Was ‘owning the index’ a good idea in 2000, when ~50% of the S&P 500 was in tech?
Was ‘owning the index’ a good idea in 2008, when 40% of the S&P 500 was in financials?
No, of course it wasn’t.
I’m not here to defend active fund managers, who notoriously and consistently have underperformed the S&P 500.
And I”m not here to say that active fund managers are about to go on a big winning streak vs. the index (as the math just doesn’t work, unless active fund management fees suddenly go to ZERO).
What I am here to say is that when “everybody” knows something, it’s usually a good time to head in the opposite direction. And what “everybody” knows now is that the very best, smartest investment you can make is an index fund.
The conventional wisdom around indexing explains why Vanguard now has nearly $3 trillion in assets and the Vanguard Total Return Stock Market Index (VTI) is now the world’s largest mutual fund, tipping the scales at over $343 billion.
In sum, “active fund management is outmoded, and a lot of stock pickers are going to have to find something else to do for a living,” as WSJ columnist Jason Zweig recently declared.
Zweig also said the debate over active vs. passing investing is “over”, which (again) should make you stop and think about the questions posed at the top of this piece.
It should also make you think again about what happened to Fidelity Contrafund and Pimco Total’s Return fund after they became the largest mutual funds. If VTI suffers the same fate, that would of course mean “the market” will have a rough go ahead, which is exactly what Shiller’s CAPE and other valuation metrics suggest (although CAPE has its flaws and is much better at forecasting long- vs. short-term returns).
I stand behind what I said during a debate on this issue last December: “The pendulum has swung way too far where everyone thinks all you have to do is index and you’re going to do better. When everyone is on the same side as the boat there is a reversion to the mean.”
And what that would mean is a revival of the idea that there’s a place for old-fashioned stock picking vs. passive indexing.
A parting thought: In the past few weeks, stories have been written about what a $10,000 investment in Apple 10 years ago is worth today ($456,000) or buying Google’s IPO ($139,500)- and those aren’t even the best-performers of the past decade.
For another POV on active vs passive, check out this NYT interview with Bob Olstein, whose namesake fund has outperformed over long period, He says ‘the rise of index funds is part of a trend toward sloppy investing — a willingness to follow the herd’
Recommended for You
If a dud gift isn't bad enough, some stores make it difficult to return an unwanted present-especially if you don't have a gift receipt.CNBC
Some dividend stocks deliver both growth and income. Here are some top picks for the new year.TheStreet.com
When Olga Savelyeva took out a $226,000 mortgage to buy a small apartment on the outskirts of Moscow in 2008, she could never have imagined that the ruble would lose more than half its value in a few short years. In a letter to central bank chief Elvira Nabiullina, the group threatened a "powerful…AFP
Your retirement spending could be lower than you think. Here are some ideas for reducing the amount of money you'll need for a lifestyle you enjoy.Credit.com
Check Out The 2015 Hyundai® Sonata - Totally Redesigned With Class-Exclusive Technology, Advanced Safety Features & Backed By America's Best Warranty
Many investors are looking for where to put their money now that the Dow Jones Industrial Average has hit 18,000.24/7 Wall St.
The good, bad and ugly of 401(k) plans. Mad Money's Jim Cramer explores retirement investing options.CNBC Videos
Wal-Mart Stores Inc. (WMT) is about to hike wages of its workers in 2015, according to an internal memo examined by Reuters earlier this month. The wage hike will come into effect in 21 U.S. states on or around Jan 1, 2015 and will impact around 1400 stores.Zacks
These companies are survivors. Once the price of crude oil stops sliding, their shares will take off.Kiplinger
You take way too long to sell your losers.USA TODAY
Take note: Don't get yourself fired, period, whether it's before or after a mortgage is finalized.USA TODAY
MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — Minnesota's Pohlad family has acquired majority ownership of Polaroid in a $70 million deal.Associated Press
FM trader Brian Kelly outlines reasons to buy gold going into 2015. Tim Seymour disagrees with the commodity's bull case.CNBC Videos
WASHINGTON (AP) — If Hillary Rodham Clinton seeks the White House again, her message on the economy could be an important barometer as she courts fellow Democrats.Associated Press
Umbrella insurance can save your retirement or college-savings nest egg from disaster.USA TODAY
HAVANA (AP) — A half-century after Washington severed relations with Cuba, the United States' seven-story mission looms over Havana's seaside Malecon boulevard as the largest diplomatic outpost in the country.Associated Press
(Bloomberg) -- Saira Malik, a managing director at TIAA-CREF Investment Management, talks about the outlook for small-cap stocks in 2015, including Crown Holdings Inc. and Costco Wholesale Corp. She speaks ...Bloomberg
Promising pipeline candidates, progress on the regulatory front and interesting research platforms helped these 4 biotech stocks stand out in 2014.Zacks