And when provoked, he tends to overreact wildly. His latest fit of pique is over comments that Mika Brzezinski of MSNBC’s Morning Joe made about a speech Trump gave in Virginia a few days ago in which she said

    The Fiscal Times
  • Business

    Retire Wealthy: The Millennial March to $1,000,000

    Today I want to teach members of the Millennial population how to retire wealthy, perhaps with at least a million dollars. It is vital that Millennials understand how to use the power of time in their financial march to a million. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) recently reported on how Americans are doing when it comes to saving for retirement. Unfortunately, it was not good news. The GAO analysis discovered that almost half of households with members age 55 or older, had no retirement savings in a 401(k) plan or IRA, and nearly 29% have neither retirement savings nor a traditional pension plan. In about half of the households with members age 65 and older, Social Security provides

  • Business

    Delta Offers Pilots 27% Raise as Contract Impasse Lingers

    Delta Air Lines Inc. offered its 13,000 pilots a raise of about 27 percent over four years, significantly less than what the employees have proposed in contract talks that have lingered since the beginning of the year. The carrier’s offer was disclosed in a letter Sunday to pilots from John Malone, chairman of the Delta chapter of the Air Line Pilots Association, which is asking for a 37 percent raise over three years. The union has taken an aggressive stance in negotiations with the Atlanta-based airline, saying that the carrier’s profits justify the reversal of pay and benefits cuts adopted in the early 2000s. “Delta is committed to reaching a timely new agreement that is market-based, sustainable, and that also ensures Delta pilots have an industry-leading package of pay, benefits and work rules,” Morgan Durrant, a spokesman for the airline, said in an e-mail.

  • Business

    Former IRS chief says Trump has no excuse to not release his tax returns

    Much has been said and written about Donald Trump 's refusal to release his tax returns. Tax returns paint a revealing picture of who we are. But nothing prevents us as taxpayers from choosing to release our tax returns — and those who aspire for the highest public office have done so for decades.

  • Business

    Berkshire Hathaway Stock Split: Bringing Warren Buffett's Genius to the Public -- The Motley Fool

    Warren Buffett-led conglomerate Berkshire Hathaway (NYSE:BRK-A) (NYSE:BRK-B) has the most expensive publicly traded stock in the world. While the massive Class A shares have never split in the company's history, the company created Class B shares and has since split them 50-to-1 in order to make Berkshire accessible to all investors. Berkshire Hathaway pre-1996 Berkshire Hathaway class A shares were the only ones in existence until 1996. The A shares currently trade for about $223,000 apiece, and they have been an unusually expensive stock for decades. For a while, Warren Buffett was adamant that the company's shares would never split. And technically, Buffett has been true to his word: Berkshire's

    The Motley Fool
  • Business

    Why markets may be setting up for a Yellen surprise

    Markets are only half listening to the Fed, and that leaves room for a bigger reaction if Fed Chair Janet Yellen sounds as hawkish as the comments of some other Fed officials suggest she might. If they want to get this done, and they don't want to shock the market and create a whole repeat of last year's market volatility from not going [last September] … they have to inject the expectations of another rate hike. With little to sway the markets this week amid very light trading, markets are fixated on Yellen's Friday speech in Jackson Hole, Wyoming.

  • Politics

    Will 15,000 New Emails Be Clinton’s ‘October Surprise’?

    In the latest chapter of the long saga of Hillary Clinton’s woeful mishandling of highly sensitive government documents and email, the government confirmed on Monday that the FBI uncovered nearly 15,000 previously undisclosed documents that Clinton sent or received during her four years as secretary of state. The 14,900 Clinton documents that the Justice Department revealed in federal court are nearly half again as many as the roughly 30,000 emails that Clinton’s lawyers assessed as “work related” and delivered to State in December 2014 as part of a federal probe into Clinton’s use of a private email server in her home. FBI Director James Comey said in July that investigators found “several thousand” more emails that were not included in the December batch.

    The Fiscal Times