This is a guest post written by Peter Morici. Peter is an economist and business professor at the University of Maryland, national columnist and five-time winner of the MarketWatch best forecaster award.
Obama’s Anti-Business Tax Agenda Chasing Burger King to Canada
Burger King’s effort to acquire Tim Horton’s, a Canadian purveyor of coffee and doughnuts, is a good business decision, but its choice to locate corporate headquarters north of the border would be the direct result of President Obama’s anti-business tax policies.
Burger King is a well managed global enterprise with stores in nearly 100 countries, and half its profits earned abroad. Like rival McDonald’s, its sales are declining, as millennials turn away from hamburgers, and it is seeking other avenues to expand.
McDonald’s is getting into coffee—a high margin business—in a big way, and Tim Horton’s java knowledge offers Burger King the opportunity to do the same.
Also, Burger King could apply its knowledge of foreign franchising and restaurant regulations to expand Tim Horton’s limited global footprint, as rival Dunkin’ Brands is doing in Asia.
Simply, the U.S. federal corporate tax rate is 35 percent and applies to both Burger King’s domestic and overseas profits, whereas Canada’s rate is 15 percent and only applies to Tim Horton’s domestic sales.
In the second quarter of this year, Burger King’s federal and state income taxes were 24 percent of its operating costs and 34 percent of its profits. Locating in Canada would cut those figures by up to 25 percent.
No responsible CEO or corporate board could reasonably ignore those figures, and that’s why about 60 U.S. companies have completed or plan so called “tax inversions”—acquisitions or mergers with foreign companies that permit them to locate their tax address in a friendlier jurisdiction.
What American businesses actually pay in federal and state income taxes varies a lot, thanks to many exemptions, deductions and provisions to delay taxes on foreign earnings; however, the average combined U.S. and foreign tax burden on profits is about 30 percent, whereas the average for foreign rivals is about 23 percent.
Ohio Democratic Senator Sherrod Brown is calling for a boycott of Burger King, and Treasury Secretary Lew is busy crafting legislation for Congress to make tax inversions more difficult if not impossible.
If Congress doesn’t act, Lew is threatening to bypass Congress and make tax inversions illegal by “reinterpreting” tax laws—likely as suits the convenience of Obama’s political agenda.
And that’s the more fundamental point. The U.S. tax system has become both burdensome and quite arbitrary—a political tool that presidents of both parties may use to reward friends and punish enemies.
A 2013 study undertaken by a European think tank ranked the United States 94th out of 100, right after Zimbabwe, for its impact on business competitiveness. No wonder the U.S. economy is not creating enough jobs.
In a recent example, the Treasury Department determined that telecommunications company copper and fiber optic transmission lines—think the wires on poles outside your home—are real estate, and may be placed in a special real estate investment trust that receives privileged tax treatment.
It is no accident that telecom companies, which are highly regulated entities, are big donors to the Democratic Party. In fact, the home of Comcast’s CEO is one of the president’s favorite fund raising venues.
Democrats and Republicans alike say they want corporate tax reform—eliminate loopholes and deductions and lower rates—but Obama has made clear he wants more revenue overall out of the exercise.
As Lew’s recent actions demonstrate, that will come down to burdening firms led by Republicans paying even higher taxes and dolling out advantages to industries whose management support the Democratic Party.
House Republicans will never go for that.
Nothing will change until we get a president with some understanding of business and a treasury secretary with some sense of shame.
Peter Morici is an economist and business professor at the University of Maryland, national columnist and five-time winner of the MarketWatch best forecaster award. He tweets @pmorici1
Robert H. Smith School of Business
University of Maryland
College Park, MD 20742-1815
703 549 4338
cell 240 429 7824
Recommended for You
It's going to get ugly in the bond market soon, and there are a few companies that have more...Business Insider
It's not an ideal time to buy Harley Davidson stock, according to technical analysis, no matter what the deal rumors say.The Street
It’s sadly fitting that in a year when the likely presidential nominees for the two major parties are both as widely disliked as Democrat Hillary Clinton and Republican Donald Trump, the presence of a plausible challenger from a third party has no effect on the race because supporters leave the two…The Fiscal Times
If you're using Windows 10 Home but missing some of the features found in the Pro edition, it might be time to upgrade. Here are the steps to make it happen.TechRepublic
A digital video disc player was found in the Tesla car that was on autopilot when its driver was killed in a collision with a truck in May, Florida Highway Patrol officials said on Friday. "There was a portable DVD player in the vehicle," said Sergeant Kim Montes of the FHP in a telephone…Reuters
ROME (AP) — A crackdown by Italian authorities on the increasingly powerful Chinese community in Tuscany resulted in new searches Friday in Italy's Chinatown and clashes this week that drew the ire of China's Foreign Ministry.Associated Press
CNBC's Courtney Reagan has details of a takeover bid report for Harley-Davidson. The FMHR traders, and Stephanie Link, TIAA Global Asset Management, discuss the likelihood of this deal with KKR.CNBC Videos
We knew that before Microsoft paid $26 billion for LinkedIn, the social network was also...Business Insider
Jim Cramer will be ready for stocks to make a bang next week when this big, bad number is reported.CNBC
SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — Gov. Jerry Brown signed six stringent gun-control measures Friday that will require people to turn in high-capacity magazines and mandate background checks for ammunition sales, as California Democrats seek to strengthen gun laws that are already among the strictest in the…Associated Press
Stock splits: the dog whistles from companies that coming news is constructive, even though splits don't change stock value.The Street
You may owe money, but you still have rights. Know what's illegal.Investopedia
Stocks will have a terrific second half of the year, the strategist predicts. He makes the case for an 11 percent rally.CNBC.com
Fallout from disclosure of former President Bill Clinton’s ill-advised informal chat with Attorney General Loretta E. Lynch on an airport tarmac in Phoenix, Arizona, earlier this week came swiftly on Friday. Lynch announced that she was effectively taking herself out of the chain of command in…The Fiscal Times
Marc Faber, The Gloom, Boom & Doom Report, and Frank Berlage, Multilateral Partners Global Advisory, look at risks lurking in the markets.CNBC Videos
Despite Brexit upheaval and stock market losses, U.S. real estate market appears on much more solid footing in 2016MarketWatch
How high of a credit score do you need to get a home mortgage or buy a car? Read on for some actual numbers.Investopedia
Matt and Jessica Johnson were the typical American couple — until they sold everything and hit the open waters.CNBC