Before 1990, there wasn’t an easy way for investors to put money to work in a diversified basket of commodities. Unless you had your own seat on the futures exchange a la Dan Akroyd and Eddie Murphy in Trading Places or hired a broker who did, it would have been nearly impossible to include commodities in a well-diversified portfolio.
That all changed in the early 1990s once fund companies were able to set up investment vehicles to buy and sell commodities to package as investment products for prospective investors. Once commodities started to show promising performance in the early 2000s more and more products started popping up in the form of mutual funds and ETFs that made it much easier for investors to gain exposure to commodities.
This left many long-term investors wondering if it makes sense to include commodities as a permanent position within their portfolio.
Let’s take a look at two of the most well-known, diversified commodity indexes to see how investors would have done since the early 1990s when the asset class became available for wider distribution.
These are the performance numbers for the S&P GSCI (formerly the Goldman Sachs Commodities Index) and the Dow Jones UBS Commodity Index compared to the returns earned in stocks and T-Bills:
Over this nearly 25 year period, a diverse portfolio of commodities would have earned investors similar returns to cash with similar volatility to stocks, the exact opposite of what you would want to see from a long-term asset class. Factoring in inflation the real returns were 0.37% and 1.45% annually for the respective commodities indexes.
This data makes a strong case that commodities don’t make for a solid long-term investment as a dedicated allocation in a portfolio. They are probably much more conducive to trading than investing as you can see from this performance breakdown by different periods:
There have been bouts of strong performance but there are wild swings in the prices of commodities over time. This makes sense because commodities are really just materials and input costs. They don’t pay dividends or generate earnings like stocks. They don’t pay income like bonds.
It has been argued that the high volatility in commodities could actually help reduce overall portfolio volatility as a hedge because the returns are uncorrelated with stocks and bonds. A recent research paper refutes this suggestion by showing that commodities actually increase overallportfolio volatility with a decrease in risk-adjusted returns.
Many investors and financial advisors saw the huge returns in the early-to-mid 2000s as a signal to increase their long-term allocation to commodities. The data shows that this was probably a mistake.
Commodities appear to be a trading vehicle, not a viable long-term investing option.
Photo: Terence Wright
Recommended for You
After weeks of criticism from patients, doctors and even other drugmakers for hiking a life-saving medicine's price more than fifty-fold, Turing Pharmaceuticals is reneging on its pledge to cut the $750-per-pill ...Los Angeles Times
Maverick Carter, the manager of LeBron James’ growing business empire, has followed in the footsteps of the NBA superstar, buying a home in the Los Angeles area.Los Angeles Times
Retirees have special concerns when evaluating state tax policies: Are Social Security benefits taxed? Does the state impose its own estate tax? Are there property tax breaks for seniors? The answers can ...Kiplinger
Making "The Big Short," about investors who foresaw the collapse of the housing market and made money short-selling it, left Brad Pitt with little faith in financial reform. Gracious Home CEO ...Bloomberg
In the spirit of Colorado’s consistently groundbreaking legislation, hundreds of thousands of taxpayers and voters get behind a new bill that will leave the state footing the cost of healthcare. This podcast was recorded on 11/11/2015.The Motley Fool Videos
Philippine economic growth accelerated less than analysts estimated last quarter, underscoring the external risks that policy makers are guarding against even as spending by households and the government ...Bloomberg
No holiday cheer for investors this year.Fortune
MOSCOW (AP) — Tensions between Russia and Ukraine escalated Wednesday as Ukraine decided to stop buying Russian natural gas — hoping to rely on supplies from other countries — and closed its airspace to its eastern neighbor.Associated Press
Deep discounts on 4K TVs, laptops, and fitness watchesUSA TODAY
VW had 45 days to come up with a recall planUSA TODAY
Find out how your 401(k) works after you retire, including when you are required to begin taking distributions and the tax impact of your withdrawals.Investopedia
Buy socks when they are on sale as, contrary to the opinion of the general investor, pricing weaknesses usually provide the greatest investment opportunityZacks
Colorado has constantly been in the news regarding its recent overhaul on the legislature allowing for personal recreational use of marijuana. As Ohio has cast their vote determining their citizens were wary of following in Colorado's footsteps, it could very well set into motion a path for other…The Motley Fool Videos
Wolfango Piccoli, managing director at Teneo Intelligence, discusses the aftermath of Turkey downing a Russian jet and subsequent comments from Russian President Vladimir Putin. He speaks with Jonathan ...Bloomberg
If you want to get rich, start investing — and do it sooner rather than later. When you're...Business Insider
While students from Yale University in Connecticut to Claremont McKenna in California are protesting, demanding more cultural sensitivity, safe spaces and trigger warnings, some students at Princeton University in New Jersey are fighting back. As signatures on the petition climbed, students formed…The Fiscal Times
At a time when Canada is questioning its commitment to the staggeringly expensive F-35 Joint Strike Fighter, the United Kingdom this week released a national security roadmap that goes all in on the multibillion weapons program. The “Security Strategy and Strategic Defence and Security Review”…The Fiscal Times
Ever wonder why some tax returns are eyeballed by the Internal Revenue Service while most are ignored? Short on personnel and funding, the IRS audited only 0.86% of all individual returns in 2014. And ...Kiplinger
We think that there might be more chance for crude oil futures to trade higher the next several weeksTheStreet.com
Bank of America CEO, Brian Moynihan is unlike your typical executive. He chooses to live in Boston while his bank is headquartered in Charlotte, North Carolina. This presents a huge challenge to the company as a whole, and its investors. What are the financial ramifications to the company when…The Motley Fool Videos