Back in a January post we detailed the activity in the Jan15 50 puts in HLF when the stock was in the low $70s after a quick decline from the recent highs int he lows $80s:
Well, in the past week, we’ve seen a flurry of activity in the Jan15 50 puts in HLF. First, on Thursday, January 9th, the Jan15 50 puts traded 25k times at 7.25 (mentioned in our Friday TMO post). The same line traded another 20k times at 7.10 on Friday, January 10th (also mentioned, in our Monday TMO). The Jan15 50 puts now have the most open interest of any strike in HLF, at around 50k in total.
Well, around noon today, the trader rolled the Jan15 50 puts out to the Jan16 50 puts, selling 28,000 of the Jan15 50 puts at $8.05, and buying 32,200 of the Jan16 50 puts for $15.55. It looks like Bill Ackman is on the move again, paying an additional $7.50 in premium to roll the short HLF view out to Jan16.
What’s interesting about this trade is that the Jan15 50 puts were bought back in January 2014 at $7.10 and $7.25 when HLF was still in the 70′s. Today, HLF is around $50, and the put has only appreciated around $1.00 as a result of time decay. Moreover, the cost to roll the put position out to Jan16 means an additional $7.50 in premium, and since there was not much of a gain on the Jan15 50 put, the total premium at risk for the trader is nearly $15 for the Jan16 50 put. In other words, the break-even for the entire trade from initiation in January 2014 is currently around $35 for the Jan16 50 puts that were opened today.
Add to that the fact that the trade position is now bigger today than it was on a premium basis 6 months ago, and you could argue that Ackman is actually increasing the size of his bet. While he has given himself one extra year, he also has doubled the total potential loss if HLF rallies or remains above $50 by January 2016 expiration. Some who would argue that that’s a sign that regulators like the FTC might be taking longer than Ackman had hoped in investigating Herbalife. Whatever the reasoning, it’s quite surprising to see a put trade that only offers 2.33 to 1 upside if the company goes all the way to 0 ($35 potential gain vs. $15 potential loss). That is an indication that Bill Ackman is betting on the stock to go to 0 due to regulatory action. He is not in this trade for a decline to $25.
Timing is a crucial issue for any options trade, but particularly so for a situation that is so public. Herbalife management is also watching Bill Ackman’s trading very closely, and I’m sure they’ll take notice of today’s roll as well. In fact, part of the reason they probably were so aggressive in buying stock earlier this year was to delay any decline in HLF stock to put more pressure on Ackman as his puts decayed. Matt Levine laid out the rapid pace of that buying ina late April post:
Those are irresistibly big numbers, and I did not resist them. Here are Herbalife’s share repurchases, as a percentage of daily volume:
Those are kind of wild numbers! And, actually, the first-quarter numbers are a bit exaggerated, since Herbalife did most of its buying in one big swoop, from hedge funds who were naturally set up to sell stock to hedge the convertible that it issued. If you ignore that one day of buying, basically Herbalife averaged less than one percent of daily volume for the previous 15 months — and then almost 10 percent of volume in April.
Or another comparison: Net income over the past 15 months totals about $650 million; cash flow from operations was a little under $1 billion. Throw in the $297.4 million that Herbalife spent on share repurchase last year, and you get over $1.3 billion of share repurchases and related transactions in the last 16 months, well ahead of operating cash flow and more than double net income. Herbalife is funneling money to shareholders faster than it can make it.
We actually put on a bearish trade in Herbalife after the late April earnings announcement, with the thought that the company had used up most of its buyback ammunition in the first 4 months of the year. We took that trade off for a profit at the start of August.
Now, Ackman’s latest move puts a bit more pressure on HLF, as he might be sticking around for another full year to see his thesis through. Given that HLF has much less buyback ammunition, the real fight now will be on the regulatory front. Herbalife management should see quite clearly that Bill Ackman is playing for a closure of the company, not just a large stock decline. With that in mind, Herbalife executives are likely to regroup and strategize about how best to address the many issues that Ackman has brought up and regulators are likely to probe. The stakes have been raised. This has become a fight for survival.
Recommended for You
SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg and his pediatrician wife, Priscilla Chan, are expecting a baby.Associated Press
An Arizona man is accused of using his company credit card to pay for, tip and give gifts to strippers he befriended online.Credit.com
The Pentagon awarded $4.83 billion in new defense contracts Wednesday -- all but $495 million of which was contained in one single award. The lucky winner of this award -- all $4.34 billion of it -- is ...Investopedia
Jim Cramer goes over his game plan of stocks and events he will be watching next week, including this event that could send averages into a nosedive.CNBC
Oppenheimer's Ari Wald says the combination of narrowing breadth and seasonal weakness could set up for a stock market pullback.CNBC
Puerto Rico Governor Alejandro Garcia Padilla shocked investors in June when he said the island's debt, totaling $72 billion, was unpayable and required restructuring. According to a 2014 bond offering statement, Puerto Rico has never defaulted on the payment of principal or interest of debt.…Reuters
All eyes on China. "Mad Money" host Jim Cramer wants you to look for a major discount on this stock if China tumbles.CNBC Videos
Republicans in Congress have been working to kill the Iran nuclear deal almost before it was even completed and in the past week, a new strategy has emerged. Under the agreement negotiated in advance with Congress, the president will be able to commit the United States to the deal unless Congress…The Fiscal Times
Seven months ago (before I knew about my termination), my wife and I decided to extract $180,000 to pay off the mortgage of our only residence in preparation for retirement. In addition to the 20% I paid when receiving the withdrawal to pay off our mortgage, the IRS is asking for another $15,000.…Bankrate.com
The company is adjusting to what may be a very period of low oil prices.TheStreet.com
Kansas reported Friday that it collected slightly less in taxes this month than expected, and officials attributed the $3.7 million shortfall largely to a national softness in consumer spending affecting ...Associated Press
At 5 p.m. on Tuesday, a gong will be struck at the Fox News headquarters in New York. At that moment, the five most recent national primary polls, “as recognized by FOX News,” will be averaged, and the top 10 Republican presidential candidates will get invites to the network’s prime-time debate…FiveThirtyEight
There's more bad news for the coal industry. On Thursday, Bloomberg reported that the biggest...Business Insider
In keeping with our longer-term prediction for gold, we believe a major low in silver will be coming shortly, which could result in a near-term rally of significance, but setting up a much longer-term ...MarketWatch
Baht's weakness this month is all the more striking considering "the currency's relative resilience versus the US dollar previously," wrote UBS's Edward Teather this morning. The threat of a rate hike from the Federal Reserve Bank aside, the Bank of Thailand also seems to encourage the baht to…Barrons.com
$27 million is going to 114 of the company's 370 employees.USA TODAY
How Puerto Rico's possible debt default may impact the global economy, with CNBC's Kate Kelly.CNBC Videos
The Swiss Franc is getting crushed.Fortune
They aren't afraid of credit cards but realize they're a double-edged sword.Money
The Mexican peso sank to a record, crossing the threshold that would trigger an extraordinary dollar sale by the central bank for the third time since December. The Mexican peso fell 1.1 percent to 16.4759 per U.S. dollar as of 10:52 a.m. in Mexico City, joining a drop in emerging-market currencies…Bloomberg