This is a guest post written by Peter Morici. Peter is an economist and business professor at the University of Maryland, national columnist and five-time winner of the MarketWatch best forecaster award.
Obama’s Anti-Business Tax Agenda Chasing Burger King to Canada
Burger King’s effort to acquire Tim Horton’s, a Canadian purveyor of coffee and doughnuts, is a good business decision, but its choice to locate corporate headquarters north of the border would be the direct result of President Obama’s anti-business tax policies.
Burger King is a well managed global enterprise with stores in nearly 100 countries, and half its profits earned abroad. Like rival McDonald’s, its sales are declining, as millennials turn away from hamburgers, and it is seeking other avenues to expand.
McDonald’s is getting into coffee—a high margin business—in a big way, and Tim Horton’s java knowledge offers Burger King the opportunity to do the same.
Also, Burger King could apply its knowledge of foreign franchising and restaurant regulations to expand Tim Horton’s limited global footprint, as rival Dunkin’ Brands is doing in Asia.
Simply, the U.S. federal corporate tax rate is 35 percent and applies to both Burger King’s domestic and overseas profits, whereas Canada’s rate is 15 percent and only applies to Tim Horton’s domestic sales.
In the second quarter of this year, Burger King’s federal and state income taxes were 24 percent of its operating costs and 34 percent of its profits. Locating in Canada would cut those figures by up to 25 percent.
No responsible CEO or corporate board could reasonably ignore those figures, and that’s why about 60 U.S. companies have completed or plan so called “tax inversions”—acquisitions or mergers with foreign companies that permit them to locate their tax address in a friendlier jurisdiction.
What American businesses actually pay in federal and state income taxes varies a lot, thanks to many exemptions, deductions and provisions to delay taxes on foreign earnings; however, the average combined U.S. and foreign tax burden on profits is about 30 percent, whereas the average for foreign rivals is about 23 percent.
Ohio Democratic Senator Sherrod Brown is calling for a boycott of Burger King, and Treasury Secretary Lew is busy crafting legislation for Congress to make tax inversions more difficult if not impossible.
If Congress doesn’t act, Lew is threatening to bypass Congress and make tax inversions illegal by “reinterpreting” tax laws—likely as suits the convenience of Obama’s political agenda.
And that’s the more fundamental point. The U.S. tax system has become both burdensome and quite arbitrary—a political tool that presidents of both parties may use to reward friends and punish enemies.
A 2013 study undertaken by a European think tank ranked the United States 94th out of 100, right after Zimbabwe, for its impact on business competitiveness. No wonder the U.S. economy is not creating enough jobs.
In a recent example, the Treasury Department determined that telecommunications company copper and fiber optic transmission lines—think the wires on poles outside your home—are real estate, and may be placed in a special real estate investment trust that receives privileged tax treatment.
It is no accident that telecom companies, which are highly regulated entities, are big donors to the Democratic Party. In fact, the home of Comcast’s CEO is one of the president’s favorite fund raising venues.
Democrats and Republicans alike say they want corporate tax reform—eliminate loopholes and deductions and lower rates—but Obama has made clear he wants more revenue overall out of the exercise.
As Lew’s recent actions demonstrate, that will come down to burdening firms led by Republicans paying even higher taxes and dolling out advantages to industries whose management support the Democratic Party.
House Republicans will never go for that.
Nothing will change until we get a president with some understanding of business and a treasury secretary with some sense of shame.
Peter Morici is an economist and business professor at the University of Maryland, national columnist and five-time winner of the MarketWatch best forecaster award. He tweets @pmorici1
Robert H. Smith School of Business
University of Maryland
College Park, MD 20742-1815
703 549 4338
cell 240 429 7824
Recommended for You
Vanguard is the biggest fund company in the land, with more than $3 trillion in assets. Thirty-four Vanguard funds appear on a list of the 105 most popular mutual funds in employer-sponsored retirement savings plans. No other fund company comes close.KiplingerVWIAX $61.84 0.06%
Although the overall individual audit rate is only about one in 119, the odds increase dramatically as your income goes up, as it might if you sell a valuable piece of property or get a big payout from a retirement plan. The IRS wants to be sure that owners of IRAs and participants in 401(k)s and other workplace retirement plans are properly taking and reporting required minimum distributions.Kiplinger
Jim Cramer explains why Target's own self-cannibalization is the scariest of all for retail.CNBCTGT $63.93 0.13%
The Beretta will be replaced by the Sig Sauer P320 at a cost of about $580 million. Like the Italian-owned Beretta, Sig Sauer is foreign-owned (controlled by the privately held German company L&O Holding).The Fiscal Times
Ford Motor Co , in a bid for a piece of the rapidly growing global auto parts market, is launching a new brand called Omnicraft to sell parts to Ford dealers and independent repair shops to fix competitors' vehicles. Omnicraft joins Ford's established Motorcraft which makes parts for Ford vehicles. Frederiek Toney, president of Ford's customer service division, said the global business for automotive parts, which is now estimated at more than $500 billion, and service will expand by 70 percent in the next six years or so.ReutersF $12.54 1.83%
Retirement is a major milestone that brings many life changes. According to the Transamerica Center for Retirement Studies, the most frequently reported retirement worry is outliving savings and investments. Across all ages, 51% of respondents cited this concern, and 41% of retirees claim the same fear.Kiplinger
The Latest on President Donald Trump (all times local): 9 p.m. President Donald Trump is telling House and Senate leaders he would have won the popular vote in the 2016 election if not for the votes of ...Associated Press
They’re tax-beneficial, but you’ll need good luck and good health.MarketWatch q
Jan.22 -- Now that Donald Trump is in the White House, the world's biggest companies are trying to gauge the likelihood of a U.S. trade war with China. If the tension escalates, there could be losers on both sides. Bloomberg's Jeanny Yu reports on "Bloomberg Markets."Bloomberg Video
DryShips, Teva, Endo Pharma, and Gilead Sciences posted new 52-week lows Monday.24/7 Wall St.GILD $69.88 -1.15%
Last Friday, with his swearing-in as president of the United States, Donald Trump joined one of the most exclusive clubs in the world. At the same time that he become one of a handful of living people ever to sit in the Oval Office, he effectively inducted his entire family and all of his close associates into a different club, somewhat less exclusive and far less prestigious. As of Friday, the entire Trump family became what is known in international financial and law enforcement circles as “politically exposed persons,” or PEPs.The Fiscal Times
Jan.22 -- Nasser Saidi, president of Nasser Saidi & Associates, discusses President Donald Trump's relations with the Middle East. He speaks with Bloomberg's Yousef Gamal El-Din and Tracy Alloway on "Bloomberg Markets: Middle East."Bloomberg Video
BUCHAREST, Romania (AP) — Dan Adamescu, one of Romania's richest businessmen who was serving a prison sentence for bribery, has died. He was 68.Associated Press
Trump administration's health care changes could bring higher costs and more confusion, says Jennifer Fitzgerald.CNBC.com q
Shares in telecoms giant BT plunged by a fifth Tuesday after the London-based company warned of the cost of an accounting scandal at its Italian business and broad weakness in the global market. BT had ...Associated PressBT $19.32 -20.94%
Financial markets have not priced in a protectionist Donald Trump presidency, according to Goldman Sachs. Look at how quickly Asia's export-oriented companies have bounced back, "suggesting the market ...Barrons q
A watchdog group that had criticized Donald Trump during his time as president-elect over his failure to divest his business holdings has now greeted President Donald Trump with a federal lawsuit claiming that he is violating the Constitution by allowing his company to accept payments from foreign governments.The Fiscal Times
WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump has inherited a stable economy and a government that is on track to run a $559 billion budget deficit for the year, congressional analysts said Tuesday.Associated Press