Below is a Tumblr post by my pal Jeff Carter.
I have been a member of the CME in one capacity or another since May of 1988. I was on the board. I was one of the guys that turned the place around and we IPO’ed in 2002.
I don’t really trade anymore and don’t need the seat. I had it leased out for monthly income, and lease values plummeted. The value of the seat went higher, and then dropped from $300k where I bought it to a low of $160k in 2012. At the beginning of this year, they were just over $200k, and that is when I decided to scratch it. I offered at $300k and waited.
The Federal Reserve hasn’t been kind to traders. No volatility means they can’t make money and that has depressed the value of seats. Additionally, CME management has actively worked to depress seat values. This year, they had a ballot initiative on their proxy that I lead the fight against, and won.
A number of years ago, I presented some folks at CME a plan to buy out the seats with common shares. I showed how the corresponding change in fees would more than pay for the dilution in 3-5 years. CME management wasn’t interested.
Interestingly, they aren’t interested in a lot of innovation at CME. Just preserving their vertical silo. Their stock price since 2007 reflects that. A bloated 38 member board that is now a tad under 30 people-remember they are a publicly traded corporation!
In 2011, I presented the idea of a corporate VC fund at CME. It’s now 2014, and they are getting one off the ground. That’s the speed at which they work these days. The board is indicative of the fleet footedness of the company. CME is centrally planned and a hierarchy.
Some old members think memberships are undervalued. They might be, but the market is telling you something different. In the last banking crisis, memberships fell out of bed, along with the CME stock price. What happens when European banks default? Because it’s going to happen, just a question of time.
I feel a little naked without a membership. Memberships become a part of you. But, I am glad I don’t have it anymore. I don’t care if they trade $1M, or $0. With the risk/reward, and the dedicated headwinds against them, I’d rather risk the $300k in a startup than an organization that doesn’t understand the megatrends that are remaking every business in the world.
Recommended for You
Jim Cramer gives his opinion of caller favorite stocks at rapid speed, including this oil stock that already bottomed.CNBC
NEW YORK (AP) — The Titanic's last lunch menu — saved by a passenger who climbed aboard the so-called "Money Boat" before the ocean liner went down — is going to auction, where it's estimated it will bring $50,000 to $70,000.Associated Press
Technical analysis shows Bank of America shares are headed for a long slide. Get out of the stock while you still have the chance.TheStreet.com
It's been a bad month for stocks. Here's how bad.USA TODAY
Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Alex Smith, now three years removed from throwing his last pass for the San Francisco 49ers, has put his home in Monte Sereno, Calif., on the market for $3.999 million.Los Angeles Times
By Robert Gibbons NEW YORK (Reuters) - Oil futures soared on Monday for a third consecutive day, rising more than 8 percent, as a downward revision of U.S. crude production data and OPEC's readiness to talk with other producers helped extend the biggest three-day price surge in 25 years. U.S. crude…Reuters
Hendricks accused StarKist of intentionally underfilling its 5 ounce cans of tuna. Although StarKist has denied any wrongdoing, the company did agree to pay $8 million in cash and $4 million in tuna vouchers to consumers to settle the Hendricks v. StarKist Co. lawsuit. Some StarKist tuna eaters…Money Talks News
CNBC's Jim Cramer says he doesn't know where the positive sentiment is coming from for the market.CNBC Videos
Do this, and you’ll never look at a $5 bill the same again.Money
Global markets once had faith in China’s policy makers to manage its economy and markets, but now the image of Beijing is one of incompetence in the face of financial crisis, writes Craig Stephen.MarketWatch
Tom Vucurevich, heir to a banking fortune, can't repay millions owed to creditors.USA TODAY
In the run-up to the August recess, congressional lawmakers for and against the Iran nuclear deal girded themselves for a potentially bruising, weeks-long break. Democrats had good reason to be concerned about being put in the cross-hairs over the potentially historic deal. In 2009, with Obamacare…The Fiscal Times
According to a recent poll, Donald Trump is leading the GOP pack by a large number. Ben White, Politico chief economic correspondent, weighs in on the Republican presidential field and whether Hillary Clinton's email controversy will hurt her campaign.CNBC Videos
Most of the time, it makes sense for couples to file their taxes jointly. Except for these possible exceptions...Investopedia
According to a Bloomberg report, industrial goods manufacturer General Electric Company (GE) has shelved its plans to shift the corporate headquarters from Fairfield, CT to Dallas, TX.Zacks
While the broader markets have been both down and up, some quality stocks are still way down, including recent Icahn buy Freeport-McMoRan (FCX), Micron Technology (MU) and many others.TheStreet.com
Last week was a heck of a week in the global markets. On Monday, it looked like the world was...Business Insider
Big changes are coming to both credit scores and credit reports – some as soon as September. Here's a guide to what's coming up and how it could affect you.Credit.com
As the cost of college continues to rise, reconsider some of these expendable expenses.Kiplinger